Discussion Board

Why India should focus on income-based reservation


Total 189 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Kallol Bala
Why no wealth based reservation...
by Kallol Bala on Sep 18, 2014 10:57 AM

Income can't & mustn't be a criteria for 'Reservation'.Reservation is given with a philosophy for uniformity in participation & representation of all citizens,in various organs of the society,with the intent to prevent monopoly,crony-capitalism,inducing fresh air(ideas & approaches) & to inculcate a sense of inclusiveness to all & sundry in the process of evolution of the civilisation.This can happen if the victims of past groupism have enough resources to build their 'Networks',to ensure a sustainable modern self-support system.Till such time,the society has to provide network building & maintaining charges to citizens denied of existing modern supporting networks & it takes some time for human systems like say 'reservation' to percolate to various strata of a given caste,given human psychology is not same as that of a machine(unless,it is intended to create caste based ghettos & slums for cheap & compulsive labour by going into the denial mode).Only then,eventually can the present system of reservation become meaningless.But if economic criteria is used as a parameter for reservation,it ensures a 'Heads I win,Tails I win' situation for the castiests.Moreover,whereas caste based reservation is meant to give a corrective bias,in mostly economical only,to the gloom & disparities created by social biases, we mustn't give credit to a person for being 'Poor'.It would encourage able bodied people to shy away from economic activities and woul

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kallol Bala
Why no wealth based reservation...
by Kallol Bala on Sep 18, 2014 10:54 AM

Income can't & mustn't be a criteria for 'Reservation'.Reservation is given with a philosophy for uniformity in participation & representation of all citizens,in various organs of the society,with the intent to prevent monopoly,crony-capitalism,inducing fresh air(ideas & approaches) & to inculcate a sense of inclusiveness to all & sundry in the process of evolution of the civilisation.This can happen if the victims of past groupism have enough resources to build their 'Networks',to ensure a sustainable modern self-support system.Till such time,the society has to provide network building & maintaining charges to citizens denied of existing modern supporting networks & it takes some time for human systems like say 'reservation' to percolate to various strata of a given caste,given human psychology is not same as that of a machine(unless,it is intended to create caste based ghettos & slums for cheap & compulsive labour by going into the denial mode).Only then,eventually can the present system of reservation become meaningless.But if economic criteria is used as a parameter for reservation,it ensures a 'Heads I win,Tails I win' situation for the castiests.Moreover,whereas caste based reservation is meant to give a corrective bias,in mostly economical only,to the gloom & disparities created by social biases, we mustn't give credit to a person for being 'Poor'.It would encourage able bodied people to shy away from economic activities and woul

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kallol Bala
Why no wealth based reservation...
by Kallol Bala on Sep 18, 2014 10:53 AM

Income can't & mustn't be a criteria for 'Reservation'.Reservation is given with a philosophy for uniformity in participation & representation of all citizens,in various organs of the society,with the intent to prevent monopoly,crony-capitalism,inducing fresh air(ideas & approaches) & to inculcate a sense of inclusiveness to all & sundry in the process of evolution of the civilisation.This can happen if the victims of past groupism have enough resources to build their 'Networks',to ensure a sustainable modern self-support system.Till such time,the society has to provide network building & maintaining charges to citizens denied of existing modern supporting networks & it takes some time for human systems like say 'reservation' to percolate to various strata of a given caste,given human psychology is not same as that of a machine(unless,it is intended to create caste based ghettos & slums for cheap & compulsive labour by going into the denial mode).Only then,eventually can the present system of reservation become meaningless.But if economic criteria is used as a parameter for reservation,it ensures a 'Heads I win,Tails I win' situation for the castiests.Moreover,whereas caste based reservation is meant to give a corrective bias,in mostly economical only,to the gloom & disparities created by social biases, we mustn't give credit to a person for being 'Poor'.It would encourage able bodied people to shy away from economic activities and woul

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kallol Bala
Why no income based reservation...
by Kallol Bala on Sep 18, 2014 10:50 AM

