My message is right dharam was the right film to go for oscar. Ekalavya was a cinematic film, fine but thats it, nothing more than that. Ekalavya was visual gripping but not arousing of any level, I mean to say all levels. There are a lot of levels to discuss but its a waste of time, but in the end only one movie should go to oscar and that is DHARAM,FINE
RE:Well guys dharam was a lot better to go for OSCARS
by mohan saud on Oct 01, 2007 05:42 PM
Idiots like you are falling for the trap set by the likes of Bhavna Talwar. All this is a media gimmick. Have you EVEN seen Dharam? It played in the halls for a week. I saw it - fine it was a okay film - well shot and all that - but it is NO WAY close to being an Oscar film! All this hype Ms. Talwar has created has got you people believing its a better film!? BULL-PHUCKING_SHITE!
hey Oscars...Oops!!!Many of you guys seems to have forgotten a movie that has capture the attention of all the Indians, Alas not only of Indianns but of people over the globe!!!!Yup you got it right SIVAJI...that should be indias nomination to oscar... If it is esnd or if the people at the top brass are benign enough to consider this legendory movies as worthy to be send to Oscares bet on me it will emerge as the best movie and our Rajni anna will be the Best Actor...plz consider Sivaji if you want our india shine bright....
RE:consider
by ASLAM TV on Sep 30, 2007 02:50 PM
Hello mr, with respect Mr.Rajani doesnt know acting, he is making some comic repeated style whole his films. If you ask any critics they will explain you what is rajani.
I agree he is style mannan but not a real actor. If you want to acting you watch Kamal,Mammootty and old Amithab Bachan.
First you dream a national award for Rajani and think about OSCAR.Do you know what is OSCAR(Learn first)?.
RE:consider
by VSR on Sep 30, 2007 03:07 PM
In India, everyone is bothered about foreign goods. Foreign TV, foreigner as head of congress, foreign adward Oscar. Forget about all these men. Let us admire what is good for India and admire that has good value. Let these these guys any movie to Oscar ultimately they also give award only to those whom they know. Like Gandhi was given award because everyone knows Richard Attenborough. Oscar is not free from bias anymore, whether it is selection within India or getting award outside India.
This is not for the first time that oscar selection is biased. Vidhu Vinod Chopra is the best filmaker and Big B is the biggest in this film industry. What is special in paheli and dharm. VVC has made good films in the past and Eklavya is the film which was made irrespective of the profits. Film for oscars is selected on the norms of oscars and not on the basis of bollywood or high court decisions or from any comments through srk / fk / sk and their types. Eklavya should go to oscars.
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by kaushik dutta on Sep 30, 2007 02:47 PM
Hey Harish,
Do u understand anything about films?? Without big B, small B would have been asking for coins in Mumbai signals? Let alone SRK, small B is a small fry compared to Hrithik Roshan. Baat karta hai!!!
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by madhu mittal on Sep 30, 2007 01:46 PM
R u mad??? where does the question of minorty arise??? every one likes SRK coz of his acting skills...n nothing else.. guess its sick mind like urs which cause all the divide in our country
RE:RE:Years of bias behaviour
by VSR on Sep 30, 2007 03:14 PM
In film world no religion guys. We all liked Dilip Kumar, Amitabh, Rajesh Khanna, Forez Khan, Sanjay Khan, Amjad Khan, Ajit, SRK, Salman, Amir, Ajay Devgan, Akshaye, Mumtaj, Meena Kumari, Waheda, Sharmila, Hema, Zeenath, Shabana, Reena Roy, Neethu and so on. There were very old actors who were from muslim and there are new actors who are muslim. Liking of an actor is not based on religion, but based on acting. Again, not everyone need to like acting of everyone. Some people like Amitabh (even today), somelike SRK and some like Sanjay (even after he is jailed). At least, let us respect this.
