all the mentioned intellectuals are good for nothing for the society ,they are doing so to highlight themselves in the media.the incident was really planned as because c m repeatedly told that the police will enter nandigram to establish law and order over there.it was known to every leader of the opposition before 14th and accordingly the people ofoposition perty had planned how to fight with the police force.women and children were forced tomarch forwarde to fight with the police .whereas men were throwing bombs stones to the police, they also opened fired from their arms.police was compelled to fire to protect themselves. the result is known to everyone .14 dead and so many injured.this situation could easily be averted if leaders of oposition tried to cool down the situation instead of provocation.now come to the point, what is the contribution of buddha babu for our state .thound and thousands of students from the colleges got employment in our own state,number of industries have come up ,number of engineering colleges are working here,big hospitals(including tata) ,and these we have got within iast few years ,we are eagerly waiting and watching, the other good things which are gradually come out from his future plan . Budddha is great, so people not only of bengal but from other states,other political perties,even most of the well known personalities of developed countries recognise the thought and path of Buddha babu.we are proud of him.after all he is doing for the interest of the people of bengal,not a money maker for his own like other political leaders.BUDDHA should not resign.he should carry on to fulfill the dreams of the people of bengal.leaders of opposition perty are jealous ofBuddha babu.(BURA NAZAR WALE TERE MUYEA KALA)
I have doubt that the CBI can published the original report as the central govt. is supported by Left front. It is the real fact that the incident is happened due mishandling the situation by the government. The root cause problem is that our leaders have no control over the root level caders. If any one protests anything they are identified either trinamul or anti left. In last meeting in brigade parade ground Mr.Budhadeb Bhattacharya was announced that no police will be enter in the Nandigram but he does the opposite things. The brand Budhadeb hugely marketing by this government like in such way that Jyoty Basu Government was by right front and they are not responsible for that period mistaken. But originally there is not happened anything till now.
In the health point of view it is worst condition. After the Nandigram killing program ,the victims people also not getting proper treatment from the local hospital as the hospital have only two doctors and less nurse and caretaker and equipment.
The Chief minister neither apologies nor he is declare any compensation and also not taken any steps towards the police. He looks like Mohammad Bin Tughlak the mixer of opposite.
We will see the reality of the movie "HIRAK RAJAR DESEY"...Dari dhorey maro tan .. Raja hobey khan khan...
RE:Nandigram outcry: Will Bengal CM resign?
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 19, 2007 06:32 PM
see this is basically fight between the CPIM cadres who have been driven out of Nandigram by Jomi Bachao Uched Committe members and JBUC to regain their lost ground and homes...i think Laksham Seth and CPIM cadres were desparate to get back at the JBUC members who have eroded their support base..police was made the scrapegoat in this...while Buddhadev shuld take moral responsibility for the massaccre he shuld not step down..
RE:RE:Nandigram outcry: Will Bengal CM resign?
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 02:07 PM
If Budhdhadeb takes the moral responsibiltiy of this incident then he is at fault and has no right to stay in the chiar after taking away so many innocent lives.It is really surprising that in one hand he is taking the moral responsibilty(Maybe he didnot want to take that but was forced by his left partners) on the other hand he is not going to see the wounded in the hospitals for once,not arrangeing any fund or rehabilitation process for the poor villagers who lost everything in their life. We can only say ...One more Iraq is being created in the history and everyone knows what happened after that.
Well.Ratan tata doesn't have the guts(or maybe proper documents) to give allegations to his competitors.Giving allegations without documents was a habit of Budhdha Bhattacharya,it was not expected from ratan tata. regarding Budhdha Bhattacharya,how many times he would let the court dispespect and harras him?During the book fair,the court directly said the the Govt was involved in providing fraud documents to the militery to get the permission to make the fair at maidan.BB said "I tried to save the bookfair".Well,so he admitted that he tried to make the fraud documents which was caught at the court.Once again in this nandigram issue CBI would make him exposed.He still has time to back up keeping his self respect.Otherwise we might court ordering somehting very serious for our HONEST CM.This is your lasdt chance Budhdha babu to quit.
RE:Budhdha still have the chance to retain his self respect.
by BANGALI on Mar 19, 2007 06:29 PM
ur diverting.. i am proud that he told lie to save bookfair and not to increase his own bank balanace or etc..a lie is not alie if done to benefit a bigger cause...pride of kolkatta
RE:RE:Budhdha still have the chance to retain his self respect.
