These are cars that super rich people can afford, if they want. Why should we worry about it as long as they dont snatch money from us. It is the fault of our political system if someone feels that Amar Singh is looting public. We cant blame him alone for that. As voters we have a major role in electing them. Alternatively, f there is a demand, we should think of assembling such cars in India and give jobs to people. Also, it is good to hear that govt gained 30 lakhs as duty due to the wild fancies of super rich. The govt can think of charity measures...
RE:Its their life...
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:08 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:RE:Its their life...
by suyog pandit on Feb 09, 2007 03:37 PM
nirmal..whose money you are earning? you have no idea what you are talking about.Your boss is paying you so does that mean it is boss's money,so you are answerable to him on how you spend your money? Or if you are a government servant then you are answerable to public? grow up,learn some economics.Anyway who asked people to spend money on Bachchan? It was for entertaintment that people watch movies.He is in entertaintment business,that's his proffesion and whatever he has earned is his hard earned money.Govenment is answerable for useage of public money and not a citizen for his personal wealth.
RE:Its their life...
by khusi zindagi on Feb 09, 2007 06:47 PM
Even manikchand gifted his daughter a 1 crore car but at that time no1 reporter questioned how ethically its right to sell guthkha to millions of ppl and gift the best car to the daughter...
Many people are commenting on Bachchan's or Singh's income and that they should spend their money for poor etc. Pls. understand first of all it's their earned money and they have every right to spend as they want,nobody can force them on how to spend their own money.Secondly weather or not they spend for charity deeds is not known by us,it's possible that they do charity but media does'nt know about it.They does'nt need to show their charity works( even if they show,people will say it's a publicity stunt ).Finally if they pay their taxes then they are doing their bit for the society as the tax money is for people.( how many people from us like to pay taxes??).SO lets not get into all this.Amitabh deserves what he gets and so is applicable to all.
RE:Big B
by govindaraj K on Feb 11, 2007 07:25 PM
It is, we people we paid money to watch his film. So Nothing to blame. Only thing which is not there from us is unity. If we have we can do anything. Think towards that.
RE:Big B
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:09 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:RE:Big B
by Umesh on Feb 09, 2007 04:19 PM
Nirmal ....I think you are wasting your time and many others money who pays for your daily livings... keep your mouth shut and do something good in your life from now onwards...dont be jelous like a girl..be like a man ...
RE:RE:RE:Big B
by mohammed shadab on Feb 10, 2007 06:16 PM
Nirmal, Keep ur mouth shut and think before u say something. And people dont spend money blindly. They spent because they do get some satisfaction by watching his movies
If some of our are friends are new to job, then I confess myself to be super rich by standards of Bajaj - I have a car !
I think it is a wastage of money to buy bentley. I think it is a wastage of money to buy a corolla- It looks perfect only for CEOs and big people and big cities. It looked okay to own it while I was in US.
however It is perfectly fine for Bachan to use a couple of bentleys. They have far lot more money, some of the people who post here about poverty are sycophants. They wasted all their life in watching movies, so that they never found out how much extra money is out there. Couple of lakhs in infosys share in 2000 would give you crores today.
No body said a bad thing about bachan when he seemed to be fine with that much maligned hoax- secularism. It is nice to find out that even people who do business by selling sympathy to downtrodden make good profit. All the best to those who think 2.5 crores is big deal.
RE:2.5 crores and big deal ?
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:10 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:media sucks amd media monger sucks bigger
by ritnanya on Feb 09, 2007 01:08 PM
Amar singh (&mulayam) wants amitabh help in the coming UP elections to win, so he is giving the car. If he pays the income tax properly and keeps a clear status on him income, then it's OK. It's POLITICS friends. But sure, SP will get defeated this time...Hope.
RE:media sucks amd media monger sucks bigger
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:07 PM
RE:RE:wht the hell !!! by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:05 PM It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
This is so screwd up topic to be made headlines !!!! Why are people reading about these politicians and bachhan family so much??? are they so important to us???? These actors get paid extravagantly and instead of spending it on poor people to remove poverty they are buying cars and bunglows... This is a request to Mr Amitabh n his brother Amar singh... do some goodwill to the society... theres much more to do then act in stupid films and attending high society parties...
RE:wht the hell !!!
by Anisa Fathima on Feb 09, 2007 02:25 PM
DId you expect Amitabh to gift a cycle to abhishek??? It is because of his acting and the humble way in which he has carried himself all these years, that he has achieved the status of a super star today. He has entertained us for so many decades, so why should we be critical of things he does in his personal life? Just because the media doesnt report his charity works, it doesnt mean he does not donate to the needy. Lastly, if you were in his shoes, you too would have done the same thing for ur son. Amitabh has a status symbol, and he is expected to live up to it.
RE:RE:wht the hell !!!
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:06 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:wht the hell !!!
by vamshidhar reddy on Feb 09, 2007 02:28 PM
Hello Mehta saab,
I dont know why you are not able to stand the truth that they are spending money..Its their hardearned money!!!Tell me out of your earning how much do you donate to charity? Well, The media is simply targetting Mr Bachhan, thats pretty bad.
