We have been avid viewers of VOI, but we feel absolutely cheated by the way the winner of a competition has been decided not based on any talent, but on pure sectarian considerations. Ishmeet did not deserve to be even standing on the same stage as Harshit, leave alone competing for the top slot. But as Toshi said, Harshit is the real VOI, but Ishmeet will win. And what is this regional shouts on stage by Shaan bhaiya? SHAME SHAME SHAME. WHEN WILL WE LEARN TO BE INDIANS?And since when did Abhilasha become the best female singer? The way she always got off the hook from chakravat week after week shows her capability and manipulation by some one all the time. She is definitely NOT THERE, as compared to Sumitra or Priyani. WHAT A FARCE!!!!!!
Definitely Ishmeet is not a good singer. The fact that he is not trained is evident from his singing as his voice is shaky. harshid deserved to win as he has the voice that bollywood needs. he is trained and has a steady voice. ishmeet won only becoz of SMS. in fact ishmeet does not deserve to go beyond top 12. the finale wud have been more interesting if toshi or abhas was there becoz both are superb and classically trained. but, i guess there is no value for real talent. everything in this world is just MONEY BUSINESS !!!
RE:ISHMEEET DOES NOT DESERVE TO WIN !!!!
by oye on Nov 25, 2007 02:08 PM
ADVICE " JEALOUS PEOPLE MAKE THEIR OWN LOSS " HA HA HA AH DO MORE JEALOUS EEEEEEEEEEEEE.AAAA
RE:RE:ISHMEEET DOES NOT DESERVE TO WIN !!!!
by Moumita Boral on Nov 25, 2007 03:55 PM
Jealous of Ishmeet, plz check ur brains as none of us are so low to be jealous of Ishmeet. He is not even fit to be the slippers of Aabhas, Irfan, Toshi, Abhilasha, Mirande, Priyani and Ashpreet's feet. Infact Harshit's talent has been insulted becoz he got Ishmeet as his competitor and in a way it is good that Harshit didn't win becoz winning from Ishmeet is below his dignity and talent.
SMS & Advt(s) made money. 5% of the amount was given to winner. some amt was given to judges and anchor for their time and false fighting. Idinal Idol I,II,III, saregama winners, jodi no 1. All are forgotten. Ishmit will belong to the same bunch. I pity all this winners, who make money for producers and land up with hardly anything.
WAKE UP ALL, Don't spend your money on sms, you are not going to get anything. Producers are making money
LET the BEST in industry decide who is good. HOW COME SMS SAY WHO IS GOOD, else all the exams can be also cleared with voting. Real JURY SHOULD STEP IN THE business and DECIDE
RE:Awareness for reality programs
by omkar on Nov 25, 2007 02:08 PM
Bilkul theek kaha Divyesh bhai apne janta ko fool banaker yeh log apna ulloo sidha ker rahai hai aslme filmo se to nikaal die gai hai gane gane ko to mil nahi rahai hai to janta ke sms se yesh ker rahai hai jeeta jagta saboot hai alka yegnik abhijeet aur lalit in teeno ne milker wild card entry se jo ki janta ke vote ne faisla ker dia tha toshi priyaani aur abhaas ko phir se bula lia kyoki tabtek in teeno ka pet nahi bhara tha khasker alka yagnik jo ki lawaris ka gana mere angna abhi tak kaish ker rahi hai usko gane wane to milte nahi hai to sms se hi kaam chala rahi hai apas me lerker asia hi abhijeet jo ki bhappi da itne senior se kaise ler raha tha sari janta ne dekha usko baat kerne ki tammej he nahi hai jisne abhijeet ko break dia unhi bhappi da se ler gaya mer bhi janta se yehi request hai ke ab bhaut paisa berbad ker lia ab in logo ko sms dena band ker de yeh log sirf apni pocket bharne baithe hai. Shaan bhai kaha aap aur Adesh Srivastava in flop judgeo ke beech me phas gai khair all the best Shaan bhai mere hisab se aap ko best anchor ka award milna chaie dhanyad.
RE:Awareness for reality programs
by Moumita Boral on Nov 25, 2007 03:57 PM
Very true! An unhealthy nexus is going on between the channels and the mobile companies. They are more interested in making profits rather than judging true talents.
RE:Awareness for reality programs
by Navtej Singh on Nov 26, 2007 11:52 PM
Follow the good old gandhi rules....Byecott TV and demonstrate it by cancelling your subscriptions
RE:ITS NOT VOICE OF INDIA
by sojan stephan on Nov 25, 2007 01:23 PM
I strongly agree... ishmeet won with the help of SMS only...real voice of india is Abhas
RE:ITS NOT VOICE OF INDIA
by uppi on Nov 25, 2007 02:53 PM
WHAT WAS DEBOJIT..VOICE OF ASSAM?? WHAT WAS Sandeep Acharya..VOICE OF RAJASTHAN?? WHAT WAS PRASHANT TAMANG..VOICE OF GURKHAS?? GO GET SOME LIFE U LOOSERS..TRY TO ACCEPT REALITY AND BE A GRACEFUL LOOSERS..
