Yhis is very sad to the bangalis mainly for indians under whose leadership@guideleiness of UPA. Yhis is important hint to Andhra Rowdy/Nero rajasekhara reddy also. And also my deep condolence to bangali victims, Thaning uou
The fall out of Nandigram and Singur and other Land acqusitions for Industrial sectors created very bad image on present WB Ministry. Ministry totally failed to convince its own people before taking a final decision on this important issue since INDUSTRIAL LAND ACQUISTION on agriculrual land is totally unacceptable because, there are enough waste land available in WB. He has created a bad image on all SEZ projects due to his wrong doings and the resignation of WB Chief Minister will atleast give some help in reducing the present situation in Nandigram as well as other parts of the State, which have seen sporadic violence and protests.
RE:YES, HE SHOULD RESIGN IMMEDIATELY, EVEN THOUGH IT IS TOO LATE!!!
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:24 PM
hi...who had told you that it has crated a bad image....no we are happy that it has exposed the intensions of some people in opposition in West Bengal...they never never wants WB to progress....Regards...Tirtha
RE:RE:YES, HE SHOULD RESIGN IMMEDIATELY, EVEN THOUGH IT IS TOO LATE!!!
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 03:57 PM
Well Bosky. I would suggest to get your left lobe in the brain checked by some good doctor.Or maybe the problem is with your eyes because you still cann't see the bad image that has ruined the fate of WB.The partners in the left front can see it but you can't.People all around the world can see it by you cann't.the intellectuals can see it but you cann't(YOu can just see tghe opposition).the journalists can see it but you can't(You can just see opposition). actually you belong to that class of people whom this leftist Govt has brainwashed for the last 30 years.They have become robots and have lost their own logics and thinking power.BUt one thing can make you regain your own thinking power.That would be the day when someone very dear to you would be lost due to bullet injury.You will not speak of any development that day rather would come out on the road like others alreday have to dethrone budhdha.
When a person(mainly if he is economically poor) kills someone then he is a murderer.
When a celebraty kills someone then it is an accident,-as Navjyot singh Sidhu.
When Politicians kill a few people then it is just an incident.
But why law shd be like this????????????
Politicians and socially powerfull person shd get extreme punishment for this kind of incidents. Celebraties shd get punishment in less than politicians for the same incident. And one poor common fellow shd get lesser punishment than celebraties. But no one will support it as poor common fellows has lost the strenghth to speak long bk.
RE:Buddhadeb shd resign
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:21 PM
hi...dont get emotional...ur going emotional wont feed lakhs of unemployed youths in West Bengal...pls give some rock hard reason for the CM's resignation....Regards...Tirtha
RE:RE:Buddhadeb shd resign
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 04:58 PM
NO 1- The factory set up by tata can be step just on opp road of same land(thogh it not cultivation), without disturbing farmers.The Tata will set up factory which will be fully automatic & employemnt created over their will be hardly 500 person & only peons & stewrards will be from bengal rest engineeers will be of mumbai or chennai. Reason number 2- The killing of innocent in nadigram itself shows that he is not human being at any cost he wants industrilization because of not development because his govt had taken money fro tatas & salim . be human first than cpim cadre ok.
I am geartly distressed about the current massacre that took place. nevertheless please do not forget what Budhhadeb has done for Bengal single handedly during last few years. We , who stayed outside this state knew the plight of Bengal, used to feel pity for my state. No industry, no new project - others only used to point out the negative sides of Kolkata and Bengal. This is the first time Bengal is being projected as a promising state. Our CM is not alone responsible for this mayhem, Local administartion to be blamed squarely as they did not give proper feedback. As a Head of the state he has to take the responsibility but he , like any CEO has to take action based on feedback. Also CM alone cannot control unruly cadres, he is not party chief. None of the parties really concerned about the well being of Bengal, they are encashing the situation to grab power. Budhhadeb also, is supported by CPM because he was drawing urban votes. May be now he became a burden for CPM and party wants to throw him out. That will be a sad day for Bengal.
RE:nandigram- should CM resign?
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:12 PM
Bandana...WE, the people of West Bengal will never allow him to be thrown out...Tirtha
RE:RE:nandigram- should CM resign?
by wani bhardwaj on Mar 19, 2007 04:26 PM
It is ridiculous! If ruler is doing wrong thing and atrocities on its people, he is acoutable to the people of WB. He has to resign if wants that CPIM don't want to loose your supporters everywhere.
RE:nandigram- should CM resign?
by abby Das on Mar 23, 2007 05:52 PM
well,people have alreday started laughing at his back.He will be thrown out some day but just to keep his self respect,he shoyuld step down.
RE:RE:RE:nandigram- should CM resign?
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:05 PM
so that u are able to see more scenes like nadigram not only buddha but entire team of so called communist should take resignation & accept that yes they had made wrong thing in doing wrong work.Even if few people in bengal will forgive you(communist) still god wont so hey god please let communist rest inpeace after they meet their death,please forgive them of henorious crime they had done on humanity since 30 years, forgive them what they had done intentionelly or by mistake.Hey communist i on behalf of bengal people who had suffered from your cruel leadership will & am praying to god for all the above mentimned things if you all resign otherwise we will pray oppsite.so yu all decide.
