I did nt understand , Why we divide the india.. if u guys go abroad, what u will say i am from maharashtra or uttar pradesh.. No u will i am india,, The Way Raj sir is dealing ,,Australians who is hitting our Innocent students they are doing right. U should protest for something but u cant hurt some one..Lot of maharashtrain family stays outside of maharashtra,,,Then they too are not safe,, we Should progress Look further..we are going BAck... Raj Sir one suggestion Set up a company which produce crore of job and give them job their rather then hitting some one..
Re: Chk this out
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 12:06 PM
Abu Azmi is stoking the fires of Hindi regionalism. After staying in MH for so long, he still does not bother to learn Marathi - the state's official language. Shame on him.
and great job... MNS. keep it up! Such divisive regional antinational forces who want to impose Hindi hegemony should be opposed.
Re: Re: Chk this out
by asheesh mishra on Nov 02, 2009 01:06 PM
abu is man of dawood every body knos.He know how to divide natialist forces & establish mighal tule in india
Re: Re: Chk this out
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:05 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis. Any way your objection to Hindi is because it came from URDU? URDU is also a native Indian language.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Chk this out
by asheesh mishra on Nov 02, 2009 01:09 PM
Are u a muzzellem.You know how his community has ruled in india by creating caste & language divide among nationalist forces.You are trying it again
Re: Re: Re: Chk this out
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 12:10 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Chk this out
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:12 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control their migration to other developed states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
They are a big burden to other Indian states and are simply swallowing majority of tax money collected from other indian states.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Chk this out
by Prateek Jain on Nov 02, 2009 12:34 PM
One third of the entire city of Varanasi is lived in by Marathis. The shop signs, the advertisements, even the language of common-talk is Marathi there. In fact, the area has come to be called Mini-Maharashtra. As per your logic, this is an attempt of imperialist nature by Marathis to gain "control" of Varanasi?
Dude, grow a brain. Raj Thackeray is interested in power and power alone. About 5 years ago, RT had a smaller non political "sangh" where-in he encouraged poor people from ANY background (Marathi, UP-ites, whatever) to become entrepreneurs. This same man, now, in the quest for power is involved in divisive politics of language. I had great respect for him back then, but now, I feel disappointed - he's just as bad as his uncle.
Sure, Abu Azmi is no better. He is just as bad and doing the same thing.
As a thinking and educated population, Indians must make the choice to reject divisive politcs. Till we dont, we will continue to have people like RT and Abu Azmi running the show.
if Maharastra people prefer only Marathi, then go on guys and make movies in marathi only. then watch the results how many of them get sucess.... As Mumbai is in Maharastra where Bollywood Head Quaters is located.
Re: then why Bollywood movies in Hindi
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:12 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control their migration to other developed states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
They are a big burden to other Indian states and are simply swallowing majority of tax money collected from other indian states.
Re: Re: then why Bollywood movies in Hindi
by asheesh mishra on Nov 02, 2009 01:09 PM
Are u a muzzellem.You know how his community has ruled in india by creating caste & language divide among nationalist forces.You are trying it again
There is no concept of national language defined in the India's Constitution. India's Constitution defines 22 official languages with Hindi being just one of them.
Start saying Jai Bharat instead of Jai Hind. Hindi bhashis misunderstand that saying Jai Hind means saying Jai Hindi giving rise to their misconception that their mother tongue Hindi is the national language.
Re: Misconception of Hndi being the national language
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:06 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis.
Re: Re: Misconception of Hndi being the national language
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:10 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control migration to other states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
Re: Re: Misconception of Hndi being the national language
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 04:48 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
Hindi is our national language? Its one of the odd 30 languages scheduled in our constitution. Nothing official about it.More than half the country dont speak Hindi.The Hindi mongers argue that since its spoken by maximum number of people in India ,so it should be officially declared as National language.In that logic, our national bird should be crow and our national animal should be stray dogs eh?
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by prashant michael on Nov 02, 2009 10:44 AM
Have guts...come up with your real name.....hard hitter....then we can respond on your comment....dont use proxy to create hatred.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 04:48 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:08 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 04:48 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:08 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by murli nair on Nov 02, 2009 12:43 PM
then the article 343(1) should be changed and there should be no official languages imposed on unwilling people/
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Pehelwan on Nov 02, 2009 10:55 AM
Nobody is imposing Hindi on any body.Abu Azmi asked for Hindi translation of the documents.Whats wrong with that.In Loksabha, you can ask for the documents in any Indian Language.The MP's are free to speak in their regional Language.So why an issue is being made out of Azmi's request.Maharashtra is not a country.It is part of India.National Interest comes first.A false sense of regional pride is being propogated by the likes of MNS .He is playing into the game Plan of China.China has officialy declared that they plan to stoke regional fires in India.MNS and the likes fit perfectly in China's scheme of destabilising India.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 11:05 AM
Abu Azmi is stoking the fires of Hindi regionalism. After staying in MH for so long, he still does not bother to learn Marathi - the state's official language. Shame on him.
and great job... MNS. keep it up! Such divisive regional antinational forces who want to impose Hindi hegemony should be opposed.
