The irresposible Mamta and her cronies wud like to see Bengal ... as it was in 1970's ,,, absolute anarchy ,,,Jobless youths turning Naxals,,, THIS IS A BIG CONSPIRACY by a section of vested interest ,, MAMATA SPEARHEADING ,,,TURNING THEM INTO REALTY,,, Bengal is well establised in agriculture,,, the natural progression is towards industrialization ,,, PROVEN MODEL WORLDWIDE... MAMTA,,, a dangerous and suicidal evil,,, She is pushing Bengal ,, to become another Bihar ,, cheap and exploitable labour for all the places in the country... if not already there,,,, BONGS are emotional fools ,,, very self destructive ,,,, swayed by mean ppl,,, How can the innocent Farmers murder cop and ppl ,,, bomb check post ,,, AGAIN ,,, a part of bigger conspiracy ,,,, few innocent ppl put as a showcase and crime done frm behind ,,, LOOK AT THE WEALTH AND PROSPERITY OF GURGAON - NOIDA - PUNE %u2013 CHENNAI ( the list is endless ) ,,,unfortunately nothing percolates to Calcutta,,,, Why MAMTA doesn%u2019t raise her voice against Unemployment and poverty ,,, her energy goes fr stopping the ways of wealth creation and prosperity ,,,, few Intellectuals ( sic!! ) r driven by a lobby working overtime against Bengal. WHEN INDIA WUD B ENJOYING D FRUITS OF GROWTH ,,, Bengal wud look like a Temple of DOOM,,,GUD LUCK BENGAL
RE:BEWARE !!!!!
by Indraneel Banerjee on Mar 19, 2007 05:29 PM
Its GOOD not GUD. I assume you are not a Bengali or have any knowledge of Bengal and first hand Eastern Indian history. You talk non sense anyway.
RE:BEWARE !!!!!
by Surojit Chatterjee on Mar 19, 2007 05:10 PM
Never mind Allen, we dont need ur comments.Work for the good of ur state.YOu dont have a first hand knowledge.So keep quiet.We are not discussing economic models, we are discussing deaths and the pros and cons.
Tell me one thing....how many people would be employed in a car factory?? What will happen to the farmers whose land are gone ? Will they find employment ? Tata requires an area 6 times that of maruti's Gurgao plant with 6 times more land ... What will happen in the rest of the land...May be used as real estate for the tata's... What did Salim Group did in indonesia?? It finished the indonesian communists and is under prosecution there , and here communists are supporting him !!!.....Now he wants to open a chemical hub in nandigram....Is it known that chemical hubs are banned in European Countries the so called "developed nations". Sulphuric acid is so toxic it is not produced by any of the developed countries but in haldia it is only made....Is it sufficient or I need to write more...I can write a few more pages if u insist....
RE:Read the facts ....
by allen on Mar 19, 2007 05:30 PM
deep talukdar... An automobile Unit is highly manpower itensive unlike process industries... It comes along wid a big pack of anciliaries ..which again generate huge employment.. a rough estimate wud b like ...to roll our 5 lac vehicles a year ... one wud require at least ten thousand ppl working frm all front... PLZ NOTE ..MARUTI doesnt hv a closed complex of ancilliaries which TATA's are planning...if u put all d ancilliaries into account ..MARUTI has more dan double ...wat TATA wud get... U MAY B IGNORANT ...CONSULT A AUTO EXPERT...
RE:[object]
by abby Das on Mar 26, 2007 06:07 PM
One more thing i must say.generating employment for 8000 - 10,000(at most) the tatas are taking 997 acres of multicropped land.Do you have any idea how many people they would be making unemployed?
RE:Read the facts ....
by abby Das on Mar 26, 2007 06:05 PM
well,Allen,I have a relative who works for Hyundai.(I hope you would consider as an expert). To produce 5 lacs vehicle a year one would require not more than 8,000 wrokers(Your estimation was wrong in the very first place).Secondly,what ancillery units are you talking about exactly?Have the Tatas cleared mentioned the details anywhere?Have they quantifiesd the number of people exactly who would be getting jobs in those industries?How much land exactly(in quantitaive terms) would they erquire for each ancillery units?
If you have these answers please clarify them first .Or else admit that you are ignorent too.
This leftist party once agitated against computers,agitated against english language.The same party is today becoming the slave of industrialists,calling the IT sectors where both computers and english are needed.This party is only capable of doing "Secret Trade" to fill up their own pockets and when they face any opposition they just know to shoot and kill people.That is the reason till today the killer of Tuhin samanto still roaming free.
