what HRD DID IS GOOD FOR THE NATION AND PUPIL. WHAT IS NECESSARY TO STUDY GERMAN. THOSE WHO NEED GERMAN STUDY AS THEY WISH. SAMSKRUTHA IS ANCIENT BHARATHIYA LANGUAGE,
Sanskrit Latin and third language r 3 basic languages I think there must be one common mother tongue of these 3 also lingua franca so like computer languages these languages must be simple as possible biggest problem of sanskrit is that 4000 rules of Panini made sanskrit toughest
Re: Lingua francs
by bigben bigben on Nov 23, 2014 01:18 PM
not true. sanskrit is actually easiest to learn if taught properly. it is also the most unambiguous language, and accepted widely as the language most directly suitable for computer programming.
how many of those advocating to impose sanskrit on the children know the language themselves. If a student learns German he stands a better chance to study in Germany if he opts ...what will the student do with Sanskrit.....hypocrits
Re: sanskrit as base
by bigben bigben on Nov 23, 2014 01:20 PM
let whoever wants opportunities in germany learn german in their spare time. why should 100s of millions of children learn german for 10 people to go to germany?
Re: sanskrit as base
by Shri Hegde on Nov 23, 2014 11:08 AM
how many learn german and end up in germany for 1 out 1000 students, 999 have to learn a foreign language ...moronos
Sanskrit must be made compulsory. only then people will know what truth??? lies hidden in bhraminical texts.. Else they will keep thinking that there is satellite design hidden there.
SANSKRIT is the mother of languages hence it should be learnt by all. Knowing more languages is definetly to the adavantage. No should be stopped from learning other languages though.
Re: SANSKRIT CONTROVERSY..
by SivaSankaran Sarma on Nov 23, 2014 10:49 AM
No its not and stop posting and repeating the same lies thinking it becomes the truth
Re: SANSKRIT CONTROVERSY..
by jhatu on Nov 23, 2014 10:53 AM
Another Modiyapa Bhakt! Did your Mather & Fatter learnt sanskrit? Then why you are forcing this vomit? German is in yede!
Why only all this attention to Sanskrit by the Indian government and not to Tamil that is India's most ancient and other classical language. That has also equally influenced all modern Indian languages Indian culture and the Hindu religion. Modern Indian culture and the Hindu religion is more than 75% Dravidian. Even most Indians are Dravidian. They may not speak Dravidian but largely Dravidian by race. So one treatment for Sanskrit and another for Tamil. This smacks of selective cultural and imagined racial superiority by certain sections of the ruling elite, to praise one Indian classical language and completely ignore the other
Now a days science has proved that the best language for computers is only sanskrit. And its the fake dependent mentality imposed on Indians by the ancient foreign rulers that foreign language is best for development. If so then how Japan has prospered ahead adopting Japanese language as the medium of study in their country? How China prospers where chinese language is given priority? So its the real time for we Indians to come out of that illusion that any foreign language can make us to prosper. Rather the ancient sanskrit language only has the potency to make a powerful education system enabling us to lead the world which we have forgotten. Its the right time to start now.
Re: Sanskrit is the base language from which all other languages
by SivaSankaran Sarma on Nov 23, 2014 10:39 AM
Sanskrit is not the base language for all languages. Who told you this? It is only the base language for Indo Aryan languages. The base languages for other Indo European languages is not Sanskrit but others. The base language for Dravidian languages is old/classical Tamil. Sanskrit has borrowed quite as much from Dravidian as Dravidian has from Sanskrit. Tamil has borrowed more words from Sanskrit than Sanskrit has from Dravidian. It is a trivial thing for a language to borrow vocabulary. But when it uses another language's syntax to form the way it expresses things, and uses another language's phonology for its sounds, that is really profound influence. The fact is, Sanskrit HAS been influenced in this way by Dravidian. Of course, some Dravidian languages have also borrowed Sanskrit sounds (bh, etc.) But none of the four Dravidian languages I have read has borrowed anything from Sanskrit syntax . Much of the syntax of Sanskrit is Dravidian, and it has a large Dravidian vocabulary. Its system of phonetics is profoundly influenced by Dravidian -- Indo-Aryan is the only IE family with retroflexes. The word Dravidian clearly comes from the word Tamil. This has been demonstrated time and time again -- the earliest occurrences of the word in IA are dramiDa ==> draviDa.
Re: Re: Sanskrit is the base language from which all other langua
by ravi khot on Nov 23, 2014 10:48 AM
so then we shall follow german , chinnese etc and neglect our own language. we do not have an identity of our own. all counties co ordinate in there in naive language and we fools are using english. offcourse it is giving bread and butter to us but whant about ou identity in overall senario.
Re: Re: Re: Sanskrit is the base language from which all other la
by SivaSankaran Sarma on Nov 23, 2014 03:14 PM
Learn Tamil far more older , living, classical, as rich as Sanskrit and contributed a lot to modern Indian languages and culture and Hinduism like Sanskrit and truly Indian and not an import from Central Asia, if you want to learn a truly Indian language
Re: No one has a right to impose a language on another
by SivaSankaran Sarma on Nov 23, 2014 10:30 AM
What is modern India is an artificial creation of the British, that was made up of many former kingdoms and empires, that spoke many languages and cultures. If you want to maintain this unity then stop imposing certain languages or language on others falsely in the name of national unity. It is not national unity but smacks of selective racial cultural imperialism, just like the British did. People will learn languages that they feel, is useful to them in their work communication and studies. Do not forcibly impose languages on others in the name of majorities, culture of religion it will never work and people will rebel
Any subject not having much relevance for Livelihood or survival should be optional only, in long term it’s good for maintaining peace and harmony in Society.
After becoming expert in Sanskrit, what Carrier option do people have? Other than becoming priest in marriages or other Hindu ceremonies and read from holy books written in Sanskrit.
How many Brahmins, who can read holy Sanskrit books, does the Society need to function properly? Too much off them might create trouble.
Re: Re: Well..
by Kanu Singh on Nov 23, 2014 10:17 AM
I studied Sanskrit as a basic subject from class 6 to 8, I think that much knowledge is enough to raise doubt and start my personal research, in case an expert Brahmin try to make fool of me while translating from a holy Sanskrit book during a religious ceremony.
Re: Well..
by ramdev Bhattacharya on Nov 23, 2014 10:37 AM
It should be optional...should nt burden on students...better to remove hindi and add Sanskrit in schools.
