Discussion Board

Land Bill U-turn: Another defeat for the Modi govt


Total 111 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
chandrashekar nayak
Needless Celebration
by chandrashekar nayak on Aug 08, 2015 05:26 PM  | Hide replies

Modi Govt failed to get RS approval for the much needed Land Bill and the united opposition and the Media is celebrating the " defeat" of Modi Govt. What they have forgotten is the big road block in the Make in India program. Only Industrial growth will ensure more jobs for young and educated Indians.If there is no land, there will be no industries and no jobs. How to create jobs for 10 million new graduates produced every year in India? Opposition Parties are taking revenge on Modi for the humiliating defeat he handed them over in May 2014 General Election. They have made up their mind that they will block all developmental plans of Modi Govt.A section of Media, like Karan Thapars and Rajdeep Desais have not been able to suppress their joy at Modi's defeat in getting Land Bill passed. If Land Bill is not passed, will Modi lose anything personally? No ! It is millions of our own young boys and girls who will remain unemployed.Country's economic growth will take a beating and ultimately, it is the poor farmers and labour class who will suffer the most- the very same people whon our Opposition Parties claim to be protecting from " Land Grabbing Modi Govt". Modi's opponents wants Modi to fail politically so that they have some chance to gain their lost ground. But what is wrong with our Media? So much hatred towards Modi? Our young generation should understand the bigger, selfish game plan of politicians which is harmful to their future.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
vishal patel
Re: Needless Celebration
by vishal patel on Aug 08, 2015 05:54 PM
Someone should do something about this website , Its celebrating the victory of the defeat of the nda govt.
This website is making a mockery of our govt.
It telling the news with such proudness , its become clear that this website is acting and doing everything basically on the behalf of the kangiss

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Bishwanath Chatterjee
Re: Re: Needless Celebration
by Bishwanath Chatterjee on Aug 09, 2015 04:40 PM
Above report is bogus, it will move through state.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Yamla Jatt
Re: Re: Needless Celebration
by Yamla Jatt on Aug 09, 2015 04:55 PM
Relax, dont see it as a defeat of BJP but victory of democracy. Nothing unusual and everything happened according to Indian constitution

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sanjay Tomar
Property should not go in hand of some corporate, Politician.
by Sanjay Tomar on Aug 08, 2015 07:42 AM  | Hide replies

Development doesn’t mean forced the 60% population farmer in helpless state, to get exploit without getting guarantee of source of permanent income for their all coming generation, without giving demanded justified price of their land. Farmer are ready to give their land but they want permanent source of income for their all coming generation , Job security, Demanded justified price of their land without forcing them to give land is the way for development that is all farmer is getting from their agriculture land but government want to cheat the farmer in the name of development don’t want to give demanded justified price of their land , forcing the farmer depend on private , corporate Job is only temporary source of Income only exploiting employee, required permanent source of Income, in the name of fair price cheating the farmer not giving justified demanded price of their land only forcing them to give land is illegal can’t be allowed. People can’t survive on temporary source of income without justified pension, salary. Development of Industry not mean is only become slave, live miserable life to work in Industry, corporate is the policy of government. Both politicians, Industrialist corporate making farmer slave, to get exploit, live miserable life for their personal benefit can’t be allowed.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Indian Sadhu
Re: Property should not go in hand of some corporate, Politician
by Indian Sadhu on Aug 09, 2015 04:29 PM
Then remain a country practicing socialism / communism. We will see how much India prospers then. Look at examples across the world and see which countries have prospered more - the industrialised ones or the agricultural ones.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Ramanath Babu
Re: Property should not go in hand of some corporate, Politician
by Ramanath Babu on Aug 10, 2015 11:13 AM
mr. tomar,

can you throw more light on the subject. what is the compensation offered by the govt to farmers? what exactly isthe farmers' demand? Since you are talking authoritatively, you must be having these figures. Kindly share it with readers.



   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sanjay Tomar
Property should not go in hand of some corporate, Politician.
by Sanjay Tomar on Aug 08, 2015 07:42 AM  | Hide replies

Development doesn’t mean forced the 60% population farmer in helpless state, to get exploit without getting guarantee of source of permanent income for their all coming generation, without giving demanded justified price of their land. Farmer are ready to give their land but they want permanent source of income for their all coming generation , Job security, Demanded justified price of their land without forcing them to give land is the way for development that is all farmer is getting from their agriculture land but government want to cheat the farmer in the name of development don’t want to give demanded justified price of their land , forcing the farmer depend on private , corporate Job is only temporary source of Income only exploiting employee, required permanent source of Income, in the name of fair price cheating the farmer not giving justified demanded price of their land only forcing them to give land is illegal can’t be allowed. People can’t survive on temporary source of income without justified pension, salary. Development of Industry not mean is only become slave, live miserable life to work in Industry, corporate is the policy of government. Both politicians, Industrialist corporate making farmer slave, to get exploit, live miserable life for their personal benefit can’t be allowed.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Dipankar Mukherji
Re: Property should not go in hand of some corporate, Politician
by Dipankar Mukherji on Aug 08, 2015 05:58 PM
Only .001% of Agricultural land is being taken for Govt development such as roads, Power plants and other govt infrastructure projects.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Dipankar Mukherji
Political Survival
by Dipankar Mukherji on Aug 08, 2015 07:34 AM  | Hide replies