Budhdha has got a mandate of people. He should stay. People with less than 30 or soem with no seats, criminals like Naxals and Media which hardly understand what we Bengalees need and want today do not hav any moral righ to ask him to resign. Let him do his job and Nandigram i snot a land issue - it is a political war of CPM vs muslim and other parties do not misrepresent the case
RE:Bengal in Change
by Bob Seth on Mar 19, 2007 04:12 PM
The media and the intellectuals have to step up pressure and see that buddha resigns, let anyone else replace him from the left front or let bengal go in for a fresh round of elections.Buddha resignation will send across the message that No CM of any state can get away by grabbing land and later killing the right full land owners in cold blood.history will never pardon india if we let a person with Stalins, Hitlers, Saddams, Dweyer mindset to continue.In fact he should be treid for murder arrested immediately and put behind bars for getting poor helpless women raped, young children orpahned, young men maimed. His atrocities sounds very similar to what Hitler did aginst the Jews.
RE:RE:Bengal in Change
by Bosky Nandy on Mar 19, 2007 04:16 PM
Dear Bob...there's a difference between land aquisition and land grabbing....land aquisition with adequate compensation is constitutional...its happening all across India....all the roads, highways and canals/dams are constucted on land taken by aquisation...then we need to amend the constitution inself or according to you ask all the CMs and even the PM to resign....Regards...Tirtha
RE:RE:RE:Bengal in Change
by Bob Seth on Mar 19, 2007 04:33 PM
dear bosky will you give me your house/home/property just because i want to setup a factory on that and i will decide the price i pay you.if you dont agree i throw you out, fence your property and the protestors will be raped, maimed and orphaned by the very same police who is supposed to protect you. waht do you call this. it is people like you who has given the despot buddha the confidence to do such things since he knows he can get away with it.
RE:RE:Bengal in Change
by on Mar 19, 2007 04:57 PM
Buddhadeb shuld continue for the sake of Bengal. We need jobs and not lectures from Intellectuals.Ratan Tata is a far better option than Medha Patekar or Mahashweta Devi as none of them can provide a single job to a youth. So industrialization should continue.
RE:Bengal in Change
by wani bhardwaj on Mar 19, 2007 04:28 PM
Yes, he has got the mandate. But it doesn't mean that he can do whatever he wants. There is rule for everybody and he is answerable to the public when he does some wrong thing.
Land acquisition with adequate compensation is constitutional. It is happening all across the nation. Everever a road, a highway, canal or a dam is constructed. In cities and towns, new colonies are constructed over agricultural lands. If we want to stop all these, we need to make an amendment to our constitution. I dont know then why the West Bengal Chief Minister is being targetted alone, when such things are happening all across the country. Can anyone who understands this better could explain me????
RE:Land Acquisition
by Praveen Bagaria on Mar 19, 2007 04:36 PM
Mr. Nandy, Are you aware that Sector V, Salt Lake (which is New Town or Rajarhat whatever you may choose to call it) was earlier cultivable land. This the West Bengal Government acquired from the peasants forcefully and promised them adequate compensation. It is a pity that till date none of the farmers have been compensated by the LF Government. That is socialism for you West Bengal Government style.
RE:Land Acquisition
by Rajib Basu on Mar 19, 2007 04:20 PM
DEAR TIRTHA,
Please be INFORMED (for the sake of sanity) that no other CM has meditated to kill innocent women and children and then followed up with enough force to remove those bodies through party cadres.
Actually such AUDACITY of politicians come from the very fact that they know many people like you believe in SUPERFICIAL things and celebrate the proverbial IGNORANCE IS BLISS philosophy. Actually, such is the population who elect rogue poiticians in this country - if the electorate is mean-ly selfish the LEADERS have to be so!!!
Hon'ble Chief Minister Mr. Budhhadev Bhattacharya is doing very good job. People of Bengal should think that present and future generation can not survive without industrilisation. The Bengal will be neglected from all over India as well as world if the industrilisation does not take place. I would request the people of Bengal as well as the political leaders to join hand with Budhadev Babu and make the Bengal No. 1 in India so far indusrilisation is concerned
RE:Budhhadev Bhattacharya should not resign
by bobby on Mar 19, 2007 05:12 PM
West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee should accept moral responsibility for the andigram violence and quit. "In the eyes of the law, those who committed the crime are criminals and those who abetted it are also criminals. Chief Minister had sent the police and party cadres to Nandigram and ordered them to fire. You are behind the operation and you also ordered the arrests. You have taken the responsibility for the incident. The case has been proven against you. You must resign. If you do not, not only Bengal but the whole world will condemn you,"
At least ten Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) workers have been arrested and illegal arms seized after the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) started its investigation into the causes behind the violence on the orders of the Calcutta High Court.
