who ever acts...which ever films...what ever films - discussion boards fills with Shah Rukh Khan - that is the name, that is the brand...avoid him..nail him... - but U never can reject him, that is - SRK The King..
Whenever srk movie releases, rediff start promoting it in advance and most of the time his movies are crap just like OSO, MNIK etc but when other make it, rediff has a long story to say about the short coming. Please if you cannot support the fellow indian hardwork than stop making comment on it. Lots of people make a day and night hardword, u urself put so much hardwork on this website but if u will not respect other works, no body is going to respect u as well
Re: Shahrukh khan hit
by Forrest Gump on Apr 17, 2010 09:23 PM
hahaha...jealous fool supporting the likes of shahid who are not even 1% of SRK's personality and brand.
if it were an srk-j0har docu-melo-drama then characters wud never have been 'unidimensional with no grey shades', sets like those in rnbdj wudnt have been 'cardboard-like' and performances wud have been oscar winning. diff standards for diff people. very rediff-like!
It seems that rediff management is furious from bollywood & hindi movies as all the movies have altogether a bad verdict. Wud request u to stop this practice & let the viewers be a bettr judge.
It has now became a trend for rediff review to rate good movies as bad and horrible movies as excellent. Recent example is of LSD which was worse docudrama ever seen still rated as 5* and several gud movies rated 1*. Rediff has lost its reliability.
Re: LSD rated as 5* and gud movies 1*
by Prashant Kumar on Apr 16, 2010 06:37 PM
LSD was crap...I hope this movie should be good. Off late Shahid has improved a lot and has given some good hits. Moreover the graetest harm you could ever do to a movie is to go by Rediff's review. Remember they rated 3Idiots as 1* initially. Rediff reviewers are either insane or have been hired with lowest salry or perk (in other sense waste guys) or are bribed well by Biggies (no need to mention names)
Re: Re: LSD rated as 5* and gud movies 1*
by shounak ray on Apr 17, 2010 02:42 AM
LSD got good reviews from cnn-ibn, ndtv, indian express, mid-day, mumbai mirror, hindustand times, indiatimes..should i overlook these as well?
I request rediff management to stop this practice. Earlier they had given very poor remarks on 3 Idiot which later on has great sucess.In fact I have lost faith on this portfolio of rediff
Re: Stop review
by nikhil gupta on Apr 16, 2010 05:03 PM
hey i totally agree with you
i dont know why they are against each and every film. this system just can;t be trusted.. they can take out flaw from even sachin tendulkar if they were asked to review a cricket match....
It's all about how you pay rediff. Love Sex Dhokha was given the highest rating and it was a terrible movie to watch even for half an hour. Rediff please give your fair opinion given the chance that you enjoy the affinity of the readers on your articles.
Re: Fair analysis pls
by shounak ray on Apr 16, 2010 05:16 PM
well..why single out rediff?..cnn ibn, ndtv, mid-day, indian express all gave it a good review.It is 8.3 on imdb.And of course, you would so easily claim that it is all a conspiracy and the journalists and even the imdb have been paid to do all this. But don't you think the makers of 3 idiots, My name is Khan or Paa would pay rediff a bigger amount than say a movie like LSD would. The makers of a movie such as 3 idiots have a much stroger clout-the wife of the producer-Anupama chopra is a renowned film critic and is apparently good friend with Rajeev Masand, Raja Sen and the likes. I do not understand Why film critics are so badly looked down upon-why are they judged with so much cynicism? If we don't like a particular review, then fair enough. 3 idiots got a rating of 2 on rediff, but did that stop the movie from becoming the biggest hit??So, why vent out such mean words for these guys? And a larger question-why are forums on rediff turning into platforms for such vicious name-calling?
Re: Re: Fair analysis pls
by shounak ray on Apr 16, 2010 05:18 PM
well..why single out rediff?..cnn ibn, ndtv, mid-day, indian express all gave LSD a good review.It is 8.3 on imdb.And of course, you would so easily claim that it is all a conspiracy and the journalists and even the imdb have been paid to do all this. But don't you think the makers of 3 idiots, My name is Khan or Paa would pay rediff a bigger amount than say a movie like LSD would. The makers of a movie such as 3 idiots have a much stroger clout-the wife of the producer-Anupama chopra is a renowned film critic and is apparently good friend with Rajeev Masand, Raja Sen and the likes. I do not understand Why film critics are so badly looked down upon-why are they judged with so much cynicism? If we don't like a particular review, then fair enough. 3 idiots got a rating of 2 on rediff, but did that stop the movie from becoming the biggest hit??So, why vent out such mean words for these guys? And a larger question-why are forums on rediff turning into platforms for such vicious name-calling?
Frankly even Taare zameen par was like a documentary drama by films division but it was still appreciated .So paathshala is also in the same category according to reviewer.