Sincere request to you NOT to resign. You are the first among so many to take the issue of all round development of West Bengal in your stride and we are proud of you. We know you live in a small apartment and you do not ENJOY the THRONE as some people want us to believe. The whole issue of Singoor and Nandigram is the brainchild of a handful of people involved in every possible nefarious activity they can manage to perform to tarnish the image of the CPI-M led government and in particular you. They are afraid of the popularity of the government and you and will leave no stone unturned to tarnish the state's image to others. The ulterior motive is to gain some more seats in the next elections. People realize this and they will ensure there will be no TC members in the next state assembly. Please continue with your developmental work for the state.
RE:On Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 05:10 PM
Development or destruction?After so many deaths you still can't see destruction?(Actually none of your own have died).In Singur case the only point was "Secret Trdae" where Nirupom Sen was also a partner of our HONEST CM.and how can you say about popularity when the opposition gets 49.6% votes while the CPM party alone doesn't even get 40% votes and you speak about popularity?
RE:RE:On Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 19, 2007 05:22 PM
well we would like to be optimist than be pessimist..in the last 7 years we have seen Kolkata and Bengal developing..though we condemn the death of farmers in Nandigram we cannot take credit of resurggent bengal from Buddhadev..and we still have faith in him..he is genuinely working for the development of the state..all these talk of "blood in the hands " etc crap are just romantic word of intellectuals who have just debated over years as what needs to be done and never done anything..no wonder bengal is lagging today..these ppl feel that a farmers son wants to be a farmer..plz understand..if Bengal has to develop we need Buddhadeb.
RE:RE:RE:On Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 05:55 PM
Ritwick
Thank you for answering me.You said in last 7 years you have seen Kolkata Developing.Do you have any idea how many tea gardens closed donw in the last 7 years?Why still people at Amlashol dies of Hunger during the last 7 years?
Why Police has become so desperate that a OC can shoot a citizen and still roam free?This happened during last 7 months(not years) and our CM forgets his own words "Do it now".He says 96% of farmers of singur has given their land willingly while the Govt could only give documents of 30% willing farmers.(This is within last 7 months,not 7 years).The court ordered during book fair that the Govt tried all means to make farud to keep the book fair at the maidan.(This is also during the last 7 months).Do you still want our CM to stay and let the court harras him for all his lies?If he has got self respect then he should leave by his own immidiately.
RE:On Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by Sanjay Ranawat on Mar 19, 2007 06:03 PM
Do you need any more proof of BB's poor policies & the double standards of Communists. They should be thrown out of this country.
RE:On Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by S on Mar 20, 2007 07:43 AM
These situations are just the tip of the iceberg. In every street and every town, every village and every hamlet of West Bengal, freedom is being raped by the Police-Party-Promoter coalition. The said development of the last few years are nothing but some real estate sharks making money. West Bengal has crores of unemployed poeple and beggars, all due to false policies of CPM. Whatever happening today is just a method of excating contracts out of massive real estate operation by some mafias and arraneging cut-money for the CPM leaders and their families. Buddha is a head strong person at his core. He is not fit for running a large and varied populace. He must go.
A CM who lies left and right should resign for just that reson only.When Mr Binoy Kongar thretened to make the life of people in Nandigram "Hell" this useless CM did not react.It was well anticipated what Mr Binoy Kongar wanted.Our CM said in TV channel that "There would be no policing in Nandigram" and after that ordered the police to be the cause of so many deaths.He is the greatest shame of our state.
RE:Any more douts?
by rana mitra on Mar 19, 2007 05:03 PM
BUDHHA SHOULD STAY
Yes nandigram is a deplorable incident but that doesnot mean he will have to resign and industrialization has to stop, only to satisfy some marxist hardliners and some stupid intellectuals who have done nothing for Bengal. The industrialization should continue and BUDDHA is doing the right thing.
RE:RE:Any more douts?
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 05:21 PM
If Budhdha stays then our state would just be like Bangkok where people come,have fun with local girls and go away while the leaders are busy doing "Secret Trade".
For the last few years West Bengal has been lagging behind as because of Industry. Now Chief Minister Buddhadev Bhattacharjee is trying to do somthing for West Bengal which seems a lot more pressure for other ruling parties. Mamata on the other hand has done nothing for West Bengal except aggitation and number of Bandh's . So, Chief Minister Buddhadev Bhattacharjee must go on with his plan which he dreams for his state.
RE:Carry on Mr Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 04:54 PM
Yes...carry on Budhdha...carry on with all your lies,your "Secret Trades" and brutality.A handfull of people would always support you beacuse you have passed down a portion of your "Secret Trade" to them.They can be purchased very cheaply.
