It is well known now that this movie is a big disaster at the box-office. When are you going to declare it so... or will you call it a semi-hit as you did for DON.
Well,i guess everybody have their opinion.Few things i want to say: >>>>>>>Guys never ever think a film to be reality...if u think u want reality then u better stay at home and watch idols and roadies. >>>>>>>>>Second can anybody suggest me a film which has no flaws...comon.... >>>>>>>>>>And the truth film is OK not the best BUT U will be entertained if u r open minded,i amnot SRK's die hard fan but i think it is a nice movie to go out for perhaps after Singh is king....
Re: Clear minds
by Vikram on Dec 22, 2008 11:56 AM
It worst & unexpected movie of SRK. Please tell me. remove SRK from this movie. now tell me ur review about the movie. what is left in this movie?
Well,i guess everybody have their opinion.Few things i want to say: >>>>>>>Guys never ever think a film to be reality...if u think u want reality then u better stay at home and watch idols and roadies. >>>>>>>>>Second can anybody suggest me a film which has no flaws...comon.... >>>>>>>>>>And the truth film is OK not the best BUT U will be entertained if u r open minded,i amnot SRK's die hard fan but i think it is a nice movie to go out for perhaps after Singh is king....
Well,i guess everybody have their opinion.Few things i want to say: >>>>>>>Guys never ever think a film to be reality...if u think u want reality then u better stay at home and watch idols and roadies. >>>>>>>>>Second can anybody suggest me a film which has no flaws...comon.... >>>>>>>>>>And the truth film is OK not the best BUT U will be entertained if u r open minded,i amnot SRK's die hard fan but i think it is a nice movie to go out for perhaps after Singh is king....
i agree ...its like people have been overdosed by srk and they want change but they have to note that its the cool actor that they r ignoring
people have to agree that hes a nice actor and as he rightly said ...srk said this...."u can love me ...hate me....but u cant ignore me"
this is correct ,though one may say amitab or aamir or akshay or hritik is good ....but if u refer to bollywood in rest of world its srk they understand and not these ....yup amitab is also popular worldwide but i m proud to say that if u note it over 3 bn people know srk and about 2.7 bn people know tom cruise or brad pitt.....so heres ur answer about great in the worldwide film industry and u comparing internally and that too criticizing him....ya there are few flop films and also other actors are too good but its not good to ignore him.....when u like cheni kum by 65yr old then y u blaming him when hes 42,,,,,,,,also tell me who else can do such acting ....a double roll ....if u see it its too good....hes a through hardworker and also a great actor hats off to him suri rocks rab ne is too good i love u srk i also love others but srk is indias or bollywoods true ambassador go on man u r great
Re: yes
by omshiv on Dec 23, 2008 04:51 PM
3 bn know srk. great.. Osama is known for more than 3 bn. what do u feel about osama, very less know about BABA AMTE . DO You think SRK is greater than Amte...
I just saw Rab Ne yesterday and I found it very good. I think there are set of people who just want to criticize SRK for the sake of it. Like someone said earlier in the comments, if you see something with Blue glares ON, you will see it Blue and not Red, definitely not white... I think the movie was good.. it brought smile on my face and keep me interested for 3 hrs. I think thats what an audience expects from a good movie.
Ofcourse you can't say it was best movie of the year. You can't say it was a simple love story, such things do not happen with simple people.. It was definately no match for DDLJ. But you can't expect every SRK/Adi movie to be DDLJ, it's unfair on their part. I think it was a typical bollywood movie with some flaws in it. But it was not bad at all.
Go watch with atleast once.. go without any biased mind and you will enjoy the movie.
Re: You can't compare it with DDLJ
by priya on Dec 19, 2008 06:24 PM
even if one doesnt compare it to ddlj it was an average movie, one def expects better from aditya chopra. it was more a failure from ac not srk. srk is a competent actor no doubt , his potrayal of surinder sahni was just fine. but one missed moments in the movie , after all a romantic movie is all about moments, that is what one leaves a movie hall with
Yash Raj films hamare Rs 220/- wapas bar. There should be a censor board to stop such films from being released. Its boring..slow.. hardly any story. Idont know what happened in the end cause I got up before midiway and left the theatre. The movie is very bad, "Shahrukh to abh budha lagne laga hain. Kitna bhi Botox injection le ya excercise kar...to bhi kuch nahi ho sakta hain tera"
when i have to assess the movie , i dunno whether to say the movie was good or bad ! that in itself is a bad sign , it means that the movie has somewhere failed to strike a chord. it has left me cold.this comung from aditya chopra , whose ddlj is my all time fave. the problem with the movie is surinder suri and raj. i could identify with neither !also , the romance failed to touch me.pudfy faced anushka did not set me on fire in the least. and why on earth would a woman all set to elope with another man whom she is madly attracted to suddenly see rab in her husband.there seemed no trigger for that or build up. this was where the movie went wrong.the story was not credible.