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 02:09 PM
Good that you admit that Budhdha lied.That wonderfull. "He did not lie to increase his own bank balance."Well,he doesn't poke his nose and lie in these petty amounts.He is more interested in doing "Secret Trade" with the industrialists where huge amounts are transferred.
RE:RE:Budhdha still have the chance to retain his self respect.
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 19, 2007 06:37 PM
the lie was not told by Buddhadev but by Guild members who not a part of the Govt..please get ur facts right...buddhadev tried to save the book fair but not by giving false document..what do u think he has no work but to produce false documents to save a book fair !!!
RE:RE:RE:Budhdha still have the chance to retain his self respect.
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 11:42 AM
Well,The Govt filed one affidavit for the last three years that they would provide alternative place for the bookfair which they did not.Everyear during the last few days they used to get the permission from the militery saying that this is the last year.Do you think Budhdha babu was not aware of this fact?in case he knew this fact,why did he tried to retain bookfair at Maidan when there is a court order of shifting its place?saying"I tried to save book fair" indicates that he was in suport of the guild.
I have doubt that the CBI can published the original report as the central govt. is supported by Left front. It is the real fact that the incident is happened due mishandling the situation by the government. The root cause problem is that our leaders have no control over the root level caders. If any one protests anything they are identified either trinamul or anti left. In last meeting in brigade parade ground Mr.Budhadeb Bhattacharya was announced that no police will be enter in the Nandigram but he does the opposite things. The brand Budhadeb hugely marketing by this government like in such way that Jyoty Basu Government was by right front and they are not responsible for that period mistaken. But originally there is not happened anything till now.
In the health point of view it is worst condition. After the Nandigram killing program ,the victims people also not getting proper treatment from the local hospital as the hospital have only two doctors and less nurse and caretaker and equipment.
The Chief minister neither apologies nor he is declare any compensation and also not taken any steps towards the police. He looks like Mohammad Bin Tughlak the mixer of opposite.
We will see the reality of the movie "HIRAK RAJAR DESEY"...Dari dhorey maro tan .. Raja hobey khan khan...
First They Came for the Rich and landed First they came for the Rich & landed and I did not speak out because I was not a Rich nor landed Then they came for the middle class and I did not speak out because I was not a the middle class Then they came for the muslims and immigrants and I did not speak out because I was not a muslim nor an immigrant Then they came for the bargadars and I did not speak out because I was not a bargadar
Then they came for me and there was no one left to speak out for me. With inspiration from Pastor Martin Niem?r%u2019
(The original text by a German author in context of Nazi Germany and the policies of Hitler is reproduced below) First They Came for the Jews First they came for the Jews and I did not speak out because I was not a Jew. Then they came for the Communists and I did not speak out because I was not a Communist. Then they came for the trade unionists and I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for me and there was no one left to speak out for me. Pastor Martin Niem?r
THESE POETS / ACTRESSES / WRITERS CANNOT FEED THE HUNGRY STOMACH OF MILLION UNEMPLOYED YOUNG PPL. AT THE MOST FEW STAGE SHOWS WILL BRING A FEW SCORES OF FOODS...ALL TEARS NO REAL WORK...
JUST REPLY ME ALL U INTELLECTUALS !!!
HOW WILL YOU FEED THE MILLION STOMACHS!!! JUST BY SAYING THAT INDUSTRIALIZATION TO BACKWARD AREAS LIKE BIRBHUM/PURULIA WILL HELP IS ABSURD...THE GEOGRAPHICAL POSITION DOES NOT ALLOW THAT...PLZ MIND I HAVE A LAND ADJUCENT TO BIRBHUM,,,AND IT MAKE NO SENSE AS OF NOW FOR INDUSTRIALISTS TO SET UP INDUSTRY THERE...
ANYWAY, WHATEVER HAPPENED WAS FOR GOOD! WHATEVER IS HAPPENING IS FOR GOOD AND WHATEVER WILL HAPPEN WILL BE FOR GOOD!...AMEN!
RE:Poets / actress / writers
by allen on Mar 19, 2007 06:20 PM
When Mamata was agitating for Singur she wanted the factory to be shifted to Dankuni. Now that the Govt is allocating land to DLF in Dankuni, the same Mamata Banerjee is protesting. Can someone explain WHY?
