Hello Rediff, please improve your movie review statndard. Your Finance/Economic analysis and GetAhead type of news are really remarkable. Bring movie reviews also to that level.
RE:Pl improve review level
by Sudhan Deo on Feb 11, 2007 04:07 PM
I agree, this review was quite horrible. I've worked in the movie trade and find such weird reviews in some of the industry publications. Sudhan!
RE:Pl improve review level
by Saikat Parida on Feb 11, 2007 06:21 PM
I agree. Movie reviews is the only section in rediff that is pathetic. I think its time for an exhaustive overhaul. Throw out these idiots who are reviewing and hire fresh people. This reviewer says the director should have chosen a more glamorous actor and chosen better (i guess refined) dialogues. I think next he/she would want a few romantic songs and then finally make this a family entertainer in the lines of HAHK or KKHH...
RE:RE:Pl improve review level
by chaitanya Sardeshpande on Feb 12, 2007 11:00 AM
well said !!! I don't konow weather this he/she know anything about review ? send her to sharukh,karan,chopra's camp and tell him/her served as their PRO .....plz bring some best reviewer rediff........know it's routine when rediff review is bad the movie must be good & when rediff say the movie is good then it's absolutely pathetic ....ask any one ....
Hello Rediff.. I strongly feel you guys need to get a good critic to post reviews on films..Just changing people for each review doesnt bring out good reviews..This is a very serious problem that needs to be addressed by you guys before prople lose their credibility on this website(at least this section) if its not already lost..Its also shame on the way the reviewer writes about Rajpal Yadav
you are making statements on how the movie should be - like middle class film, glamorous actor and so forth. This article seems to be an opinion and not a review. Moreover, review has to be made in context of what the film maker wanted in terms of vision, script, execution and so forth. judging by commercial success is a parameter to the review and not the whole review. You have not touched upon the quality of direction,the tightness of script, and other technical aspects. You need to improve both upon your review and english lang.
i dont know how the rediff people agreed to post such a senseless review.rajpal yadav is an actor first.atleast by now rediff shld take take care to remove this article from web.