RE:ITS NOT VOICE OF INDIA
by Moumita Boral on Nov 25, 2007 03:59 PM
My dear we are not losers it is people like u who judge people on the basis of reginalism and communalism as losers. ishmeet and Prashant Tamang both dont deserve this win and that's final. They are SMS king not talented singers.
Ishmeet's victory is a tight slap on the face of Abjijeet - who said he dosent deserve to be in top 12 and Aadesh-Lalit who repeatedly made racist comments against him.
Aadesh shrivastava became totally shameless and was shamelessly supporting his Kayastha brother harshit saxena. Hv u seen any judge supporting a contestant so madly. That was love between 2 kayastha brothers. These kayasthas support each other shamelessly, the proof of it is in aadesh-harshit nexus. Even biased judges could not help harshit. shame shame puppy shame.
RE:Ishmeet's victory
by Moumita Boral on Nov 25, 2007 04:05 PM
Abhijeet was the one who used to dance maximum with ishmeet and the day he made this comment that Ishmeet should not have come to top 12 even was the day when all the judges received some threatning msgs from some cheap public of Punjab who said that Ishmeet should win-------otherwise?????????? got it and why should Abhijeet's face be slapped what do u think that by winning the title due to some stupid SMS system would make a person a singer, Ishmeet is not fit to be the slippers of Aabhas, irfan, Toshi, Abhilasha, priyani and Ashpreet. Infact its good thing that harshit lost becoz winning from Ishmeet would have been an insult to his talent. Just becoz Irfan was voted out that Abhijee did not even come to watch the finals becoz he knows that anytime and anyday Harshit is a better singer than Ishmeet. And no one is jealous of Ishmeet becoz 'to be jealous also one has to belong to certain category' and Ishmeet doesn't have any category he is just SMS king devoid of any talent.
RE:ISHMEET GREAT SINGER
by Divyesh Sampat on Nov 25, 2007 01:07 PM
SMS & Advt(s) made money. 5% of the amount was given to winner. some amt was given to judges and anchor for their time and false fighting. Idinal Idol I,II,III, saregama winners, jodi no 1. All are forgotten. Ishmit will belong to the same bunch. I pity all this winners, who make money for producers and land up with hardly anything.
WAKE UP ALL, Don't spend your money on sms, you are not going to get anything. Producers are making money
RE:ISHMEET GREAT SINGER
by Suresh Ganti on Nov 25, 2007 01:16 PM
Divyesh you are right....keeping the money invested aside the same fate will be with ishmit too. he will be remembered for 2 yrs or so and then he will join the group of forgotten talent. the beneficiaries are start plus, judges. organizers have announced that some part of money will be given to blind people to get their sight back but i am sure lot of mishandling will happen and no proper accounts will be maintained.infact the same happened with kargil warriors who laid down their valuable lifes for country but wat did they get one medal and now their families dont have basic eminities to continue their living. they are on roads.
not only with regards to winner but i feel there was a lot of discrimination interms of awarding or gifting abhilasha. as far i remember i have seen her in danger zone for more than 6 to 10 weeks so in what way the judges has done justification to the contest.i feel real talent is ignored. singers like thoshi,priyani,mirande,sumitra etc have been ignored and those who are not talented were given importance.
RE:ISHMEET GREAT SINGER
by Moumita Boral on Nov 25, 2007 04:09 PM
"Kisi ki Juti bhi nahi jalegi Ishmeet se kyunki woh uss layak bhi nahi hai ki koi usse jale" he is just an SMS king without any talent. Woh Aabhas, Irfan, Toshi, Abhilasha, Priyani, Mirande and Ashpreet ke jutti uthane ke layak bhi nahi hai forget competing with them. Its good Harshit lost from him becoz it would have been an insult to Harshit's talent to win from Ishmeet as Ishmeet won becoz Punjab gave him votes via reasonable and unreasonable procedures. Just like Pransht Tamang won Indian idol due to booth capturing in a same way Ishmeet won and he doesn't deserve.
First of all congratulates to Ishmeet and supporteres of Ismeet because he deserve it and without support no body can win in the show.Ishmeet dont think about that people who are saying that you have a votes not talent but your voters are still with you because you deserve it. Good days ahead
RE:VOI the best show
by Divyesh Sampat on Nov 25, 2007 01:01 PM
SMS & Advt(s) made money. 5% of the amount was given to winner. some amt was given to judges and anchor for their time and false fighting. Idinal Idol I,II,III, saregama winners, jodi no 1. All are forgotten. Ishmit will belong to the same bunch. I pity all this winners, who make money for producers and land up with hardly anything.
