I feel Aamirs Tare Jamin Par was superb and touchy. Slumdog wins West because it shows Indian poverty and most white people love to see India as a country of slums.As the film leaves barely any impression on us, I believe those who favor this film still are doing so to make dollars at the cost of Indian poverty.
Saw it on the first day... you would be moved by a good movie, you would have scenes/situations to remember to recollect… none of this happened to me at least.
Ok, there is lot of discussion on what kind of a movie this is…lets take those.
A hardcore realistic portrayal of poor India: It does not fit in hear. You would have had many points by now to go against the word “realistic”. May be the things shown about the slum life is true but mixed with lot of other unrealistic aspects removes the overall realism from the movie.
A spellbinding fiction with an Indian slum touch: This would be closer. But, for a fiction I would expect more ‘wow’ scenes, scenes pushing you to tears or engrossing script/screenplay.
No single emotion carried through the movie nor was any single emotion defined. One main thing that runs across the movie, the lead pair’s love, even that did not reach me.
And for the music, it’s great but not his best. I did not find anything that justifies a 10 Oscar nomination movie. Yes we can be happy for Indian(s) making it big globally. But how they managed it is not clear. I think this movie would help in understanding the long debated credibility of Oscars.
I would compare it to a “Bhelpuri” made with 80% correct ingredients without any salt!!!
Re: Felt something to be missing
by piyush jansari on Jan 25, 2009 10:37 PM
HELLO ALL THE READERS First try to erase the news about awards to SDM. Now see the movie. This movie has lots of good points. Struggle of a small boy. Direction...etc etc.. BUT....BUT... What message you get when you walk out of movie hall is?????????????????? What things keeps on running in your thoughts??????????? what indirect subconscious message enters our brain???????????? FILTH POVERTY GUTTERS CHILD EXPLOITATION SEX BHAILOG... EVEN BAD PART IN CHARACTER OF ANIL KAPOOR GIVING A WRONG HINT (THIS WAS NOT EXPECTED IN MOVIE!).. Getting award is really great achievement.But this movie is a brain child of outsider about India.. It is English movie dubbed in Hindi. Agreed our politicians are not doing any thing for the slums... agreed its a reality.. But do we need to enlarge it? And enlarging it will help to reduce it? Also why showing the Internal problem to other countries in Glorified way? I feel its our own foolishness that we Indians are happy for getting award for this movie in west which is showing negative things about our country. If you think about the performances, no doubt they deserve what ever the nominations etc etc.. BUT THE SUBJECT PROBABLY HARMS INDIA MORE THAT IT IS GOING TO BENEFIT. I STRONGLY RECOMMEND ALL THE READERS TO SEE THIS MOVIE AND DECIDE HOW YOU FEEL AFTER THE SHOW.
Re: Re: Felt something to be missing
by Elango Narayanaswamy on Jan 26, 2009 07:31 AM
Oops!! I come from the exactly opposite school of thought :)
"Erase the news about awards to SDM" - this is easier said than done! All talking about it, 3 nominations for a Indian in Oscars, etc etc.. one cannot remove off the movie... After all this, when one sees the movie most of them would see whether suits the hype, the awards... etc..
"Indian would be harmed by what’s shown in the movie" The world , India is too big to be affected by a movie... can you think of a tangible damage this movie would create? As such do you think people in the west think of the metros they think about India? do you think they think about infosys, pubs, multiplexes, bandra.. etc...? sorry that’s not the reality... most of them think still we are snake charmers!!! Its my personal experience... few know India through metros... many know through books , discovery channel or the beggars, traffic jam, theft, autowalas in the tourist destinations... The point is – the present image is not dignified, yes you may say that this movie would affirm or worsen things, but I feel the international damage delta would be negligible... but for we Indians it would be a big time REALITY CHECK...
"the movie deserves the nominations for performance...etc etc" What performance? Whose performance.. Try comparing it with crash, million dollar baby, TZP, Anbe sivam, etc etc
As a pure movie review - THE movie is GOOD not GREAT
Re: Re: Re: Felt something to be missing
by piyush jansari on Jan 26, 2009 03:20 PM
As a pure nationalist thought, We should not allow these Britishers to make movie highlighting the worst part of India and if this is not enough, the movie is being awarded left and right. Because of these awards people are going to see atleast once! I would say, we should ban this movie in INDIA. This is like making a movie involving British actors having made sex legal below 13 years and showing it in worst ways and giving them awards and showing all over that country, spreading indirect message that whole country`s population is involved in sex since they are 13 years of age. And do u feel they will jump in joy to get awards like we in India are jumping with joy now for SDM? This shows character of the Indian population. Given this, what can we expect, from ages on, then to be slaves of Muslim attacker, European settlers, and now Islamic terrorists.!
nothing great in slumdog just average film only script is good if this movie gets any oscar award then mr manmohan desai, and prakash mehra better deserve oscar for their all films
saw the movie last night at 11:pm show in SPICE,NOIDA...
I got the ticket very easily and was somehow surprised that on a weekend how could i get the ticket of most-talk about movie in the world..
Any how I sat on the chairs and the movie started...
And what i was exposed to,was the "unreal" realities of Mumbai...
Never ever any person jumps in to the sh* t just to see a superstar...how poor or die-hard fan he may be..
Its not Indian thing ,but yes I have seen it in hollywood movies where its must to have a scene where we say "yucks"....
The movie is an OK thing. there is nothing in the movie to remember for long time..
children of slums speaking fluent ENGLISH is as absurd Idea as the US blacks living in NY-slum speaking hindi.
There are much more good films in hollywood than this..
Its a sure flop in atleast India...
becuase the issues and scenes of poverty has been filmed more dramatically and in full context in Indian MOVIES LIKE :DHARAVI" company,traffic signal,satya,chandni bar...
this is mix of all things mentioned above..
Western people liked it,i think,becuase of curiosity factor as India has always been a beautifull place in bollywood movies..
for us its boring to see reality of india..
for them reality of Indian means "GOLDEN GLOBE" and "OSCARS"..
The worst thing about the movie was when the kids where first shown the movie it showed "mumbai -2006". And the grownup Zamal was 18-20 . That means whole thing happned in around 2020.
See it again if you missed this.
Slumdog shines because of - the acting of kids - Story
Re: slumdag reflects true india
by The Leader on Jan 24, 2009 09:48 AM
It is natures law that every entity has good and bad sides. Every country has its good and bad sides.. the real test is how successful you are in portraying success and controlling and minimising failures.. Every country in the world, be it US, or UK, is constantly doing that. Why then should we always highlight our failures and not successes. But it is true that when we highlight success, we should not forhet failures.
So there is nothing wrong in showing how we have progressed in various fileds. That progress we are showing is also real and not a whim of fancy.