RE:RE:Budhhadev Bhattacharya should not resign
by Aloke De on Mar 19, 2007 04:38 PM
How did you agree with him, Piyal? How many good companies are there in Bengal right now? Jute Mills, Metal Box, Shaw Wallace, Phillips, Jessop, BI, Carter Pooler etc can be named a few. Some have shifted, some closed, some sold, some running like snail-speed. If existing companies are take care of properly then no new industry is required.
Dont listen to that effeminate Kaushik Sen or that turncoat Teko Suman and Sankha Ghosh. And the other so called 3rd grade guys who pass themselves off as intellectuals.
The people of bengal will decide if u were right or wrong - wait till the next election. You will win again. The people of Bengal are with you.
Mad Mamata and the lousy Intellectuals without intellect dont matter
RE:STAY - DONT LISTEN TO THOSE IDIOTS
by tuhin roy on Mar 19, 2007 04:30 PM
You are right. Opposition is interested to gain political mileage out of dirty practices. CM has a great Vision which most of the opposing people can not follow even.
RE:RE:STAY - DONT LISTEN TO THOSE IDIOTS
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 05:55 PM
Yes,a great vision to see money and make "Secret Trades" with the indutrialists which most of the opposing people cannot follow even.
RE:STAY - DONT LISTEN TO THOSE IDIOTS
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 04:10 PM
Sir. It seems you have alreday received a part of the "Trade Secret or secret Trade" done with the tatas down the line.You are suggesting him to stay in anticipation that a few more "Trade Secrets" would happen and eventually your pocket would also heat up.Dear Sir,people of bengal was brainwashed for the last 30 years.Now every one has understood that never before the state has seen a CM who can lie to this extent.The state wants someone with a sppine and not a person who lies and becomes the slave of the industrialists.
RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharya - Good or Bad?. A 'must read' for intellectual here in Rediff.
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 04:25 PM
Sir,let me give you one by one where Budhdha Bhattacharya sold his spine and lied. 1.He said 96% of the farmers of Singur have given their land willingly.However,when HIgh Court asked for the exact numbers,the Govt could only produce documents for 330 acres which is just 30% of the total 997 acres. 2.Once he said,"We are 235 and they are just 30".What he actually did not say or did not want the people to understand that out of total voters only 50.4% voted for Left Front(Including all leftisit parties) while the opposition got 49.6% votes.They are majority by just 0.8%.(Not even 1%) 3.Once this man said "Do it now" as if he is trying to break the shakkle.When the OC of Katoa PS killed Mr Tuhin Samanto he ddid not bother to answer the press even.He never took the initiative of arresting the criminal OC. 4.A few days before the nandigram issue our HONEST Cm said in a TV channel that "There is no question of sending police in Nandigram".However,within a week he have send police to nandigram 5.He said "Police had to fire for self defence".Well,so he must have read in advance that police would be attacked and gave modern amunations in the hands of police?He also said that Police went there to repair roads and bring back peace in the area.No where in the country poice goes to repair road with riffles and other modern amunations. 6.He said"Tear off the notice which started the trouble at Nandigram".Well,doesn't he know that a Govt notice when issued,merely tearing off doesn't make it inactive.One more notice against this notice has to be issued making the earlier one inactive.If he is not aware of this,then he should just resign for not knowing this procedure only.He is not fit to be a CM. 7.Mr Nirupom Sen lied about the Maruti Factory at Gurgaon in a TV channel.The next day Maruti published their website in a newspaper and proved he lied.Mr Biman Bose lied against Ms Medha Patekar and later he had to appologise once again publicly in a TV channel.Weher was Budhda then?Why did he did not take any actions against this liers?Maybe he supports saying lies.
People who have been brainwashed by this dangourous party has staretd to wake up.Bengal is waking up once again.Very soon CBI would give the list whom they have arrested to the high court.It is not very late when he has to leave throne and may also be behind the bars.
RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharya - Good or Bad?. A 'must read' for intellectual here in Rediff.
by TSN Xumar on Mar 19, 2007 03:59 PM
Well Said. The intellectuals like Suman/ Kaushik Sen are idiots.
RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharya - Good or Bad?. A 'must read' for intellectual here in Rediff.
by pradeep kumar on Mar 19, 2007 04:25 PM
After reading the statement I wonder every body in Bengal have to say this much I don't know who he is right and who is wrong . But this is democracy so every body have right to say and justify on there own terms.
RE:RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharya - Good or Bad?. A 'must read' for intellectual here in Rediff.
by S Ray on Mar 19, 2007 04:15 PM
Hi,
Are you from Bengal? I think, let Bengal and Bengali with voting rights decide if what is wrong, the rule or the person. Don't make a person scrape goat of a law. Whats has happened is wrong, like Gondra was wrong, equally Gujrat riots were wrong, but atleast he has immediately accepted the CBI enquiry.
RE:RE:RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharya - Good or Bad?. A 'must read' for intellectual here in Rediff.
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 06:04 PM
well,well,now he thinks he has taken a wrong decision by letting CBI enter.That is the reason Mr Prasad Ranjan Roy is stressing on Govt Level enquery.
