Review is all crap.....i dont know why he is so negative in his review!!! The film is about very honest emotions and exellent performances! And audience remarks are proving it! Reviewer needs to wake up! there is 1 thing about SRK that I want to tell him..."You can Love him, U can hate him....But U cant ignore him"....he is the undisputed king of BOffice....and collections of RNBDJ are proving it rightly so! cheer up!
no m no diehard fan of SRK,but i dont hate him too..had really loved him for what he did in Chak De & Swades..for dat matter OSO too..he is gud in kal ho na ho also..
But dis movie has degraded him in literal sense..First of all i think aditya chopra has lost it completely- just one msg for him:..you dont have to explicitly tell evry little damn thing to the audience and stretch it over making it an emotional fool\\\'s paradise..Few things should left to be understood and felt on its own. I feel the movie being such a disaster,SRK is not to be blamed..he still was fair enuf..a man of his level cant be questioned for his acting skills.. The whole blame is on the way the movie has been over stretched.. Its just not worth it. It was a gud script,based on a simple man, n his little world..but the emotional content went way too high ,out the limits.. Any thing is possible in movies i know..m not questioning ne logics hre..coz movies r meant to b entertaining minus or plus logic..doesnt matter... But dis high melo drama is way too lousy..yash raj films got to understand that they need to atleast put the right amount of evrything!
I find it hard to imagine how anybody can like this movie. I know we Indians are generally starved of a quality entertainment. But even for our deprived entertainment-hungry mind, isn't this movie kinda emotional junk food?
1. Did anybody really find the antics of the Khan funny when he tries to woo his wife by being 'cool'? I did not hear any laughter in the theatre, albeit some were forced ones, may to be out of sympathy considering the energy Khan was putting in rather than for anything else I think.
2. Did not you squirm in your seats when the wife fails to gauge the similarity between the face she sees everyday at home and the face of the person that befriends her. The difference was merely a mustache and clothes.
Re: This movie is good?? Come on
by Avinash Patalay on Dec 16, 2008 03:12 AM
mr. salil
is this the first time the bollywood has witnessed such circus?
time and again it has happened... while the bollywood is striving to break the mould to move to another level, movies like this and bringing it back to square one.
You are too cool and too intellectual to be understood in the minimum sense possible. I am neither a SRK fan nor I have watched this movie, I am just commenting on the basis of reading a piece of writing. I am forced to say it does not make no sense at all!! The reviewer has negatively criticized the movie for the sake of doing it.. Get a grip!
