Re: Why Congress use national Tricolor???????
by SkShazid on May 26, 2009 01:30 PM
i agree if a party can use national tricolor with some changes why not a person can use national anthem with some changes.
Re: Why Congress use national Tricolor???????
by slayer slayer on May 26, 2009 12:58 PM
hows he disrespectful when hes projecting the status quo of our society?? hes expressing an irony which i think is great creativity... its just ppls habit to bash him up for anything and everything
Re: Re: Why Congress use national Tricolor???????
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:18 PM
wat the society has got to do for his disrespect to national anthem, all society is trying is to protecting our anthem...yeah.. we dont want him to distort anything that is national...
Re: Re: Re: Why Congress use national Tricolor???????
by SkShazid on May 26, 2009 01:31 PM
like the national flag too? that means u support for not using distorted tricolor with a hand in center.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why Congress use national Tricolor???????
by SkShazid on May 26, 2009 02:05 PM
oops it hurts bcoz i might have talked about the party u just voted. OR May be national anthem is ultimate and national flag is not. OR May be your party have right to do such things but not someone whom u don't support. OR May be you are a hypocrat.
Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by NISHANT SINGH on May 26, 2009 12:54 PM
years ago someone in US posted video on Youtube of gandhi look alike doin pole dance... and indians went crazy as a result video was removed
wat shameful gagging of freedom of expression
i am damn sure had that person been in india ..indians wd have killed him and molested women in his house.. in name of patriotism
I beleive in 100% FOE even if it means demeaning country, religion and everything sacred...infact only then it wd really be freedom of expression
Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:00 PM
yeah, u cannot do anything and everything in the name of freedom... shall i paint ur family women without dress and post in in youtube.....
Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by SkShazid on May 26, 2009 01:32 PM
Nishant i agree on your statement to an extent but sathya has a good question. I hope u'll live upto your words in this matter and will avoid any sort of hypocracy.
Re: Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:31 PM
i think i am better than u cheap a-ole
Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by Satyan Kamath on May 26, 2009 01:41 PM
i want to role with nishant singh's other half, uski biwi ya uski ladki and nishant wouldnt object, man he likes freedom of expression, i want to express a lot with his other half and nishant wouldnt mind a wee bit
Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by Vitty Vits on May 26, 2009 01:27 PM
There is a diff bn freedom of expression and freedom of bakwas. The commercial film makers have only money in their mind. Creativity is Dead, they can only think of making Remixes in the name of songs or copy in the name of remaking. Creating controversies for commercial gains is now an old phenomenon in Indian Film Industry which is rightfully renamed as Bollywood for copying everything from Hollywood and not feel ashamed about it.
Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by Nitin Jain on May 26, 2009 12:52 PM
Freedom of expression can never mean the freedom of disrespect to nation and its symbols. As an artist, you cant do anything that hurts the feelings of fellow nationals.
Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by NISHANT SINGH on May 26, 2009 12:58 PM
MR NITIN
what is freedom of expression if its not for the thinking dat provokes
Man by ur logic even taliban provide freedom of expression ..bcoz they wont do anything to people who speak things they want to hear
ANYTHING THAT HURTS THE FELLOW NATIONALS... and yet it is not gagged... das the real freedom of expression
Wat u r saying and people like u..which are 99.99999% in our country and countries like ours...
'Speak wattever u like, as much u like.. but only that which i like... bcoz i beleive in freedom of expression"
National symbols are not some sacred stuff.... we as people even abuse God when v get upset... so v can abuse god and god doesnt hit us back.... what value dese national symbols have... nothing
i hope someday u people will understand meaning of freedom of expression
Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:03 PM
hihihi.... u talk like a fifth grade student and call that as freedom .. highlight of comedy....better freedom is not given to ppl like u ....u will laugh at the person who spanks ur m-om calling that also as freedom (as long as ur m-om doesnt complain)
Re: Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by SkShazid on May 26, 2009 01:35 PM
sathya u r not getting points of nishant. his thoughts is beyond nation which I support because borders are created by human and we sd not be fanatic for it. Again someone sd not use it as ur weakpoint and exploit the peace.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDI
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:41 PM
hey shazid....his basic itself is wrong... anything that hurst fellow nationals but it should not be gagged ...who has got any right do that .... buddy wats wrong with all of u...
