he himself is the most over-rated.atleast kunal kohli doesn't get so much credit.he just makes entertaining masala films without any pretension.leela acts as though he's making masterpiece but they r so boring and so expensive.i think he misses the box office success of kunal.to top it leela prefers salman over srk and saif over aamir!!
RE:sanjay leela is the most over-rated
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:33 PM
leela movie is about real art of direction. Kunal categoy is like Village Ki Nautanki, for example - Ramanaya and Mahabharata . Stupid dialogs and shayari and repeated story of Fiza
RE:RE:sanjay leela is the most over-rated
by saptarshi datta on Feb 27, 2007 12:03 AM
leela`s story is baseless... in black it was scene to scene copy.. hdddc - stuupid movie.. its more of a village ki nautanki.. and devdas it was a copied atoryline didn`t have any originality
RE:Fanna To Good
by raja ram nisha on Feb 26, 2007 06:21 PM
do not agre. fanaah had glorified a separatist terrorist. i am yet to see this movie for this reason.
RE:RE:Fanna To Good
by Arindam Mitra on Feb 26, 2007 06:37 PM
Agree with u Raja...Fanna is a a very negative movie which gloriifies a terrorist who is engazed in killing innocent people. The same reason, I also didn't see the movie. On the other hand, Black is an all time Classic.
RE:RE:RE:Fanna To Good
by Mohd Asif on Feb 26, 2007 09:50 PM
if fanna is very negative movie then KANK ws even more worest than fanaa (according to your think it should be like that). Ofcourse there is no question to compare between black and fanaa both are totally different and i must say black was vry beautiful movie. Just wanna remind you (jaydeep patel) all movies are not based on reality and even some movies they really don't had a exact stoy but they were appricated by audience.Everyone have their own vision the things only matter is how beautifly they can present to audience and what message they wanted to convey...........
RE:RE:Fanna To Good
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:35 PM
Exactly sudhanshu, Fanaa doesnt seems real life or any story. It was full of dialogs "Shayari". Which really sounds stupid. "Most Overated" because of Kajol's come back.
RE:RE:Fanna To Good
by Prateek Mishra on Feb 26, 2007 05:51 PM
We should not compare here BLACK with FANNA both being a film are good . As for the remark of Sanjay Leela Bhansali... it doesnt suits Bhansali at all... and good reply by Kunal
The same story backdrop of kashmir, people really fed-up with this subject. The other subject like "Karwah chauth", "Punjaabi marriage" songs etc are ferquently repeated by Johar and Chopra production. They should make movie with different league than their usual standard :)
RE:RE:RE:Fanaa was really bad
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:35 PM
Exactly sudhanshu, Fanaa doesnt seems real life or any story. It was full of dialogs "Shayari". Which really sounds stupid. "Most Overated" because of Kajol's come back.
Kunal Kohli is just 3 movies old in d industry n out of those 3 films only one hve touched me ..ats HUMTUM..bout MDK,d less said d better..Fanaa did a good job in wasting d powerhouse of talents like Kajol n amir Khan..Khan was given a role at could have been played by anyobody n everybody in d industry..D script was weak,dialogues were stupid..remember d irritting shayri by Kirron Kher n Amir? D only reason t was a hit was coz of Kajol's come bak n since dis paring was never seen b4. Bhansali may b wrong in publicly showing his dissent on d film..bt sorry 2 say his opinion,however blunt it may seem,is TRUE n by d way those regarding BLACK is one of d most beautiful movies of out time..even a layma will agree 2 dat..Kunal Kohli cant even imagine 2 make a masterpiece like dat in his entire lifetime.. :)
RE:bhansali is right
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:35 PM
Exactly sudhanshu, Fanaa doesnt seems real life or any story. It was full of dialogs "Shayari". Which really sounds stupid. "Most Overated" because of Kajol's come back.
RE:SLB's overrated comment..
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:36 PM
thats rite. But Fanaa doesnt seems real life or any story. It was full of dialogs "Shayari". Which really sounds stupid. "Most Overated" because of Kajol's come back.
RE:its bad Mr. Bhansali
by jaydeep patel on Feb 26, 2007 06:36 PM
thats rite, But Fanaa doesnt seems real life or any story. ,It was full of dialogs "Shayari". Which really sounds stupid. "Most Overated" because of Kajol's come back.
RE:RE:its bad Mr. Bhansali
by Asif Siddiqui on Feb 26, 2007 09:58 PM
Black was even stupid too........... If black was casted by low grade stars then i don't think anyone here even remember that movie.
RE:RE:I am not Intelect
by denver on Feb 26, 2007 05:49 PM
Very Very Very Well said....
It was a real torture, a third degree type.
Except for the child artist Ayesha (and ofcourse, the people who watched the film), nobody deserves a true credit.
Everyone else has been over rated.
Although Kunal Kohli needs to prove his consistency, there is no exaggeration if anyone would say Hum Tum was more realistic and entertaining than Black.
RE:RE:I am not Intelect
by AP on Feb 26, 2007 05:37 PM
absolutely!! also, Hindi cinema really needs to evolve from this insipid Johar, Chopra, candy floss, social drama phase...and fast!