RE:RE:VOI the best show
by Nirmal n on Nov 25, 2007 01:08 PM
sahi bola divyesh.. Ishmeet wil soon follow prashant tamang n who was t other Indian Idol 2nd winner their way............
RE:VOI the best show
by Nirmal n on Nov 25, 2007 01:06 PM
Rajiv we will see how long will Ishmeet will long.. I am sure deserving guys guys like Toshi & Harshit will go much much more places thane Ishmeet. Ishmeet is just abt an ordinary singer nothing spectacular abt his voice, while guys like toshi & harshit were superb....
I really admire Toshi who commented that Harshit was real Voice of India but Ishmeet would win. Its a fate accompli which could happen only in our country because of religion and regional bias.
RE:Ishmeet wins Star VOI
by jorawer mann on Nov 25, 2007 01:10 PM
It's for everybody , who thinks Ishmeet wins because he is punjabi. Harshit is also a punjabi, so I don't why all of you are so JEALOUS of Ishmeet you are just creating regional or religion mess out of nothing. Zones were created by Star Plus and this discussion board not by Punjab or Punjabis. Madhuri the Bollywood queen who have more music sense than any of you just babbling also favoured Ishmeet openly. If according to you Harshit was better, you should have spent some money and supported Harshit instead of showing your jealousy for Ishmeet here.
RE:Ishmeet wins Star VOI
by Nirmal n on Nov 25, 2007 01:01 PM
sahi bola bosss i was also of t same opinion tat Harshit was real Voice of India but Ishmeet won coz of his religion and regional bias n his SMSin
Rediff this a important messg to you. Please tell me what sense does it makes who wins what? I mean check this out a participant who wins gets all the contracts renumeration, car etc...cellular companies makes money out of messgs or votes that sent thru sms....we the viewers are the biggest fools who do vote them mindblowing 6RS per sms... the worst part is participants like ministers commit on shows that they are going to sing for us why they dont agree that they want votes coz they want to win which is as simple as that....so now is Ismith ,for example, going to donate some money to those people who have voted him? a simple question........
RE:RE:Reality shows sucks!!!!!!
by Divyesh Sampat on Nov 25, 2007 01:00 PM
SMS & Advt(s) made money. 5% of the amount was given to winner. some amt was given to judges and anchor for their time and false fighting. Idinal Idol I,II,III, saregama winners, jodi no 1. All are forgotten. Ishmit will belong to the same bunch. I pity all this winners, who make money for producers and land up with hardly anything.
the voting simply showed that clear victory of Harshit everyone knew that he is well deserving even irfan and toshi were more deserving than ishmeet. if the prog brags about ' sache suro ki talash ' then this decision is totally partial a substantially wrong decision. i don't see this channel and prog anymore authentic and credible. i am myself a punjabi but i know that harshit was far more better than ishmeet. these prgrammes shd not portray candidates on the basis of their religion or region, if they use this criteria then it is not a true search for the talent and it is like you are using people's emotions to make large money. it is just another form of divde and rule policy. how bad i will never watch star voice of india and i no more consider the channel and program credible ...
RE:ishmeet is just voice of punjab not india, it was a biased decision
by Divyesh Sampat on Nov 25, 2007 01:00 PM
SMS & Advt(s) made money. 5% of the amount was given to winner. some amt was given to judges and anchor for their time and false fighting. Idinal Idol I,II,III, saregama winners, jodi no 1. All are forgotten. Ishmit will belong to the same bunch. I pity all this winners, who make money for producers and land up with hardly anything.
RE:RE:ishmeet is just voice of punjab not india, it was a biased decision
by Navtej Singh on Nov 26, 2007 11:57 PM
Divyesh, you are born stupid. Punjabis are 2% of the total Indian Population. If Ishmeet was my son, I'll take him out of India, the poisonous country
RE:ishmeet is just voice of punjab not india, it was a biased decision
by rajiv sethi on Nov 25, 2007 02:07 PM
You never be a punjabi nor be a good viewer of VOI because you dont have good judgement. Keep it in your mind quality is by chioce not by chance its not a game of Cricket where sachin will not bat and india will not win. Here is a guy of punjab and he deserve to win because at every moment of every episode he is being demorlised by Adesh and Lalit some times by Abhijeet also. But even the wrong comments pass on by judges he is a winner . We are proud by common judge who always on right track nor support any body and never demorlised any body thats Jatin ji. Now we again and again wish him a good and healthy future to Ishmeet on his future plans.
