Well, a sad news ..!! but we r not short of good movies..!! we've got A wednesday! even Ckompanyy would have been good if it was well directed, the story was pretty good!!!
I have seen the movie....and these sort of movies shld go for oscars...TZP is a commercial movie..made for money making..dont compare it with KJ's DDLJ or any other movie...
Re: Slumdog Millionaire
by madan kumar on Jan 14, 2009 06:19 PM
Just another aamir hater or shah rukh lover I think. Only people from those two groups can talk of such obnoxious things.
Re: TZP is not worth.
by Td Ed on Jan 14, 2009 05:18 PM
what about Monsoon Wedding or if u talk about proper hindi cinema...we have Saraansh, Ek Ruka Hua Faisala, the list is endless.....
Re: Re: TZP is not worth.
by saurabh wahi on Jan 14, 2009 05:55 PM
Ek Ruka hua faisla was a remake of '12 angry men'. Monsoon wedding did not make it to the Oscars list because we decided to send Lagaan instead...
TZP may be a milestone in Indian cinema,but if you took the pain to see some of the foreign films like Waltz with Bashir or Meinhoff Complex,you'd know we have a long way to go before we could compete in that category. How I wish a movie like Slumdog was made by an indian film maker(no offence Danny Boyle,I love you too!),like a Sekhar Kapur or Anurag kashyap or some of the other young talents out there.
Re: TZP
by ramen das on Jan 14, 2009 04:43 PM
yes..Black Friday was one world class movie that was ruined by its own foolish system & ignored by own foolish countrymen...& now they cry foul over Trash movies not getting Oscars...
Re: Re: TZP
by pankaj agarwal on Jan 14, 2009 05:08 PM
You are right. We could have got an Oscar much earlier had we selected right movies. Like "Hazaron Khaweshe Aise" which never went to Oscars.
Sholay, Mother India, Barsat, Mughal-e-azam, DDLJ, Pyasa, ... does not get any international awards. It does not mean that theywere not great films. Time has come that we must stop begging for oscar or any other international awards and concentrate to taking Indian filmaking to that height that the international community themselves feel honour to nominate our films for their awards. We have got the talent and potential and our directors or actors are no lesser than their international counterparts.
Re: Re: why Oscar?
by pankaj agarwal on Jan 14, 2009 05:16 PM
It's no point putting your point Ramen here because most of the guys who are talking about greatness of Hindi cinema have actually not seen best of Hindi Cinema.
Re: Re: why Oscar?
by ratnadeep ray on Jan 14, 2009 04:50 PM
Rightly said. Movies like DDLJ are meant for only making money. As far as Sholay is concerned it was the copy of Good, bad and the Ugly. So no international award for it.
Re: Re: Re: why Oscar?
by ramen das on Jan 14, 2009 04:55 PM
slight correction...sholay was copied from "magnificent seven" which was itself a copy of "seven samurai"....along with "influences" from many other movies...
Re: Re: Re: why Oscar?
by parth kulkarni on Jan 14, 2009 05:12 PM
Kindly get your facts right or atleast refer to correct foriegn publications which u might feel are last words in movie-making.
Re: Re: Re: why Oscar?
by ramen das on Jan 14, 2009 05:07 PM
Indian public always loved trash because they had no other options... films like Hum aapke hain kaun, vivah, dhoom 2, all govinda movies...all are gigantic trashes...
Re: Re: Re: Re: why Oscar?
by ratnadeep ray on Jan 14, 2009 05:31 PM
I know this. Indian people always want hero and heroine to run around the trees and marry in the end. If they do this then the movie is good or else the movie is trash.
Re: Re: Re: why Oscar?
by sanket bhatnagar on Jan 14, 2009 07:42 PM
mother india came out in 1957 merely 10 yrs of india getting indepence. u should praise such a movie and if u think ddlj was oscar worthy, then u do not deserve to be in this discussion.
I BET ITS OUT WITHOUT A VIEW THATS WAT HAPENS WITH OUR MOVIES AND SM OF THE PEOPLE ABOVE CONDEMING THE MOVIE ARE DOING IT IN FRUSTATION FOR Me BLACK AND TZP AND SALAAM BOMBAY WERE POTENTIAL WINNERS AT OSCARS NOT JUST THE BEST FOREIGN FILM BT MAIN AWARDS TOO ANYWAYS BLACK WASENT SENT,SALAAM BOMBAY WAS TOO GUD FOR OSCARS AND TZP DINT GET A CHANCE TO SHOWCASE ITSELF I HOPE 1 DAY WE'LL WIN BT NOW IN MY EYES OSCARS HAVE LOST CREDIBILITY
I HAVE JUST WATCHED SLUMDOG MILLIONARE ITS FANTABULUS BUT IT IS NOT EVEN NEAR TO MOVIES I MENTIONEDE ABOVE
Re: roshan
by ramen das on Jan 14, 2009 04:33 PM
u havn't seen anything... black was utter bakwas.... Salam Bombay got nominated to its credit...but Pelle the Conqueror won...I'm sure u've never heard of tht... TZP was another confused piece where he wasn't sure whether to go ofbeat or please the crowd...
Movies like TZP have been made in other countries since ages.. its only now that the Indian cinema spoke abt Autism... It might be new to india but old to west!! Its a good movie tho... but prolly dint bring anything new to the table..
I BET ITS OUT WITHOUT A VIEW THATS WAT HAPENS WITH OUR MOVIES AND SM OF THE PEOPLE ABOVE CONDEMING THE MOVIES ARE DOING IT IN FRUSTATION FOR MR BLACK AND TZP AND SALAAM BOMBAY WERE POTENTIAL WINNERS AT OSCARS NOT JUST THE BEST FOREIGN FILM BT MAIN AWARDS TOO ANYWAYS BLACK WASENT SENT,SALAAM BOMBAY WAS TOO GUD FOR OSCARS AND TZP DINT GET A CHANCE TO SHOWCASE ITSELF I HOPE 1 DAY WE'LL WIN BT NOW IN MY EYES OSCARS HAVE LOST CREDIBILITY
I HAVE JUST WATCHED SLUMDOG MILLIONARE ITS FANTABULUS BUT IT IS NOT EVEN NEAR TO MOVIES I MENTIONEDE ABOVE
I BET ITS OUT WITHOUT A VIEW THATS WAT HAPENS WITH OUR MOVIES AND SM OF THE PEOPLE ABOVE CONDEMING THE MOVIES ARE DOING IT IN FRUSTATION FOR MR BLACK AND TZP AND SALAAM BOMBAY WERE POTENTIAL WINNERS AT OSCARS NOT JUST THE BEST FOREIGN FILM BT MAIN AWARDS TOO ANYWAYS BLACK WASENT SENT,SALAAM BOMBAY WAS TOO GUD FOR OSCARS AND TZP DINT GET A CHANCE TO SHOWCASE ITSELF I HOPE 1 DAY WE'LL WIN BT NOW IN MY EYES OSCARS HAVE LOST CREDIBILITY
I HAVE JUST WATCHED SLUMDOG MILLIONARE ITS FANTABULUS BUT IT IS NOT EVEN NEAR TO MOVIES I MENTIONEDE ABOVE