RE:Poets / actress / writers
by allen on Mar 19, 2007 06:13 PM
ask diz singers to perform widout money!!!! or maybe at remote places wid lil resources...dey wud insantly run away ...ALL CROC TEARS.... ask them wat shud b done to hv a good quality of life ..at par wid dere counterparts in other METROS / MINI .... they hv no answer.... they wud put all there efforts in non value added activities... and hv a feeling of pride in being poor and being jealous of other's hard work and wealth. That's what screwing up the future of the Bengal.... IGNORANCE IS NOT A BLISS ITZ A CRIME
RE:Poets / actress / writers
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 06:05 PM
Dear Sameek, when the lives of innocent goes,then who needs feeding?and you said geographical locations.Well,the Tatas were shown an alternate land just opposite to the present site at Singur.Why did they deny to go there?Just to make "Secret Trade " with the Govt?
RE:RE:Poets / actress / writers
by BANGALI on Mar 19, 2007 06:17 PM
dear aby:
ur message sounds more of old leftist ..cholbe na..cholche na.. no one is denying the sad incident..but we are all trying to see the bigger picture.. asotoma satgamaya
RE:RE:Poets / actress / writers
by allen on Mar 19, 2007 06:19 PM
When Mamata was agitating for Singur she wanted the factory to be shifted to Dankuni. Now that the Govt is allocating land to DLF in Dankuni, the same Mamata Banerjee is protesting. Can someone explain WHY?
RE:RE:Poets / actress / writers
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 19, 2007 06:18 PM
Dear Abby,
There is no proof that TATAs were shown the land opposite to present site except offcourse the opposition claiming to have done such a thing..why do u think the plot on one side of the road is so fertile that no factory can be built on it while the plot on other side is so barren that factories can be built ? moreove TMC MLA from Singur has accpeted that a car factory is required in Singur (he was ousted from the party for no following the diktat of Mamata)..u cant stop a factory from being built just coz 5% ppl dont support it..
RE:RE:RE:Poets / actress / writers
by abby Das on Mar 20, 2007 12:31 PM
ritwick,this 5% figure is one more lie of Budhdha Bhattacharya.When the couort asked for the exact numbers of willing farmers,til now only 330 acres of land (which is just 30% of the total land) has been registered in the court as given willingly by the farmers.Will you still stcik to that 5% figure? secondly the plot has been given as an alternative was declared in front of the press which was telecasted in a couple of channels.Do you want to say that without any official documents of offering the alternative plots,the opposition decleared that in front of the media?Budhdha Babu or Ratan Tata did not oppose this news which was flashed in the media.So it could be apprehended that the news is true.
It is undoubtly true that the incident at Nandigram recently was a misfortunate.I sympathize with the people who have been killed. But It should also be noted that Mr.Buddhadeb is not a criminal.He is doing for we people, the process of getting started industries in Bengal is a dream cum true for the State. Just look at the developmenthe had made in the recent past.Now in order to get industries set up at Bengal, the government would have to compromise with the Industrialist. It is a shame for the political parties who are actually making out a mess of this. Please let Mr.Buddhadeb do his work proplerly else all the people will leave the state for a better future elsewhere, if there is no development. We all know that our CM is a very simple man and carries a LEADERSHIP quality to translate VISION into REALITY. So please do not make him a political victim and let him do his work properly.
RE:Opposition making a Mess
by abby Das on Mar 19, 2007 06:07 PM
He is a simple Man?Did I read it correctly?Such a hypocrite person who can lie left and right be a simple man?I must check my eyes once.
Do you have any idea how many tea gardens closed donw in the last 7 years?Why still people at Amlashol dies of Hunger during the last 7 years? Why Police has become so desperate that a OC can shoot a citizen and still roam free?This happened during last 7 months(not years) and our CM forgets his own words "Do it now".He says 96% of farmers of singur has given their land willingly while the Govt could only give documents of 30% willing farmers.(This is within last 7 months,not 7 years).The court ordered during book fair that the Govt tried all means to make farud to keep the book fair at the maidan.(This is also during the last 7 months).Do you still want our CM to stay and let the court harras him for all his lies everytime?During the bookfair it was proved that how our CM was involved to get the farud documents to get the permission from the militery.He tried all his means to win but court was strict.If he has got self respect then he should leave by his own immidiately.
I am not against industrialisation, it is absolutely necessary, the only thing the way it is done. Instead of one time compensation, they should be given monthly pension (amount wrt land area) for the entire life since it is the only source of income for them plus job for one person from the affected families.Otherwise the problem can not be solved. Further all the Govt.machinery & administration are with the Cadres hence the Nandigram incidents may occur anywhere . Mr. CM should take careof the common man otherwise there will be serious problem for West Bengal it can outburst anytime.
