Dragging this case again means...either the CBI is worthless OR Nodia police (which we all know) OR Narco Analysis test OR may be all 3 of them..Seriously, once the Narco test proved the innocence of talwars why make them go thru it again.. This case is becoming pointless. India should ban Narco test just like other nations if you dont honour the test results.
Re: Stupid
by Mast Ram on Feb 10, 2011 10:18 PM
Well, Noida police screwed it up. They didn't collected the evidences correctly otherwise it would have been known who all were present in the house. You can imagine it, when they didn't find the blood trail leading to Hemraj, what was their performance. This gave killer's enough time to clear the evidences. Be it talwar or the servants. CBI took over after a month or two. I don't expect them to find any evidence that was not collected by police. So their investigation has to be based on police collective evidences or narco tests/interrogation. So even if they know (by interrogations) that talwar's did it, they can not prove it in the court. I think we should pay homage to Aarushi, and say sorry that her killer can still live like he didn't do any thing.
Hard to imagine that parents could murder their own daughter, that too the only child. Talwars say that Arushi was born through an IVF process after the couple were childless for several years. In these conditions, motive part for parents seem to be missing.
If anything, this case only shows the decay of police forces and investigative agencies. They seem to be completely ill-trained or lacking analytical skills.
Re: Hard to imagine...
by Sachidanand Gupta on Feb 10, 2011 10:17 PM
Honour killing is usually motiveless and a result of spurt of anger, may be on seeing their daughter/sister in objectionable state.
Re: Hard to imagine...
by Mast Ram on Feb 10, 2011 10:21 PM
Well if you follow crime news enough, you will see there is no such relationship where a murder is not possible. "Meera Road rape case", "dehradoon rajesh gulati case" and many more.
aarushi's murderer will come in the light only when destiny will reveal, but this is surely a searchlight on today's parents who can't give time to their kids...it's time for awakening for many talwars and aarushis...
Re: NOT Real Daughter
by Sunny on Feb 10, 2011 09:00 PM
You are correct....They have stolen it from some nursing home...they didnt have any child of own...
Re: Re: NOT Real Daughter
by IndianGuy on Feb 10, 2011 09:10 PM
LOL... CBI had several INTUITIONS just like you did.. We know the results of those INTUTIONS BUT... you do have a good point :) keep writing your INTUITIONS.. ;)
Re: NOT Real Daughter
by prem k on Feb 10, 2011 09:14 PM
Even if what you are saying is true, it does not give a motive or prove anything. People get attached to even a pet that they have seen grow in front of them. And she was a girl. Even if she had been adopted, there is no motive to kill her and in fact all the more reason to believe that her parents are innocent. Why should they kill a girl after giving her a life?
Every day a new GHOTALA is out. Don't you guys think that Govt. is trying to divert all attention from Ghotalas and Mehengai Dayan!! Very clever trick played in the Media by the Govt. Focus on one family and " ALL IZZ Well' HAHAHAH!! Gr8 Democracy !! Gr8 People!! Love India.....
Re: Political Game by Congress!!!
by Herry on Feb 10, 2011 08:58 PM
everything is planned by congress.anything happens in this country is planed by congress. Even if ur wife gives birth to a kid its planned by congress.
Thinking as a parent, why & how did they take it for granted that the servant had killed, even if so what was the motive for that man, he had not stolen anything, his belongings were all there, there was no scuffle....even after the postmortem, why such hurry to dispose the body....as a caring parent, you want to find evidence, not get rid of them,how could anyone clean the golf clubs without them knowing? the other servants how would thy know to cover up so well.... if 3-4 guys did so much how can any normal human beings sleep through the event? what kind of a sleep is that? there is lot more to everything.... parents really do have some role to play in the whole issue.... what about her friends,everything has to be done by some educated, tech savvy person & not those poor servant boys...
Re: Re: not so clear parents
by Sachidanand Gupta on Feb 10, 2011 10:21 PM
Sunny,
Imagination horses running on full steam, harness those may go out of track very easily. This is not your usual sleaze and violence bollywood movie, this is real life with real people and real murder.
Re: not so clear parents
by sukhmeet singh on Feb 10, 2011 08:58 PM
u are right..... from the very begining the doubt was on parents.. how they misguided the police by not telling them abt servant death up-stairs and then by not giving police the key to staircase... and then by removing all the evidence ... shows that parents have a CLEAR role.
