It was very clear form the replays that Rohit Sharma was not out. Should the players always pay the penalty for the umpires negligence. Should ICC not penalize the Umpire??
Re: why nis the Umpire not penalised for wromg decision.
by Against Pseudos on May 12, 2010 06:10 AM
Raviprolu:
You are making it sound as if this is the first time a batsman has been given out wrongly in the history of the game...
Rohit is an international player and he should know better than to signal for third umpire referral when he knows that UDRS is not applicable in this tournament.
Re: why nis the Umpire not penalised for wromg decision.
by sultan bhatt on May 12, 2010 11:02 AM
I think it was the umpire's ego that made umpire not to refer it to Third umpire.
BiLLY BOWDEN, nxt time plz declare all indian batsman are out even before they come to crease... just raise ur hand and dance 10 times thats enough, anyway india is out doesn't matter.
Re: msg to billy bowden
by Aravind Naik on May 11, 2010 08:13 PM
Umpire BILLY BOUDEN has To be fined because he has given wrong decision.why he has not consulted third umpire?for that also he has to be fined. Aravind
Re: Re: msg to billy bowden
by Suprovat Ghosh on May 12, 2010 03:48 PM
Yes, I agree that Umpire Billy Bouden should be fined because his wrong decision cause huge damage to wining team
Re: msg to billy bowden
by Mohit Kaushik on May 11, 2010 03:16 PM
Thant god he had given him out otherwise he would waste more balls than runs and the deafit margin would be very high if he was not given out as harbajan and doni would get less no. of balls to play and score very low. Rohit has taken 8 ball to score 5 run (including the chancing 4 near to slip) in rest 7 balls he score 1 run ??? Thanx billy, I don't like the Player like Rohit Sharma in India and Salman Butt in Pakistan who played all the inning from the very begning and still the your side is lossinggggggggggggggg
Re: msg to billy bowden
by Against Pseudos on May 12, 2010 06:13 AM
Joseph:
Don't worry. Even if he doesn't do that, our batsmen are capable of doing the dance themselves and going out themselves... :)
Its another story that before returning to pavilion they will again do a dance when they feel the third umpire should take a view of their splendid performance... :)
sometime back Steve Bucknor was instrumental in giving DRAVID,SACHIN out many times on fake LBWs, Now he is kicked out, Billy will follow him if he continues...
1. dhoni making all bad moves, taking bad decisions 2. bad selection by srikant 3. bad form, performance by top batsmen 4. lack of quality bowling, on top of all 4. Billy bowden gives wrong decision to IN-FORM batsman ROHIT SHARMA.
Re: ...
by Manjunath MS on May 11, 2010 08:44 PM
Thats fo sure instead of Murali Vijay they would have selected Uthappa or the future Captain Virat Kohli. Dhoni should come up the order he is ignoring himself & lack of self confidence. Billy Bowden should pay for his mistake & not Rohit Sharma.