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Sameer Kadawala on Nov 02, 2009 10:57 AM
Very nicely put forward the logic. Even Hindi-bhashi try to speak in English whenever possible. Basically there is no such language as Hindi. Derivation of the word Hindi itself has a history like Urdu, it is a word floated by Yawans just similar to Bollywood where there is no Bolly or Wood. Actually the languages are Bhojpuri, Hariyanvi, Marwari, etc.
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:07 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 04:49 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by Narendra Modi on Nov 02, 2009 12:07 PM
Article 343(1)states "The Official Language of the Union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script." And that English could be also used for official purposes. However, attempts would be made increase the scope of Hindi in official matters on a gradual basis.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:11 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control their migration to other developed states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
They are a big burden to other Indian states and are simply swallowing majority of tax money collected from other indian states.
Re: Re: HINDI-Nothing official about it !
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 04:49 PM
read again carefully... Hindi and English are the languages that the Central Govt can communicate with. It is not the official language of the Union. There is no concept of National language defined for India, only official languages.
Hindi is just one of the 22 official languages of the Indian Union as per the 8th Schedule of the Constitution and the section on formation of linguistic states. States are free to choose their official languages. MH has chosen Marathi as the official language.
btw, I have no objection to Urdu being the official language of UP.
How a person who does not even know that India does not have a national language became a MLA. Marathi people should first ask that MLA to go through our constitution to know about language policy of our country. He should also be reminded that Hindi too is a foreign language for south indians.
Re: Shame on this MLA
by prashant michael on Nov 02, 2009 10:53 AM
Mr. Vijay T, That means you dont understand the language on your passport. The intellectual maturity of yours is so low that you have categorised Hindi as Foreign Language. This is sense of feeling develops in the society who learn to live only in racial cohesiveness & lacks the ability to merge with other communities.
Re: Re: Shame on this MLA
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:13 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control their migration to other developed states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
They are a big burden to other Indian states and are simply swallowing majority of tax money collected from other indian states.
Re: Re: Shame on this MLA
by howudoudo on Nov 02, 2009 11:07 AM
what he means is if Hindi bhashis consider non-Hindi languages as foreign languages, then south indians have equal rights to consider hindi as foreign langugae
Anyway the state's official language is Marathi, not Hindi.
Re: Re: Shame on this MLA
by murli nair on Nov 02, 2009 12:46 PM
forcing hindi on unwilling people will only antagoinse them further. dont stoke hatred among people with useless things like language, relegions etc. language is simply a means to convey thought not a conquering weapon.
Re: Re: Shame on this MLA
by Vijay T on Nov 02, 2009 10:47 PM
Mr. Prashant
I am not sure why you didnt question the intellectual maturity of that MLA who declared English as foreign language. If it comes to the ability to merge with other communities - then no language should be considered foreign. That MLA should have by now learnt some Marathi from where he is getting elected. If you think English is foreign because it was just a left over from british - then pls understand - so do is the concept of India - just don't fool urself by assuming everything foreign is bad and should be discarded.
The 2 useless politician are wasting tax payers money fighting over trivial issue. But why are we debating whether assembly should be conducted in Hindi or Marathi. We are wasting our precious saturday evening discussing something over which we don't have control. Guys stop posting your opinion and use your time more effectively
Re: stop this...
by dirty on Nov 02, 2009 12:13 PM
First of all Hindi people should control their population, they should control their migration to other developed states and should develop themselves as they are dragging the growth of whole India.
They are a big burden to other Indian states and are simply swallowing majority of tax money collected from other indian states.
Re: We want English to be the Link Language, Say No to Hindi
by asheesh mishra on Nov 02, 2009 01:11 PM
Are u a muzzellem.You know how his community has ruled in india by creating caste & language divide among nationalist forces.You are trying it again
Re: We want English to be the Link Language, Say No to Hindi
by murli nair on Nov 02, 2009 12:48 PM
they already have. no language should be seen as superior to another. Let us just have English as the link language and leave it at that, nobody will object and no acrimony and it will make us even more competitive in the world.
Re: Solution: No need of any National Language, English is the Li
by Cool Mahesh on Nov 01, 2009 09:56 PM
Don't worry! Non-Hindi speaking people will fight tooth & nail against making Hindi the national language. This will never happen.
