Dear Mr. Venkatesh, what do you think about the unscrupulous and corrupted CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS who play the role of AUDITORs and help these thieves like Nirav Modi to steal national resources? These CAs are entrusted to implement checks and balances in the system so that peoples like Nirav Modi, Mehul Choksi, Vijay Mallya can't cheat the nation. So, it is better if the author come clean on the role of his class before commenting on others.
Dear Mr. Venkatesh, what do you think about the unscrupulous and corrupted CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS who play the role of AUDITORs and help these thieves like Nirav Modi to steal national resources? These CAs are entrusted to implement checks and balances in the system so that peoples like Nirav Modi, Mehul Choksi, Vijay Mallya can't cheat the nation. So, it is better if the author come clean on the role of his class before commenting on others.
Re: One simple question to Mr. Venkatesh!!!
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 03:19 PM
Throughout the year, the bankers are busy with one audit or others like concurrent, statutory audit, RBI audit, internal audit etc. None of the auditors has ever pointed out any discrepancy in this deal. What is the role played by the top management of the bank ? Were they sleeping when large amount of LOU were issued by their representative and were not aware of the liability which may fall on them in case party become a defaulter ? why no amount was shown even as a contingent liability in their Audit accounts ? I feel that the top management of the bank, RBI and the auditors has miserably failed in their professional duties and CBI must take them to task for their serious lapse.
Re: One simple question to Mr. Venkatesh!!!
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 03:19 PM
Throughout the year, the bankers are busy with one audit or others like concurrent, statutory audit, RBI audit, internal audit etc. None of the auditors has ever pointed out any discrepancy in this deal. What is the role played by the top management of the bank ? Were they sleeping when large amount of LOU were issued by their representative and were not aware of the liability which may fall on them in case party become a defaulter ? why no amount was shown even as a contingent liability in their Audit accounts ? I feel that the top management of the bank, RBI and the auditors has miserably failed in their professional duties and CBI must take them to task for their serious lapse.
Re: Re: One simple question to Mr. Venkatesh!!!
by Satyajeet Singh Yadava on Mar 01, 2018 03:37 PM
When they achieve,the Politicians thump their desks,pat their backs & waive every other body part,but when something goes wrong they quickly wash off their hands?????????????????????????????
Re: Re: Re: One simple question to Mr. Venkatesh!!!
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 03:57 PM
Bhaiyaji, better read the comments carefully and if you have very limited capacity to understand the role of Auditors and top bank officials of the bank and RBI , better keep quiet instead of exposing your lack of knowledge and intelligence.
Yesterday CBI advised NiMo to come to India for prosecution and he bluntly and darely rejected informing that he is having businesses through out the world. What they will do, only citizens can hear powerful speeches from the head of the Govt., where a meagre amount may be recovered as eye wash. Very funny, there is no control over the immigration process to our Home Ministry and hence those culprits are escaping from the country with the hard earned money of people.
Re: Nothing will happen, we are the spectators only
by Satyajeet Singh Yadava on Mar 01, 2018 03:37 PM
All this chest thumping & attempt to show sincerity is just EyeWash/Hogwash!!!!Neither Nirav_bhaiModi nor MEhulBHai_Modi will come back to face Indian Law.It is another matter that many officers will be getting Paid Holidays,all over the world in search Of Niravbhai_Mehulbhai_Modi?????????????????????????
Re: Re: Nothing will happen, we are the spectators only
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 03:59 PM
Did Quottrochi and Win Chadhdha of Bofors or Anderson of Union Carbide ever came back to india and face trial ? Who were the people who helped them to flee ?
Re: Re: Re: Nothing will happen, we are the spectators only
by Satyajeet Singh Yadava on Mar 01, 2018 04:22 PM
So my Dearest Shahji,do u want Modiji to emulate the Congies,by giving such explanations!We wanted a show of 56"Chest but sad,it proved to be a damp Squib???
Re: Re: Re: Re: Nothing will happen, we are the spectators only
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 10:27 PM
Bhaiyaji, first you stop your nonsense and don’t try to write comments on the subject you don’t know. You comments show there is no difference between you and Mad person like Mitesh.
Re: Re: Nothing will happen, we are the spectators only
by P S SHAH on Mar 01, 2018 04:00 PM
Did Quottrochi and Win Chadhdha of Bofors or Anderson of Union Carbide ever came back to india and face trial ? Who were the people who helped them to flee ?
AUTHOR SEEMS TO BE CONGEE AND ANTI NATIONAL.125 CRORE COUNTRYMEN HAVE FULL FAITH AND TRUST ON MODI SIR,AMIT SHAH SIR,AND TEAM BJP.I CERITIFY THAT MODI SIR AND HIS TEAM IS PURE AND HONEST,THEY ARE SWIFTLY ARRESTING CONEES AND OPPOSITION LEADERS TO MAKE INDIA CONGRESS AND OPPOSITION MUKT RESULTING INTO CORRUPTION MUKT BHARAT. BHARAT MATA KI JAI SHIVRAJ SINGH KASANA
Re: MODI SIR IMAGE
by Gladyschellam on Mar 01, 2018 02:54 PM
What Mr M R Ventatesh as an Auditor said is correct. I think you have no idea about Mr Venkatesh. He used to participate in discussions being held in a popular English Channel.
Recently a New Zealand writer Brian Godzone has written an article that spread like fire on social media which I will write in brief or summarize because of its size
Indians are Hobbesian (having culture of self interest. Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore said the same, had it been 75% Indians, 15% Malays and the rest Chinese, it would not have worked, because Indian people believe in politics of contention and opposition but because in Singapore because of chinese influential culture, populace politics sought a practical way out of their difficulties and it worked)
Now this New Zealand writer said corruption is a cultural aspect. India does not only tolerate corrupt, but worship them and to know why we have to look at patterns
1) Religion is transactional in India. Indians gives gold, cash, food in anticipate for out of turn reward at religious places. Babas, guru, peer, Sufis are first step towards give and take culture hence corruption does not look bad for Indians.
He said when European and Englishmen came to India, they build modern institutions and system, whereas majority of Indians who went abroad have taken their feudal society in a modern society,
Indians believe if we can offer almighty money at religious places, there is nothing wrong in giving to corrupt beaurocrats.
Morality of Indians. He said corrupt jayalalitha went to jail and made a comeback, such scenario is impossible or unthinkable in western society
Re: India and corruption goes hand in hand - democracy
by Sameer Shaikh on Mar 01, 2018 02:53 PM
Second, Indian moral authority towards corruption is visible in its history. Capture of cities and kingdoms after guards were paid to open the gates and commander paid to surrender. Nizam took money to send his army. An invader who captured India bought kings easily. Mughals vanished Maratha and Rajput with bribes.
Last Indians do not believe in theory that all can rise if each of them behaves morally because it is not the message of the faith. Caste system separates them. The division of mind and inequality due to suppression and corrupt society in India taken a short route through corruption. From start Indian mind is calibrated for give and take to do their work because their forefathers have done bribery.
Hence corruption is in the DNA of Indians. From religion to customs like marriage where sister in law hides shoes to extract money from her sister husband to offering brides in exchange for dowry.
This was from a New Zealand writer Brian Godzone whom I agree. Indians are born corrupt and cheaters and also agree with Lee who said had majority of Indians were in place of Chinese (75% (opposite), Singapore would have been a morally corrupt society. This is why western democracy is a hoax in India which western media projects is as heavenly condition which is against the values of Indian culture.
