Re: new angle
by rama anne on Oct 14, 2010 04:59 AM
hi Sir UIID database will store info in encrypted form ,just like any bank in the world will store data in the database. There is nothing that violates privacy or misuse. It is just like any other sensitive database for any insurance company or a bank. UIID database will authenticate yes or no when a id check is performed so it will eliminate duplicate ration cards misuse of ids (paper based etc). It will also help Planning Commission to determine how much grains are needed in a certian area.How much was distributed etc. Please help it succeed. This is one project that will cleanse corruption at grassroots. This is a very noble project by a noble person SRI NANDAN NILKENNI he is not a politica person. He is helping India as a genuine citizen,we should all be greatful that a project under his leadership is chosen by the UPA Govt and implemented .We should say thanks to Smt Sonia Gandhi and Sri Mamnmohan Singh for their initiative in implementing the same
Do you think if UADAI is not issued to them there will be no act of terrorism and they wont be indian citizens? They have become naturalized indian citizens by now! Actually UADAI has the mechanism in place to give the identity to genuine people only but nevertheless it won\'t be perfect. My contention is that having these guys have the identity and fingerprints will make it easier for govt to catch hold of them and penalize rather than just beating around the bush. What do you think? Govt will be easily able to trace the modus-operandi of these guys and prevent further damage!!! Not knowing who lives among you is even more damning... How long will you deny those guys a right to citizenship. These identity anyway doesn\'t matter for them. They have everything they need by now. People p[oint out to those illegal residents of india who came into india in 70\'s. Do you imagine what would be their age now? At least 40-70 yrs. 40 if they were just born and 70 for those who had been 30 yrs at the age of crossing... Now you cannot send them back!!! There is something called humanity. But as far as governance is concerned UADAI will help govt track the culprits!!! Mumbai happened! delhi act happened and so many mumbai blasts etc has happened has anyone being caught??? It is not possible to strengthen governance without the govt actually knowing their people. So I request you to understand these points before making comments which will demoralize govt from taking constructi
there are always less satisfied people who dont get business from Govt. and then critise important projects of mass benefit in which some people( very negligible % ) may be affected- nothing is perfect in this world-
so think in broader perspective how it will be beneficial to masses rather than a few select people,
i dont think the upa is sincere in actually making the card for the larger benefit of the citizens but to undermine the national security by adding non indians i.e. infeltrators from bangladesh who have spread their network from west bengal, to assam, to bihar and causing security issues within the nation. on the whole the idea seem to be the right thing to do to weed out non indians and send them back, but the upa does not have the courage and actually wants to legitmise them for the vote back politics. its a shame and should be condemed
Re: UPA not sincere
by ravi kumar on Oct 13, 2010 01:36 PM
Do you think if UADAI is not issued to them there will be no act of terrorism and they wont be indian citizens? They have become naturalized indian citizens by now! Actually UADAI has the mechanism in place to give the identity to genuine people only but nevertheless it won't be perfect. My contention is that having these guys have the identity and fingerprints will make it easier for govt to catch hold of them and penalize rather than just beating around the bush. What do you think? Govt will be easily able to trace the modus-operandi of these guys and prevent further damage!!! Not knowing who lives among you is even more damning... How long will you deny those guys a right to citizenship. These identity anyway doesn't matter for them. They have everything they need by now. People p[oint out to those illegal residents of india who came into india in 70's. Do you imagine what would be their age now? At least 40-70 yrs. 40 if they were just born and 70 for those who had been 30 yrs at the age of crossing... Now you cannot send them back!!! There is something called humanity. But as far as governance is concerned UADAI will help govt track the culprits!!! Mumbai happened! delhi act happened and so many mumbai blasts etc has happened has anyone being caught??? It is not possible to strengthen governance without the govt actually knowing their people. So I request you to understand these points before making comments which will demoralize govt from taking constructive steps.
i dont think the upa is sincere in actually making the card for the larger benefit of the citizens but to undermine the national security by adding non indians i.e. infeltrators from bangladesh who have spread their network from west bengal, to assam, to bihar and causing security issues within the nation. on the whole the idea seem to be the right thing to do to weed out non indians and send them back, but the upa does not have the courage and actually wants to legitmise them for the vote back politics. its a shame and should be condemed
it's 'in the identity business. The responsibility of tracking beneficiaries and... service delivery will continue to remain with the respective agencies. The UID number will only guarantee identity, not rights, benefits or entitlements.'
the author has dis-approved of UID mainly on the ground of invasion of privacy. Another ground has been cited as low levels of duplication that already exist. While I agree with the 'duplication' stuff, it is hard to believe why author does not see wisdom in implementing a data base of citizens that could give us the parameters of the country in real time.
The greatest benefit of the UID will be to put the house in order. Any body who hs had trouble to find a paper clip on a messy table top, would readily agree how important it is to have a neat work desk. Similarly, once we have all citizens on a hard disk, it will give us critical parameters of the country with the clik of a mouse.
Imagine an India where the UID can help track where a criminal fueled the vehicle on a chase. Would not it be easy to catch the criminal ? Imagine an India where the UIDs of new borns, combined with UIDs of deceased and the existing UIDs gives the population in real time. That will be so good to track real time population, beneficiaries of several govt plans etc.
An India with UID will improve social security. An India will UID will be an India well documented.
Finally, I for one do not mind my personal love stories if I have to chose between national security and my personal life. national security any time.
If I can trust Google and Yahoo with all my love stori-ed emails on their servers in distant california seven seas afar, I can anyday trust somebody sitting in Delhi.
the author has dis-approved of UID mainly on the ground of invasion of privacy. Another ground has been cited as low levels of duplication that already exist. While I agree with the 'duplication' stuff, it is hard to believe why author does not see wisdom in implementing a data base of citizens that could give us the parameters of the country in real time.
The greatest benefit of the UID will be to put the house in order. Any body who hs had trouble to find a paper clip on a messy table top, would readily agree how important it is to have a neat work desk. Similarly, once we have all citizens on a hard disk, it will give us critical parameters of the country with the clik of a mouse.
Imagine an India where the UID can help track where a criminal fueled the vehicle on a chase. Would not it be easy to catch the criminal ? Imagine an India where the UIDs of new borns, combined with UIDs of deceased and the existing UIDs gives the population in real time. That will be so good to track real time population, beneficiaries of several govt plans etc.
An India with UID will improve social security. An India will UID will be an India well documented.
Finally, I for one do not mind my personal love stories if I have to chose between national security and my personal life. national security any time.
If I can trust Google and Yahoo with all my love stori-ed emails on their servers in distant california seven seas afar, I can anyday trust somebody sitting in Delhi.
