Discussion Board

Why India should focus on income-based reservation


Total 189 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
sriram chandra rao
truth is reservation will move us from a rural village living soc
by sriram chandra rao on Sep 27, 2014 06:19 AM

corruption is the net result out put of reservation as it will make us more dependent on stock market driven economy and will lead to more migration to cities and it will make more disturbed and croudy cities with lake of needy resources insted of having a vision of india leaves in villages which is our national leaders views like gandhi we will be moving to a city oriented civilization that is against the spirits of our nation building efforts.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Mahesh kumar
A bitter truth
by Mahesh kumar on Sep 22, 2014 12:32 PM  | Hide replies

I know an ST engineer man with Masters degree who fell in love with a maid belonging to BC and married her. Irony is that the relatives of woman blamed her for marrying a man inferior to her caste. This is the caste based discrimination going on in India. Actually the maid is lucky enough to have married an engineer, but the man is not being accepted by woman's relatives.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ganesh Nakkathaya
Re: A bitter truth
by Ganesh Nakkathaya on Jan 21, 2017 12:15 PM
Even I have read about similar cases. This mentality is there at all levels. How many rich SC/ST people support their brethern?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Santosh Kumar
Caste reservation is needed as long as society discriminates
by Santosh Kumar on Sep 22, 2014 09:35 AM  | Hide replies

Try marrying someone from another caste and you will realize India has not changed at the core. Some folks directly say alliances from lower castes to be excused. Even today in villages and towns, people from lower castes are prevented from using common facilities, as basic as drawing water from village well, different schools, no haircuts, etc.

People on this forum are folks who are all urban-based I guess, and do not know the ground reality in most of India.

Thousands of years of caste-based discrimination, which continues in more subtle forms today, cannot be wiped away with 60-70 years of reservation.

Get real please...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sriram chandra rao
Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discriminates
by sriram chandra rao on Dec 12, 2014 09:11 AM
what a white lie different schools just name a couple of village and their different category school names

   Forward   |   Report abuse
b g
Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discriminates
by b g on Jan 21, 2017 12:03 PM
When there is cast based reservations in the system then how can we do away the cast based system in real life. Let the cast system prevail and we get thirsty for each other's blood. Reservation is doing good to divide our community.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sriram rao
Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discriminates
by sriram rao on Oct 04, 2014 11:41 PM
get real and dare to ask yourself why gandhi did not marry outside of his caste get real please? Actually its personal to each one and it should not be disturbed by a unification

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sriram rao
Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discriminates
by sriram rao on Sep 22, 2014 02:56 PM
the commenters here are rurals but fled and became from rural to urbans, fledfrom country to other country due to your favours towards reservation

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sriram rao
Re: Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discrimina
by sriram rao on Sep 22, 2014 03:00 PM
also the govt intermediately needs to flee as well to support reservation

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sriram rao
Re: Re: Re: Caste reservation is needed as long as society discri
by sriram rao on Sep 22, 2014 03:03 PM
in search of investment cycles so that it can balance out to have reservation

   Forward   |   Report abuse
satyajit das
income based reservation must be adopted
by satyajit das on Sep 21, 2014 09:57 PM

Yes, income based reservation is need in modern India unless caste based. My personal opinion is remove caste based reservation. In India so many talented are out of competition due to caste reservation policy. govt must help poor people ( all caste) for their study but reservation in job must be removed.Everyone need job either poor or middle class.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
amar singh
Selection process
by amar singh on Sep 21, 2014 09:43 PM

Reservation in all sphere must be stopped.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
ACK satyasai
Non merit based reservations to be stopped
by ACK satyasai on Sep 21, 2014 07:08 PM