RE:Carry on Mr Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by rabi banerjee on Mar 19, 2007 05:03 PM
Yes, Mr Bhattcahrjee you should carry on even if you have lost a seizable supporters of Bengal. But how should we forget that you are very few reasonable communists left in India who understands importance of industrialisation. we cannot forget your predecessor had destroyed a generation in the name of socialisim and communism. You must carry on, but for god sake be suave, dont shout always that i have 230. from Ratul
RE:Carry on Mr Buddhadev Bhattacharjee
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:14 PM
West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee should accept moral responsibility for the andigram violence and quit. "In the eyes of the law, those who committed the crime are criminals and those who abetted it are also criminals. Chief Minister had sent the police and party cadres to Nandigram and ordered them to fire. You are behind the operation and you also ordered the arrests. You have taken the responsibility for the incident. The case has been proven against you. You must resign. If you do not, not only Bengal but the whole world will condemn you,"
At least ten Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) workers have been arrested and illegal arms seized after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) started its investigation into the causes behind the violence on the orders of the Calcutta High Court.
Well, caring and developing for the state is no harm. We all seen it past 30 years that there wass no Industry in Bengal but this Chief Minister is fighting all odds to make Bengal an Industrial hub. Other Political Parties dosen't want Bengal to rise. People are made fool in the name of land grabbing. The deaths occur due to the opposition party and not by our chief Minister's decision. So, if you want Bengal to rise, we have to support our Chief Minister. Opposition terming our Chief Minister as "Narendra Modi" dude.. did Narendra Modi took a respnsibility to himself after the deadly Gujrat Riots. The answer is "NO". But our Chief Minister accepted his mistakes n Nandigram. He is not killing people in the name of religion, well even people are killed.. only the media and opposition making it hue and cry. Long Live Buddhadeb Bhattacharjeee.
RE:Buddha Babu is the greatest CM in Bengal.
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:16 PM
West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee should accept moral responsibility for the andigram violence and quit. "In the eyes of the law, those who committed the crime are criminals and those who abetted it are also criminals. Chief Minister had sent the police and party cadres to Nandigram and ordered them to fire. You are behind the operation and you also ordered the arrests. You have taken the responsibility for the incident. The case has been proven against you. You must resign. If you do not, not only Bengal but the whole world will condemn you,"
At least ten Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) workers have been arrested and illegal arms seized after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) started its investigation into the causes behind the violence on the orders of the Calcutta High Court.In which apper did you heard or read that buddha babu had taken morale respomnsibility for killings dear.NO CHIEF MINISTER CAN TAKE THIS BUT INSIDE HE KNOWS WHAT WRONG HE HAD DONE.
RE:Buddha should not resign
by syed ilyas on Mar 19, 2007 05:17 PM
Buddha should not resign. Make Mamata Dy CM and a good portfolio She will co-operate to do any thing any Bengal.
RE:Buddha should not resign
by on Mar 19, 2007 04:56 PM
Dear Mr Rajat Basu, I appreciate your comment that Ms Mamata Banerjee is not protesting in the right manner, but please do not forget that Bengal the darling of industry in the 1960s have been systematically put into the back seat by the likes of patriach Jyoti Basu and his communist friends. Mr Bhattachrya is trying to get the act together the rut is so deep that it will take a few 30 years to come out of it. The only concern that I have is Bengal is trying to bulldoze things, which can be also obtained very amicably with the poor farmers being paid the right price.
RE:Buddha should not resign
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:49 PM
Actually...she want to thrive over under-development, unemployment in West Bengal...we will never let her do this...
RE:Buddha should not resign
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:17 PM
West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee should accept moral responsibility for the Nandigram violence and quit. "In the eyes of the law, those who committed the crime are criminals and those who abetted it are also criminals. Chief Minister had sent the police and party cadres to Nandigram and ordered them to fire. You are behind the operation and you also ordered the arrests. You have taken the responsibility for the incident. The case has been proven against you. You must resign. If you do not, not only Bengal but the whole world will condemn you,"
At least ten Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) workers have been arrested and illegal arms seized after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) started its investigation into the causes behind the violence on the orders of the Calcutta High Court.Be human first than cadre of communist.
how can running of a state be at the mercy of so called intellegentsia poets, film makers, writers all these big talk do not bring developmentonly so called laurel for thse people film festivals and booker prizes . show the world how poor we are. if the industrialists who bring development were asking for his resignation we would have understood. please separate culture and entertainment from the ground realities of econmics and development. buddhadev please carry on we need more of u
RE:what do these poets, film makers know abt economics of running state
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:50 PM
Buddhadev.....we all are with you !!!!!
RE:what do these poets, film makers know abt economics of running state
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:20 PM
so that very soon we all will be on streets ,stop supporting wrong please be brave enough to accept wrong is wrong.West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee should accept moral responsibility for the Nandigram violence and quit. "In the eyes of the law, those who committed the crime are criminals and those who abetted it are also criminals. Chief Minister had sent the police and party cadres to Nandigram and ordered them to fire. You are behind the operation and you also ordered the arrests. You have taken the responsibility for the incident. The case has been proven against you. You must resign. If you do not, not only Bengal but the whole world will condemn you,"
At least ten Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) workers have been arrested and illegal arms seized after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) started its investigation into the causes behind the violence on the orders of the Calcutta High Court.