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDI
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:38 PM
no.. but u r a certified son-of-w-re
Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by abhisek jain on May 26, 2009 01:29 PM
Well sorry to say but u've got the whole concept of FEd wrong. As it does not empower an individual to disrespect of hurt someone feeling just as the cost of his pleasure or entertainment or 4 others. If FED is what you said that anybody has got the right to disrespect any lady on the road do any ill things with her, disgrace her and what not. And all this do not fall under vindict of FED. If this is FED that the person who made a cartoon out of Hazrat ohammad should be hoarded with prizes and the mentally sick person who made a naked painting out of Indian godesses should be praised but does not happend. Just think logically why?????????????
Re: Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by Nitin Jain on May 26, 2009 01:03 PM
Talibanese also do the same thing. Speak whaever they like. do whatever they like. They can destroy the staue of Lord Budhdha. It is their freedom of expression. They dont care for the feelngs of their fellow nationals or their neibours. In the name of freedom of expression, you cant be allowed the walk naked on the road.
Re: Re: RGV i have sympathy...welcome to TALIBAN INDIA
by slayer slayer on May 26, 2009 12:57 PM
hows he disrespectful when hes projecting the status quo of our society?? hes expressing an irony which i think is great creativity... its just ppls habit to bash him up for anything and everything
Re: Rehman distorts vandemataram its OK its secular
by Nitin Jain on May 26, 2009 12:58 PM
Rehman has never and disrecpected National song. He has rather made it more famous.
Re: Rehman distorts vandemataram its OK its secular
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 12:51 PM
rehmann did not distort, he praised, but this a-ole director wants cheap stunt and cannot allow this to happen.....
Re: Re: Rehman distorts vandemataram its OK its secular
by sarathy narayanan on May 26, 2009 01:03 PM
by mean time vandemathram is not a national anthem , It is a patriotic song to which the tunes and orchestration can be changed on based of the situation
Re: Re: Re: Rehman distorts vandemataram its OK its secular
by sathyamoorthi anbalagan on May 26, 2009 01:24 PM
dear anirban..... why do u need that kind of publicity when the fellow countrymen doesnt like ur way of publicity ....its same as saying i wont allow anyone to disrespect my family .....i dont agree with anyone who plays with national icons..
Re: Re: ok what shuld be done (punishment)
by shritesh avlani on May 26, 2009 12:55 PM
I really liked the theme. What he is trying to express via that song is what we all have in our heart (90% of india). And I also accept the bitter truth. But our National Anthem should not be tempered.
I remember when there was a marathi play by the name of "Me Nathuram Godse Boltoy", it was banned as it was against Gandhi. Now RGV is asked not to defame the National Anthem. How come Hussain is allowed to paint Hindu goddess nude in the name of artistic freedom?
Is the artistic freedom a right of the select few or the religion and politics play a role here. Being a hindu is being communalist. Jai Ho!!
Re: Long live the Pseudo Democracy in our country
by Nitin Jain on May 26, 2009 12:56 PM
So what do you mean to say? If Hussain has committed some idiotic nuisance, RGV also whould be allowed to do the same thing?
Re: Re: Long live the Pseudo Democracy in our country
by Abhishek Sharma on May 26, 2009 04:27 PM
My only point is: There are two yardsticks to judge actions. Just to give you an example: The honorable Supreme Court in the year 2005 preached tolerance when 10 students who refused to sing National Anthem in a Kerala school were expelled. Why is there no tolerance in this case? I think that one should look at the intentions, and not the actions alone when dealing with art. By the way, have you heard the lyrics of what RGV has done in rann?
Re: Re: Long live the Pseudo Democracy in our country
by Abhishek Sharma on May 26, 2009 04:28 PM
My only point is: There are two yardsticks to judge actions. Just to give you an example: The honorable Supreme Court in the year 2005 preached tolerance when 10 students who refused to sing National Anthem in a Kerala school were expelled. Why is there no tolerance in this case? I think that one should look at the intentions, and not the actions alone when dealing with art. By the way, have you heard the lyrics of what RGV has done in rann?