Non-Merit based reservations are injurious to development of a country. Needy shall be given financial benefits and NO relaxation for merit.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sriram rao
Cont... From Previous Message
by sriram rao on Sep 21, 2014 01:09 PM  | Hide replies

better know slowly becoming dependent on foreigners and loosing independence

so, immediate solution is independence and high level of integrity in accountancy and remove freebies and Reservation be banned.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Romesh Morey
Re: Cont... From Previous Message
by Romesh Morey on Sep 25, 2014 07:29 PM
If we have studied so deeply the repercussion of communal based reservation, we must study the requirement of the communal based reservation in INDIA, then the our research & study will be said as complete. Communal based reservation is made to uplift the lower caste people, who were not being touched, discriminated & alienated to come in main stream by so called higher caste people though they are the native of this land. The present scenario is little different, untouchability is still there but in rural areas. But in urban areas, people having in mind the caste differences. Still people get inquired about their caste for rent a house, some industries asking religion in their forms. The ways of discrimination is changed now. If communal based reservation will banned, the gap between lower caste people & self declared upper caste people will become more. But the mentality of these self declared upper caste people will remain same and in that situation the poverty, crime, communal riots will be increased. Colleges will make make more payment seats, where only non-eligible rich people will study & real talented person will have to loose it. Communal reservation is made according to the percentage of the communities and not blindly. We were and are still dependent on the foreigners because we indians are educated illiterates, our thinking is not revolutionary, we are having bound and conservative thinking. Cont...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sriram rao
Re: Re: Cont... From Previous Message
by sriram rao on Oct 04, 2014 10:40 PM
i belong to bc in one district and gc in another district tehsil norms and we had house in the scheduled caste i.e. bauri sahi which is the caste of swwpers and we born and brought up in the scheduled caste street, what kind of untouchablity practice you are talking about and this i am telling about a tehsil area it is just about few who tell themselves as a deprived by telling a BIG LIE BECAUSAE IF YOU TELL A VERY BIG LIE TO DISTURB THE SANATANA DISCIPLINE TO WHICH MAJOR OF OUR SOCIETY EVEN FROM SO CALLED LOWER CASTE STILL HOLD ON TO IT AT THE SAME TIME ENJOYS THE RESERVATION AT THE COST OF CORRUPTION SO RESERVATION BE BANNED.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Romesh Morey
Re: Re: Cont... From Previous Message
by Romesh Morey on Sep 25, 2014 08:09 PM
We still struct in the caste, superstition & imaginary stories. If we start a TV & see the indian channels, we will not find a single program that shows some development programs, technological developments, future science, etc.for the children. We will find Chhota Bheem, Bal Ganesh, Krishna, Jai Hanuman like cartoons. This is because to make the child addicted to this to catch the mind of the future generation, to keep them (Self Declared Upper Caste people) superior & upper hand. Hundreds of years these people dominates & discriminates the poor people in the name of lower caste & declared them self upper caste & other to Vaishya for bringing & arranging money for them & one more to Kshatria for protecting them from any enemies & kept the people under fear of god & let them do all worships as the rule & only from their hands only for easy money & superiority. But those reluctant to do this become lower castes & being alienated from the society as a punishment & further it written as shudras. This is how the castes generated. This is a hundreds & Hundreds years of planning of maintaining the superiority in the society. It will be very dangerous if the lower caste people come in the main stream. Their superiority may shattered. Talking all this is important because of existence of lower caste people in india.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
Romesh Morey
Re: Re: Cont... From Previous Message
by Romesh Morey on Sep 25, 2014 08:18 PM
We still struct in the caste, superstition & imaginary stories. If we start a TV & see the indian channels, we will not find a single program that shows some development programs, technological developments, future science, etc.for the children. We will find Chhota Bheem, Bal Ganesh, Krishna, Jai Hanuman like cartoons. This is because to make the child addicted to this to catch the mind of the future generation, to keep them (Self Declared Upper Caste people) superior & upper hand. Hundreds of years these people dominates & discriminates the poor people in the name of lower caste & declared them self upper caste & other to Vaishya for bringing & arranging money for them & one more to Kshatria for protecting them from any enemies & kept the people under fear of god & let them do all worships as the rule & only from their hands only for easy money & superiority. But those reluctant to do this become lower castes & being alienated from the society as a punishment & further it written as shudras. This is how the castes generated. This is a hundreds & Hundreds years of planning of maintaining the superiority in the society. It will be very dangerous if the lower caste people come in the main stream. Their superiority may shattered. Talking all this is important because to show existence of lower caste people in india. Unless this problem of caste-ism is solved we cannot stop the Communal Based Reservation.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Message deleted by moderator
sriram rao
Cont.. From Previous Message
by sriram rao on Sep 21, 2014 01:08 PM