Political Survival of RJD, JDU, SP, BSP , Communist, RLD, JDS, NCP and other smaller parties depend upon people's grievances to remain as it is. Cong Revival depends on Modi's failure of development. All these parties are scared that once land bill is passed there may be plenty of development and their chances of coming to power is bleak. They are taking undue advantage of Arrogance of majority in Rajya Sabha. These parties and Cong also was partially successful in making people feel that Modi was anti-farmer and by repeatedly invoking the suit boot ki sarkar.
Master stroke of Modi was to auction the suit and lot of items he got as gift and auctioned amount was ploughed back to the nation's fund. People now dont know how many suits and Jackets were worn My Indira Gandhi and Nehru. Even RG is wearing white kurta when he goes to villages and Jeans and T shirt in FTII. SG by taking sari veil over her head at rallies in villages is just Hypocrisy. At least IG used to regularly do it. This show off does not help. Opp mantra is let nation go to dogs but i must politically survive. People have become intelligent to understand this drama by opp.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
chandrashekar nayak
Re: Political Survival
by chandrashekar nayak on Aug 08, 2015 05:43 PM
A bunch of Losers- 44 Congress MPs, 15 Communists, 2 JDU MPs, 4 RJD MPs are blocking Modi Govt's mega project Make in India which can assure jobs for millions of our educated young boys and girls. The flaw in our political system is creating hindrance in our Country's development. Rajya Sabha was meant for non political people, who are eminent in their respective fields. But now, it has become an orphanage for people like Yechuri, Mayavathi, Karat etc, who can not win popular mandate. A bunch of less than 50 MPs have ensured that Modi Govt is unable to clear the Land Bill in RS. What a tragedy for this Country !

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Useless Comments
Re: Re: Political Survival
by Useless Comments on Aug 08, 2015 05:56 PM
But from where you will get food for Indians when you take remaining farmers land. We already have grain shortage and importing from outside .. what will happen if you take remaining land.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
chandrashekar nayak
Re: Re: Re: Political Survival
by chandrashekar nayak on Aug 08, 2015 06:02 PM
Go to countryside and see, millions of hectares of fertile, cultivable Land is left uncultivated or being sold to Real Estate Lobby.There is enough land for Industries and Farming. I am a farmer myself and I know the facts better. It is simply the politics being played by those who have been kicked out by the people in May 2014 Election.They will oppose Modi for the sake of it. They can't digest the fact that Modi made them irrelevant in India's politics today.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Ramanath Babu
Re: Re: Re: Political Survival
by Ramanath Babu on Aug 10, 2015 11:21 AM
Mr. Useless. even otherwise year after year thousand and thousand tonnes of food grains are virtually going down the drains due to inadequate storage capacity of FCI. this is despite poor harvesting in certain pockets due to less or excess rains. If it is bumper crop everywhere, just imagine where would we store the grains?


   Forward   |   Report abuse
chandrashekar nayak
Re: Political Survival
by chandrashekar nayak on Aug 08, 2015 05:43 PM
A bunch of Losers- 44 Congress MPs, 15 Communists, 2 JDU MPs, 4 RJD MPs are blocking Modi Govt's mega project Make in India which can assure jobs for millions of our educated young boys and girls. The flaw in our political system is creating hindrance in our Country's development. Rajya Sabha was meant for non political people, who are eminent in their respective fields. But now, it has become an orphanage for people like Yechuri, Mayavathi, Karat etc, who can not win popular mandate. A bunch of less than 50 MPs have ensured that Modi Govt is unable to clear the Land Bill in RS. What a tragedy for this Country !

   Forward   |   Report abuse
NG Nileshwar
Land Bill
by NG Nileshwar on Aug 08, 2015 07:25 AM

This is not a defeat of the Govt. It is a defeat of democracy. After succumbing to the demand of the Parliament for Standing Committee decision, the Govt.should go by its recommendations. The implementation is by the states. How does it matter then? The BJP states should implement its concept and evidence the draw-backs of the amended bill. It should then question the Opposition. This is better.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Raj kamboj
No Defeat
by Raj kamboj on Aug 07, 2015 09:53 PM

This is not defeat. But the defeat of Congress, who do not want India to progress.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
mahesh kamath
Master stroke
by mahesh kamath on Aug 07, 2015 09:01 PM

This is not a defeat, but I see this as an masterstoke..All BJP led states will quietly propose land bill through presidents approval like in Gujrath and COngress led states will follow suit. With current minority status in RS it was a good decision to leave Land bill aside.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
harish
defeat of common man
by harish on Aug 07, 2015 08:04 PM

This is not defeat of Modi Govt but defeat of common man and above all final nail in the coffin of congress.
Rediff always wants sensation at the cost of Modi.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ravi Sinha
Comrades are known traitors
by Ravi Sinha on Aug 07, 2015 07:57 PM

Comrades are are known traitors and will never like an independent India.But the biggest misfortune of this country that the other parties led by Congress has got scant regard for the development of India & betterment of its people.They want to create an atmosphere of chaos so the country remais backward and divided.
Ravi Sinha

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Ravi Sinha
Comrades are known traitors
by Ravi Sinha on Aug 07, 2015 07:55 PM

Comrades are are known traitors and will never like an independent India.But the biggest misfortune of this country that the other parties led by Congress has got scant regard for the development of India & betterment of its people.They want to create an atmosphere of chaos so the country remais backward and divided.
Ravi Sinha

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 111 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message