he is a laibility in Test matches. The tail statrts with him.. most of the occasssions throws his wicket away. surely he is not suited to est cricket just like yuvraj. he should be replaced with parthiv who is a much better test batsman ( though a failure in onedayers).Similarly Gambhir should also be shown the door.
dhoni is riding on the success of the seniors in foreign pitches..hes like mike brearley. is time some consistent wicket keeper batsman drafted into teh side in place of him..he can be the ODI and T20 captain..
Re: time to pack up
by AmitkumarJha on Dec 28, 2011 01:06 PM
Include Dinesh Karthik in his place in test team. His technique is better than Dhoni as he has proved in England, SA.
He can bat only in dead pitches .do not go by averages they are often misleading also take the fact he bats at 7 or 8 the chances are he has better chance of remaining unbeaten .See Beaven fantastic average .
Re: It's advantage Australia
by Rajkumar Bhardwaj on Dec 28, 2011 01:13 PM
It will be still better if guys like u who r the biggest critiques reporters agianst anything that India does wether it is winning or losing should be sent to face the music and let us see where u stand
who says he is attacking. started with 2 lips and then again at 50-4 became defensive and allowed pointing and hussey to take easy singles. with 2 more days don't expect to draw. seen that in englan we had england 7 down with 100 odds in second inning and managable score to win but allowed tail to take score to 250. he is chicken goes defensive run saving mode rather than going for win.
Re: worst attitude by dhoni
by Another Critic on Dec 28, 2011 01:14 PM
You should go and captain India. Give some credit to Ponting and Hussey who are no bums in batting. Dhoni's captaincy is not an issue; the issue is his pathetic batting in tests.
Re: Re: Re: worst attitude by dhoni
by Sunil Vaidya on Dec 28, 2011 02:28 PM
i suppose that is why his captaincy record is inferior than dhoni's captaincy record...
Re: Re: Re: Re: worst attitude by dhoni
by Sunil Vaidya on Dec 28, 2011 02:29 PM
may i remind you that both sachin and ganguly have publicly said dhoni is better captain than ganguly.....
What do you expect from him? He is good for flat pitches...not for bouncy or fast track. it dosent suit him. so next time take someone who can bat on fast and bouncy track...virat also fall in same league
Does anyone know what's Sehwag's average in Tests outside the sub-continent? It's 34. Don't believe me, go to Cricinfo StatsGuru and check out for yourself.