RE:RE:wht the hell !!!
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:05 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:wht the hell !!!
by Jay shankar on Feb 09, 2007 02:13 PM
harmeet bahai, they have earned by workinghard. they have the right to spend it anyway they deem fit as long as they paythe mandatory taxes.all this talk of poverty is humbug if u feel so bad about it then just live with minimum requirements and donate evrything to the poor because please practice what you preach
RE:RE:wht the hell !!!
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:06 PM
RE:RE:wht the hell !!! by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:05 PM It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
We are not blaming the Bachans or anybody for buying an expensive car. Their money. They can spend it whatever way they like.
But when a political leader of a party claiming to represent the downtrodden in one of the poorest states in India flauts money to buy one of the most expensive cars so that his friends's son can use it, we have the right to crib about it.
Its all black money. I want to know if he made this money by screwing the poor people in UP.
RE:RE:RE:To make it very clear
by sachin on Feb 09, 2007 11:25 AM
If they don't have money and they are poor it shows they are kamchor and not working and now earning any money ... Thats Why they are declared BIMARU states ie. Bhihar Madhyapradesh Rajasthan and UP all are bimar states...they are Kamchors
RE:To make it very clear
by vamshidhar reddy on Feb 09, 2007 10:18 AM
When he says that it will be shown in the IT, its not black money any more...I think your message suggests that you are not able to stand the fact that people are buying expensive cars
RE:RE:To make it very clear
by Debo Mcnair on Feb 10, 2007 12:04 AM
Not at all. I am perfectly okay with Ratn Tata, Narayana murthy or even Amitabh buying the car. And thats because I know their source of income.
This Amr singh guy is a freaking POLITICIAN of a party claiming to REPRESENT THE DOWNTRODDEN in one of India's POOREST states. I am just curious as to HOW HE GOT THIS MUCH MONEY. There, I have capitalized the keywords so that your brain has less trouble understanding it.
RE:To make it very clear
by Jay shankar on Feb 09, 2007 02:16 PM
your policy seems that since i cannot afford it neither should they and yes grapes are sour applies to you perfectly.
RE:RE:To make it very clear
by Debo Mcnair on Feb 10, 2007 12:08 AM
Nope. You are weak in English, I think. The only point I raised was that a politician representing poor people in a poor state cannot have this much money unless something was going on. Where did he get the money from? Plus it is not morally correct to represent poor people when driving aroung in a Bentley.
RE:To make it very clear
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:13 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:RE:To make it very clear
by Vaishali Vinoda on Feb 09, 2007 04:23 PM
bhaiyya nirmal..y dont you atleast change your dialogue.Every where you hav pasted the same crab.thoda tho badlao dalo
Check the story My car- I paid- My temporary residence- My son and his bahu!!! can use it whenever I'm not using it etc etc. Gosh! he thinks all India is UP. I respect Mr Amitabh as an Indian. He is no greater than I am as an Indian. But if he decides to plan his like with idiots like Amar Singh, sorry sir, you have to be held accounatble
RE:Does Amar Singh think that he could fool all Indians like he does in his state...Sorry
by Anurag Rastogi on Feb 09, 2007 09:12 AM
what do you mean by UP . do you think UP is a state without rule go and check your state.i doono why you are dragging UP in this episode. and AMAR singh is right. media is culprit here
RE:Does Amar Singh think that he could fool all Indians like he does in his state...Sorry
by vamshidhar reddy on Feb 09, 2007 10:21 AM
Boss Thats his personal life..you cannot be commenting on that...I think Amar sings justification is fair enough
RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by Satya ss on Feb 09, 2007 09:57 AM
Keeping tab on Politicians is also Govt's work. Can we know how your Great amar bhai got so much money? and look at his apalling nature, when there are tons of poor people here he is spending milions of rupees on a car for his chaddi dost Bacchan. Sure people will still vote for Amar bhai..people love corrupt politicians...
RE:RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by Anurag Rastogi on Feb 09, 2007 11:09 AM
mind you business here, he is not asking any money from you , he earned that money and he had the rights to spend it wherever he likes. it is not your business how he earned that money .
RE:RE:RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by srivatsa yb on Feb 09, 2007 12:16 PM
what its not our business??ppl in public positions have to say how they earned it..after all its public money that baccha amar singh is looting...u must be a hardcore amar singh fan club member haha good for u
RE:RE:RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by brecta robert on Feb 09, 2007 02:16 PM
From where did he earn ? the money is from the poor people's pocket.Amar Sing should concentrate on his work and stop gifting rich people like Amithab, to get his favour back.
RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by nirmal narayanan on Feb 09, 2007 03:14 PM
It is not their hard earned money, it is the hard earned money of millions, who wasted their income to watch 'Bachchan' movies, that made a lay person a 'Superstar' and made him in a position to buy a 'Bentley', so he is answerable to the people, who's money he is spending, not his money.
RE:Goverment is behind bacchans
by usman khawaja on Feb 09, 2007 07:36 PM
well said anurag other wise who would censor a stupid movie promoting corruption to be even released. im talking og that idiocity called GURU
