I have noticed many times rediff will give good comments to a flop movie of SRK & Co,if the movie is not accepted by audience(for eg:DON-New)they will mention in their review ven after 4th week that "opens well",it is really a biased comment by this site,they will only pat the back of Big stars like SRK,Karan Johar etc..
The line 'Why will anyone go to watch a movie with Rajpal Yadav in it?' was simply unnecessary. The same can apply to you as well, 'who would ever want to read your reviews again?'
I just can't understand the need of a glamorous face for a movie? You need a actor to act who can carry the image of the role not a star. The reviewer seems like a one who enjoys only SRK and company singing and dancing whatever the story may be!!!
With all due respect Mr/Ms. Patcy you review is very confusing. You were not able to make any statement in your review. Just trying to make a strong statement against Rajpal yadav and then backing out. Running the movie down in all respects - cast, dailogues, budget, shooting etc. and still giving it three stars(pretty Good!!) I think next time spend some time when writing a film review based on such a strong subject.
RE:The most stupid review I ever came across
by Saif Hasan on Feb 09, 2007 07:10 PM
I am afraid this an extremely bad review. Lady, reading lines like "Why will anyone go to watch a movie with Rajpal Yadav in it?" is unpardonable. And Gosh! You would have liked the movie had it been set in the upper and middle class? First rule of writing reviews - never ever bias your reader with your personal prejudices.
I simply hope Patcy is not writing the review of Black Friday.
People who write reviews like these are the ones who do not encourage good realsitic movies!! U want big actors in these kind of movies too? C'mon Ms.Patcy...grow up!!
RE:Very stupid review!!
by sai ram on Feb 09, 2007 06:58 PM
yes it is very bad that even today people compare SRK and Big B for shows and when some one is really done a good job by giving a performance it is being Reviewed so stupidly.If you cant do good then please dont do bad as well.As far Raj pal yadav he is a good actor who has done a complete turn around from his normal skills to some thing which he has not done so far so please stupid people,dont watch good movies watch instead watch game shows and collect stupid reviews
Well I haven't seen the movie yet but the review seems utterly nonsense. Ms Patcy needs to wake up and know that movies like this need actors like Rajpal Yadav and not glamorous faces like SRK or Abhishek. Ms Patcy needs to understand that movies like these are not meant to entertain people which is what, perhaps, is the only definition of cinema that she knows.
Come on girl, go to some fashion show to find glamour.
the review seems like the work of some amateur review writer. doesnt seem like its written by a film critic. compared to the review on indiafm.com this one is just pale in comparision .
Today's audience is not dumbo, it goes for quality , story and entertainment and not for big stars. If audience run after big star cast all multi-starer films will be super-hit.
Anyways, Rajpal Yadav is a great actor and I am sure he has done justice with his role.
How can you put comments like there are less dialogs, etc. Have you gone through situations like this? I think the director/producer of movie is not fool. He had spent a lot of time on it and then the output comes...
If you have such a great mind and logics, please direct a movie like this with a super-star and then send me the results.