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by RamGopalVarmaKi DAG on Sep 30, 2007 02:07 PM
Does Shahrukh knows acting? woh ek Haklu hai. sala copy karta hai. First he copied AB, now coping Salman Khan/Akshy/Hritik by showing his body. He does not innovate. He is a follower, Bldy copy cat
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by madhu mittal on Sep 30, 2007 03:50 PM
instead of calling him all this why dont u try and do even 10% of what he has... easier said than done...mr. ram gopal varma...mind before u speak such rubbish..
RE:RE:Years of bias behaviour
by Aashit Mishra on Sep 30, 2007 02:42 PM
nothing against srk or Big B, they are both great in their own places you bloody racist. Grow up man, come up with some sensible riting!!!
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by VSR on Sep 30, 2007 03:17 PM
Guys, grow up. Be matured in posting comments. No point in bringing religion. Again, liking of an actor is an individual taste.
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by RamGopalVarmaKi DAG on Sep 30, 2007 02:07 PM
Does Shahrukh knows acting? woh ek Haklu hai. sala copy karta hai. First he copied AB, now coping Salman Khan/Akshy/Hritik by showing his body. He does not innovate. He is a follower, Bldy copy cat
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by Amrit Sen on Sep 30, 2007 02:33 PM
stop posting such stupid comments in this forum. SRK is popularity is bcoz of his minority??? Dude talk some sense.
RE:Years of bias behaviour
by animesh singh on Sep 30, 2007 02:30 PM
ja ke amitabh ke paas so ja, wo tujhe 500 rupai de dega. jakar accha khana kha lena.
Selection of Eklavya shows how Biased the Selection Process is Infact the Selection of Paheli also showed how biased Film Industry is, Vidhu Vinod Chopra has made a crap Movie which he claims to be MasterPiece infact I believe it is a Compromise coz Rang De Basanti was Chosen Last time and not Lage Raho Munnabhai, so this time they have shown bias towards Vidhu Vinod Chopra, In fact This Industry is Being Ruled by Gaaays like Karan Johar who have backing of Fudgekin Gaaays like SRK, So it is all Compromise in Selection like Selection of SRK as Leading Hero in a Karan Johar Movie(they are always in Compromising Position).
I feel Chak De India deseves to be in the Oscars, rathaer than Eklavya....
And also regarding Sivaji, only a a malbari would first of all understand Sivaji, & would want it to go for Oscar.
U think Oscar ppl want to watch that outdated action movies made in Tamil/ Malbari, with that idiot Rajnukant doing all sorts of illogical action.....Please give those ppl a break!!
RE:Chak De India
by mahesh mashalkar on Sep 30, 2007 12:48 PM
Mind ur Fudgekin Language, I think ur a Huge Fan of SRK, Mind u Rajnikanth may be Hero for Masses, but look at his conduct apart from films , he does Social Work, he works with Old Technicians and even Old makeup artists to give them a career again, he is a humble and down to earth person with no political aspirations(Even with that massive Popularity), where as SRK is a Manipulator, who cares only about his Image and His Profit and Of Course about Compromising with Karan Johar
RE:RE:Chak De India
by gyanendra sinha on Sep 30, 2007 12:51 PM
sonia & all people,,,
have you seen dharam...you say chak de india should go. but u know only best movie should go...dharam is much much better..as for sportsmanship & teamwork chak de stands nowhere to million dollar baby...if u have seen it. come on take ur self above the hindi SRK movies..do you know what acting & direction is..go & see the film which beat "lagan" our best Oscar nomination so far...you will be amazed at the simplicity & message of the film..
RE:Chak De India
by Shinu Varghese on Sep 30, 2007 12:56 PM
Sonia Javeri,
Please don't advertise your ignorance. Some of the best movies are made in Malayalam. I hope you have heard names such as Adoor Gopalakrishnan, Jayaraj and Blessy. IF not please don%u2019t comment on movies. And for your kind information Rajanikanth is not Malabari. IGNORAMUS.
RE:Chak De India
by LaX Ray on Sep 30, 2007 12:37 PM
havent you seen the chinese movie which swept oscars few years back? people flying around in name or martial arts? how can those qualify? I like those movies. We all liked, why to say our action idiotic. He is super hero for people, ur two liner won't affect him anyway.
