I think when we are talking about transperent....i think jindal steel and power would have been the best ever. i don't know how they came to conclusion that TATA's are the best?
RE:Not TATA ...its JINDAL
by Eagle on Dec 20, 2007 10:55 PM
Send your FAQ to Britain's One World Trust. Jindal????? BTW, where is headoffice and who is CEO.
RE:Not TATA ...its JINDAL
by chandan dash on Dec 20, 2007 09:59 PM
people might have different reservations and different emotional points to nurse, but TATAs outpace the rest in terms of consistent brand imgae throgh decades and veryso by completing a century of excellence in 2007.
with no pun intended and no offence meant, the jindals, the ambanis and mittals etc are pretty young and and over enthusists to be compared with the TATAs and for so with the Elite circle.
The only other Indian Business house which would have been considered was the Birlas but they have just degenerated.
This clearly hints at the power to move on...
Hats off to the TATAs (the parsis)....do not take me wrong...i'm a oriya brahmin... coincidentally in the corporate sector as a no one...
On the other hand the Reliance group is the least accountable and opaque company in India. RIL is valued $100.00 billion by market cap and simply it's not worth it. This is just RIL and not the whole group lead by Mukesh. Both the brothers are playing the pyramid game by buying and selling their own stock and keeping the momentum alive. They do this with the other companies they own and their associates spread across the market. At the least their cash flow numbers does not match. What else can you expect? One should be cautious while dealing with Reliance group. After all, the Reliance is not that reliable.
Getting rated as the third most transparent organization in the world is definitely a great achievement. What makes this achievement an astonishing one is the fact that Tata group operates out of India, one of world's most corrupt countries.
I find rating GE ahead of the Tatas a bit curious. Personally I rate the Tatas way above GE in transparency. We still remember Dabhol project, right? Enron is not the only guilty party responsible for the fiasco.
RE:RE:Bigger acheivement
by Rajesh S on Dec 20, 2007 09:33 PM
"What makes this achievement an astonishing one is the fact that Tata group operates out of India, one of world's most corrupt countries"
Let me introduce myself. I Manish Somani based in NOIDA and working towards a forming a forum for relisting of ESSAR Steel shares. I am encouraging investors to join this forum for demanding our rights. We are currently 50 plus shareholders and the number is ever increasing.
Despite public outrage and media's exposure, the company has got the permission to delist its share. It will be great if you could stress the plight the shareholders in this regard. There are still about 4 lac shareholders clinging to the stock in hope of justice.
So far SEBI/ NSE/BSE and SAT have done anything that might be helpful. Despite the numerous complaints filed by us, no response is forth coming from them.
The company says that they had complied with all the requisite laws and regulation for delisting of equity shares. All in letter but none in spirit. Essar group said it was delisting its steel and oil arms from stock exchanges to gain more flexibility in running the companies. Does the company think that by holding 87% shares the company will not be able to efficiently run the company?
The discovered price did not represent the proper value of the company and the price discovery could not have factored in several hidden values. More than that evens the process of delisting was a farce.
Please let me know if there is something you can possibly do. I have been talking to shareholders to make a forum. It will of great help if you can circulate this to your group and he
RE:Tata - Irish or Indian
by student student on Dec 20, 2007 09:13 PM
Even if what you say is true... TATA company head quarters is in India. It began in India. Hence TATA is definitely an Indian company!
RE:Tata - Irish or Indian
by Guru HM on Dec 20, 2007 09:47 PM
Kolhapuri ...chappal hei kya ...tho apne aap ko marlo ... If you are a shareholder and citizen of xyz country, will this descredit TATA group ... isn't it your problem or liability that you are taking citizenship to dodge some thing... TATA group is in India and paying taxes...period.
RE:Tata - Irish or Indian
by shailesh sinha on Dec 20, 2007 10:09 PM
sahi Guru ek dum sahi main to bloonga apna nahin hai to udhar le kar bhi dusre ka chappal apne sir mar lo kohlapuri...
RE:Tata - Irish or Indian
by praveen jagdish kumar on Dec 21, 2007 04:18 AM
mere paas do naye jore hai kolhpuri chappal ke...kal hi kharida hai...bolo to bhej dun..
RE:RE:RE:Tata - Irish or Indian
by Amitabh Das on Dec 20, 2007 10:23 PM
Hey this compliment was for "Kolhapuri ...chappal hei kya ". Not for the actual post :))
Let me introduce myself. I Manish Somani based in NOIDA and working towards a forming a forum for relisting of ESSAR Steel shares. I am encouraging investors to join this forum for demanding our rights. We are currently 50 plus shareholders and the number is ever increasing.
Despite shareholder outrage and media interest in the matter ESSAR will be delisted. It was saddest day in the history of corporate India. The move would encourage more companies to delist shares, restructure capital and moreover sending a message that the rich and mighty always have their way.
Despite public outrage and media's exposure, the company has got the permission to delist its share. It will be great if you could stress the plight the shareholders in this regard. There are still about 4 lac shareholders clinging to the stock in hope of justice.
So far SEBI/ NSE/BSE and SAT have done anything that might be helpful. Despite the numerous complaints filed by us, no response is forth coming from them.
The company says that they had complied with all the requisite laws and regulation for delisting of equity shares. All in letter but none in spirit. Essar group said it was delisting its steel and oil arms from stock exchanges to gain more flexibility in running the companies. Does the company think that by holding 87% shares the company will not be able to efficiently run the company?
The discovered price did not represent the proper value of the company and the price discove
If US hotel chain Orient-Express has not found TATA worthy its their mistake.
Nothing is gonna happend to the TATAs. I take this opportunity to congratulate Mr.Ratan Tata and the entire TATA group for being recognized as one of the most transparent companies. This is really a great thing !!
I also wish good luck to TATA to bring the Jaguars and Rovers under its enteemed brand and Tata LOGO. All the best ..
