b4 going 2 a movie a read raja sen's review and when he says the film is a crap i know it must be good and the producers have not paid him..and when he writes good about some movie..i am sure that the film is senseless. W2HEN PPL WEAR BLUE GLARES EVERYTHING AROUND WEARS A SHADE OF BLUE..raja and those who are hell bent up[on telling all movies of srk are crap,please note..
Agree with the review. Watched the movie yesterday. Completely disappointing. Wonder how people can make such movies. There are so many flaws, just to name a few 1. How a wife cannot recognize her husband, just because he removes his moustache and changes his hairstyle. 2. Surinder does not make any attempt to win her over as just being "Surinder". Leaves her all alone in the house and expects her to fall in love with him somehow. 3. Finally Taani falls in love with Surinder just because she could see "Rab" in him. What if she had seen some other stranger walking towards her when she is in the temple? Would she have accepted that person as her partner? absurd.
Please give us a break !. Totally mindless script. I think SRK needs to be mature enough to correct/question some parts of the script if they sound illogical.
Re: Movie was disappointing
by Mohammed Zameer on Dec 17, 2008 08:03 PM
I dont know who u r? every time i saw in this forum with both negative and positive aspects..
Anyways i will cleared ur doubt.. as Shahrukh Khan has already said in Zoom TV that if your remove shahrukh khan face from ur mind then you will keep 2 faces of same persons (SRK)with different identity (Surinder and Raj) then it will be difficult to recognized the faces.
As Anushka has already said to Surinder Sahni that she dont expect anything from her side as she has already lost fate in love, after that Surinder Sahni decided to become Raj just to make her happy and hope that one day she will recognized Sahni Love that happen at last..
When she has asked her why Raj loving her then Raj told her he see Rab in Taani (Anushta)character then she told raj that i didnt see Rab in anyone but why???.. but finally she recognized Rab in Surinder character..
Please remember one thing dear films are only for entertainment.. not to make it in ur real life.RNBDJ is an good film plz. accept it. and now it has been super hit all over world.
Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by Arnab Sen on Dec 22, 2008 12:49 AM
i agree to only aspect pointed by u properly...films are for entertainment....and not for irritating people which i think RNBDJ does with dexterity...
Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by priya krish on Dec 17, 2008 08:40 PM
I guess new users in this forum are referred to as "guest". So please don't assume that all "guest" comments are given by one person. Secondly regarding the explanations, I just go by what is shown in the movie and not by assumptions that I need to make in order to force myself to like the movie. I just don't understand how any caring husband can make his wife go through an emotional grind wherein under the premise of making her happy, he is making her fall in love with a person with a different identity and still expect that she will fall in love with him eventually. It is nothing but chauvinistic. And finally all this thing about seeing "rab" in another person. The realization should have dawned on her based on Surinder's persona and not just because she visits a temple and requests the almighty to make her see "Rab" in an individual. Anyways , opinions differ and the movie just did not make any sense to me. And you are entitled to have yours.
Re: Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by Mohammed Zameer on Dec 18, 2008 12:49 AM
priya dont put this film in ur real life just go n watch for entertainment as we have seen so many senseless films like OSO, Krish, Koi Mil Gaya etc. etc. where there is no logic. if you dont digest this movie okk but just remember this films dialoge All WELL THEN ENDS WELL..
Re: Re: Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by subhajit mishra on Dec 18, 2008 02:35 AM
U know what Zameer...SRK has reached a stage in his life where he can choose movies which have entertainment values and technically correct at the same time.
OSO was a pathetic movie which was packaged and promoted in excellent fashion, so is Krish, but not Koi Mil Gaya, where Hrithik was sensational to pull off that performance.
Points that Priya has made are absolutely CORRECT, and SRK should also note these things.
And, finally dont show us all these numbers, even a crap like Singh Is King is also collecting money!!! But the time has arrived to appreciate and make movies like Aamir, A Wednesday, Jaane Tu..., TZP, even Chak De...
Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by shah nawaz on Dec 18, 2008 10:48 AM
u know what is the problem of Mr. SRK? he always looks money, he can do anything for money. dont give the excuse of entertainment. everytime people expects from some good movie from him but he always disappoint.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Movie was disappointing
by Abhijit Patki on Dec 21, 2008 09:12 PM
fully agreed with your views. it is a great movie and that's why hit all over the UK UAE and India .
Agree with the reviewer in toto...beyond cliched...but ppl will watch and it will become a hit and he will churn out such disasters again n ppl will watch...ad infinitum!
The movie being so simple is in itself the biggest asset of this movie... I enjoyed each and every scene... Loved this movie .... Fell in love with the song "Tujh Mein Rab Dikhta Hai" .... Everything was perfect.... A very clean and wonderful film.... Well Done ....
Re: Really worth watching... Raja Sen I disagree with you...
by Antara Sen on Dec 17, 2008 02:51 PM
i agree with you souvik...couldn't agree with mr.raja...sorry! the whole movie is clean,with some great songs and sharukh as well as anoushka has done a really good job.
hey had u thought anything before writing this reivew. how can any one say that this move is decade old.......decade old no body used to thought what are the expectations of their wife or try to be at her expectations or change him self to meet his wife's expectations.....this is a really nice movie...
Cmon SRk, we know Adi Chopra is family n all but do u have to do crap for him?? After movies like KANK, Swades n Chak De why would u give us trash like OSO n Rab Ne??? This movie has no story, no screenplay and a no NEW dialogues!! It just seems like a summary of all of Bollywood's formula movies and the sad part is it stills boasts of being different!! I am let down by SRK and YRF has proved its sheer uselessness once again!!!!! If u care about your time, stay away from this one!
Re: This Movie is sad!!
by SANJAY DAWRA on Dec 17, 2008 02:46 PM
hey u really liked KANK....!!!!...i am not able to understand what exactly Karan wanted to say in the movie...u get married and after sometime u start feeling restless in the relationship...go for another...that too can be justified...but in movie the problem creating ppl were rani and shahrukh...we (all my friends and relatives who watched the movie)were of the opinion that it was infact priety and abhishek's character who should have quite their partners...!!
Re: Re: This Movie is sad!!
by subhajit mishra on Dec 18, 2008 02:45 AM
Look..here comes Sanjay saab straight from Dwarka... Karan just wanted to show us a side or a part of our life which we do not want to see or realise or accept.
Re: Re: Re: This Movie is sad!!
by SANJAY DAWRA on Dec 22, 2008 09:53 AM
yaar but..how come such a senseless interpretation of this relationship..movie could have been interesting if he would have chosen abhishek and priety's character in place of rani and shahrukh..anyways everyone has his own way of thinking so is urs...i just wanted to share how and what i felt while watching the movie
maina rab na bana da jodi do bar dakahaiji...mujhe badi masand ahiee ji..mujhe lagtha hain ka rajasen ka rab nahi dektha tabhi toh woh kuch bhi review liktha haiji.... Usna kabi payar hiee nahin hiya haiji ya ushe payar dard nahin hota hainji, rajasen ko lagtha hain ka woh kuch bhi review dakanga par uski galat famihi hainji log ko RNBDJ bahot pasand ahiee ji...mujhe lagtha hain ka rajasen ko movie return dekna chaiya ji....
Re: Surinder Rock kar diya ji
by SANJAY DAWRA on Dec 17, 2008 02:48 PM
aap na ji apne mind ka ilaaj karaao ji...aap jaise bewakoof logon ke kaaran hi aisi movies jhelni padti hain..!!!