there is only one option either reservation or corruption once reservation infiltrated in to system automatically its approved corruption by benefiter bypassing the compete route and the depriver any way will look for alternate way to make a livelihood


Reservation is like a double loot on system why? answer,
the benefiter of Reservation loots with a default attitude not to compete healthy with a spirit of "Har Haath Loot Har Honth Jhoot the congress way" and any way the depriver General Category left with nooption and an nicely educated willtake a Citizenship of other country or becomes hostile to the systems
ITS LOSS LOSS FOR ALL

RESERVATION IS LOSS AND ON ECONOMY ENVIRONMENT EDUCATION and EVERYTHING you can thinkof

Current problem of Reservation"Split based on community and Leak the Resources in form currency" through investment cycles: which is totally unacceptable, the sc st bc who call themselves lower layer are directionless as they are thinking very narrow mindedly to get one or the other advantage in the form of all discounts, if so take an scenario and analyze what will happen the consequence of it"

To a Lower layer gentlemen if the govt gives tax waiver, no fees for education, no fees for travelling, no tax, no electiricity bill payment
Question: what is the out put: A Gap in the accountancy of the Govt Administration and hence Govt has to pull in huge foreign investment to fill that gap for the short term and long term consequence you

    Forward  |  Report abuse
sriram rao
NOCONSISTENT GROWTH": Righteous Quality Consistent Growth Mi
by sriram rao on Sep 21, 2014 01:07 PM

Loosing the Spirit of "CONSISTENT GROWTH": Righteous Quality Consistent Growth the reason is "Corruption" which is By Product of "Reservation"


1984's pandoras box busted in 1991's and 2000 slow downs
Need immediate attention by the Modi Govt
Finally The Reasons Behind the 1991 2010's meltdowns are out here in this article, there is a discrimination practice in the current community based reservation which will only recur the slowdown incidents in future due to injustice and discrimination to a section in the name of minority appeasement and Loosing the Spirit of "CONSISTENT GROWTH".


Accurate analysis 65 Years still no Righteous Quality Consistent Growth the reason is "Corruption" which is By Product of "Reservation", If "Reservation" continues further Yes Stock Market and SEBI will take over Indians Future Decision Makers, Not Govt any more "Jiska Khaya Ushika Liy"


reservation of any kind is not good for the overall good, yes but govt can make alternate arrangements of monetary assistance or easy loans and waiveable loan schemes for example like how the farmers in various states are getting which will be good, current reservation system is hijacking the complete accountability process the moment a reservation pinches for example if some one from a reserved category person is doing a corrupt practice and goes higher in the corp ladder we are allowing it which is corrption

Cont...


    Forward  |  Report abuse
sriram rao
Split based on community and Leak the Resources in form currency
by sriram rao on Sep 21, 2014 12:46 PM

Current problem of Reservation"Split based on community and Leak the Resources in form currency" through investment cycles: which is totally unacceptable, the sc st bc who call themselves lower layer are directionless as they are thinking very narrow mindedly to get one or the other advantage in the form of all discounts, if so take an scenario and analyze what will happen the consequence of it"

To a Lower layer gentlemen if the govt gives tax waiver, no fees for education, no fees for travelling, no tax, no electiricity bill payment
Question: what is the out put: A Gap in the accountancy of the Govt Administration and hence Govt has to pull in huge foreign investment to fill that gap for the short term and long term consequence you better know slowly becoming dependent on foreigners and loosing independence

so, immediate solution is independence and high level of integrity in accountancy and remove freebies and Reservation be banned.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 189 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message