Income can't & mustn't be a criteria for 'Reservation'.Reservation is given with a philosophy for uniformity in participation & representation of all citizens,in various organs of the society,with the intent to prevent monopoly,crony-capitalism,inducing fresh air(ideas & approaches) & to inculcate a sense of inclusiveness to all & sundry in the process of evolution of the civilisation.This can happen if the victims of past groupism have enough resources to build their 'Networks',to ensure a sustainable modern self-support system.Till such time,the society has to provide network building & maintaining charges to citizens denied of existing modern supporting networks & it takes some time for human systems like say 'reservation' to percolate to various strata of a given caste,given human psychology is not same as that of a machine(unless,it is intended to create caste based ghettos & slums for cheap & compulsive labour by going into the denial mode).Only then,eventually can the present system of reservation become meaningless.But if economic criteria is used as a parameter for reservation,it ensures a 'Heads I win,Tails I win' situation for the castiests.Moreover,whereas caste based reservation is meant to give a corrective bias,in mostly economical only,to the gloom & disparities created by social biases, we mustn't give credit to a person for being 'Poor'.It would encourage able bodied people to shy away from economic activities and woul

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Kallol Bala
Why no income based reservation...
by Kallol Bala on Sep 18, 2014 10:50 AM

Income can't & mustn't be a criteria for 'Reservation'.Reservation is given with a philosophy for uniformity in participation & representation of all citizens,in various organs of the society,with the intent to prevent monopoly,crony-capitalism,inducing fresh air(ideas & approaches) & to inculcate a sense of inclusiveness to all & sundry in the process of evolution of the civilisation.This can happen if the victims of past groupism have enough resources to build their 'Networks',to ensure a sustainable modern self-support system.Till such time,the society has to provide network building & maintaining charges to citizens denied of existing modern supporting networks & it takes some time for human systems like say 'reservation' to percolate to various strata of a given caste,given human psychology is not same as that of a machine(unless,it is intended to create caste based ghettos & slums for cheap & compulsive labour by going into the denial mode).Only then,eventually can the present system of reservation become meaningless.But if economic criteria is used as a parameter for reservation,it ensures a 'Heads I win,Tails I win' situation for the castiests.Moreover,whereas caste based reservation is meant to give a corrective bias,in mostly economical only,to the gloom & disparities created by social biases, we mustn't give credit to a person for being 'Poor'.It would encourage able bodied people to shy away from economic activities and woul

    Forward  |  Report abuse
romesh  morey
Why community based reservation should stop?
by romesh morey on Sep 17, 2014 05:42 PM

Doctor should talk about castism & caste differences in the country. Even well educated indians are differentiating & teaching their children the same. Doctor should talk & teach their students about the poison of racism. After 60 years of independence and well education we indians are still ileterate. We have money to offer to temples & worships but not the needy,we have time to go to temples & worship but we dont have time for the poor people. We should stop the community based reservation when their will be no caste differences, there will be no caste based marriages & caste will be the least factor. It means people should be identified as indians not as hindus, muslims, christian buddhist & so on.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sriram rao
abolish reservation from its entirety and remove corruption
by sriram rao on Sep 17, 2014 12:47 PM  | Hide replies

reservation of any kind is not good for the overall good, yes but govt can make alternate arrangements of monetary assistance or easy loans and waiveable loan schemes for example like how the farmers in various states are getting which will be good, current reservation system is hijacking the complete accountability process the moment a reservation pinches for example if some one from a reserved category person is doing a corrupt practice and goes higher in the corp ladder we are allowing it which is corrption

    Forward  |  'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
sriram rao
Re: abolish reservation from its entirety and remove corruption
by sriram rao on Sep 17, 2014 12:51 PM
i am not belonging to higher caste either i belong to bc if any one thinks i may be from a higher caste no not i too am from backward caste my comments are for the overall good to upheld faith of all

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
sriram chandra rao
Re: abolish reservation from its entirety and remove corruption
by sriram chandra rao on Sep 27, 2014 09:32 AM
GIVE MORE INDEPENDENCE TO STATES TO DECIDE TO SOLVE THEIR LOCAL PROBLEMS LOCALLY AND SEE HOW THE RESERVATION BLACK MARK ON OUR SYSTEM WILL DISAPPEAR TOTALLY IF IT IS LEFT IT TO STATES TO DECIDE

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sathishreddy
tn
by sathishreddy on Sep 17, 2014 10:14 AM

WELL SAID, NOW TAMILS ARE CHAGING IN TAMILNADU,NOW THEY REALIZED REALITY, SECONDLY RESERVATION CATEGORY LIKE MBC,SC,ST, BC ARE RICH IN TM.
50 YEARS BEFORE TN ONLY MOOTED CASTE BASED RESERVATION BY DRAVIDIAN PARTIES,DUE TO ANTI BRAHAMIN MOVEMENT.SINCE BRAHAMINS ARE TIMID CASTE EVERYBODY LIKED THEM,

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 189 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message