Bur Viru Sehwag did not select the Team coz he hates Munaf patel coz he had a fight with him in Duleep Trophy match for which Munaf Patel was fined.
Viru Sehwag would surly have selected Amit Mishra.
Amit Mishra also belongs to Delhi dare Devils and Viru Sehwag is captain of Delhi dare Devils and he was the best bowler for Delhi dare Devils in last edition of IPL:-)
Re: MS DHoni selected moron Munaf Patel.....................
by ram kumar on Mar 28, 2009 05:17 PM
tel me one thing.which wicket luked more flat?1st test or 2nd ?
Re: Re: MS DHoni selected moron Munaf Patel.....................
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 05:21 PM
This one and this is more of a spinning track :-)
Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni selected moron Munaf Patel..................
by ram kumar on Mar 28, 2009 05:24 PM
the wicket being more flat compared to the 1st test and batting being the best strenght for india y did they score less runs compared to the 1st test
we encorage our team or joy when our team win but this is our wrong attitude. as all crickter play the game which is their profession.and one should not fail at all on the ground.(service)I am quite surprise when any our bowler take wicket or batsman hit centuri and then they show JOSH like anything that they achived somthing like a everest.why all this nakhara.Player should keep their emotion always soft but no they don,t respect others .which is really odd to see on tv.you are not doing somthing different for which you are shouting or thrilling after taking wicket or hitting century. what you should show that not to react as you have done any miracle and keep in mind that our opposition is also have a same power which you have. so play quitly and show good cricket to world beacause all world is watching your game on tv. so Don,t react and don,t show your reaction on any type of achivement beacause you don,t have continuity.Just think more about this. One game win other loss is not a proffessional cricket. Ye to gharelu cricket hai.
Re: jaffer solid player needed for test
by Ravi Chandran on Mar 28, 2009 05:03 PM
Can someone translate this into English? I am afraiding to understand.
Viru Sehwag is just acting captain and he is not taking any decisions regarding field placements, bowling changes and team selection, Everything is being done by MS Dhoni and Gary Kirsten but what really surprises me is why MS DHoni is not giving him tips if he fels he is making a mistake in either field placements, bowling changes or for that matter selection of Amit Mishra in place of Munaf Patel.
According to me MS DHoni is more responsible than Viru Sehwag coz this is more of MS DHoni's team thab Viru Sehwag's team.
If Viru Sehwag was made as captain then he would have definetly picked Amit Mishra in the team coz he knows he is excellent spinner and also plays for Delhi dare Devils :-)
In shortMS DHoni is responsible for this poor performance of Indian team in this test match :-)
Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this test mat
by vinay on Mar 28, 2009 09:26 PM
on field capt veeru has to make decisions for field placements n boling changes. how can dhoni come in the picture. okay in the team meetings, they can hv chat abt the plans, etc. but on field, quick decision has to b from capt. ie veeru.
Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this test mat
by rambo only on Mar 28, 2009 05:21 PM
Some one is saying that M S DHONI IS RESPONSIBLE for this performance.
He is right, but not absolutely.
But Actually I think following responsible before Dhoni is responsible :
1. Sachin Tendulkar - - because , what of Dhoni, even Sachin is NOT giving any tips, though he has WEALTH OF EXPERIENCE (?)
2. Rahul Dravid - For leaving captaincy 3 years back
3. VV S LAxman - For not being a Captaincy Material (Remember what Afridi said about him)
4. Gary Kirsten - What for he is there ?
5. K Srikant - For making Sehwag Vice Captain - who requires tips from Dhoni for good performace of team, (as per that person)
6. Sharad Pawar -for making Srikant Chief Selector
7. All people of Maha rashtra - Who have made PAwar so powerful
8. P Chidambaram - for forcing IPL out of India, distracting Sehwag's team
etc. etc.
After these worthies I think Dhoni is also responsible.
Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this test mat
by Ravi Chandran on Mar 28, 2009 04:54 PM
If non-players are to be blamed, Srikkanth, you and I are also guilty.
Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this test
by ram kumar on Mar 28, 2009 04:56 PM
but dhoni had the same team sans amit mishra last test match and won it for india
Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 05:00 PM
There is difference between performance and domination, Every player be it batsman or bowler has his day and FYI the 1st test match wicket had something in it for the bowlers but this wicket is more of a belter than last one and it is helpful for spinners rather than seamers.
How come New Zealand selected 2 spinner's.
Why did MS DHoni pick Munaf Patel instead of Amit Mishra :-)
Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this test
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 04:57 PM
How can U call MS DHoni as non-player when he is giving instructions from pavilion and is also responsible for team selection.
Viru Sehwag will never select a moron like Munaf Patel coz this moron abused Viru Sehwag is some county match of Duleep trophy and Viru Sehwag gave him a warning.
I am pretty much sure MS DHoni is responsible for selection of Munaf Patel :-)
Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this
by ram kumar on Mar 28, 2009 04:59 PM
but dhoni had the same team sans amit mishra last test match and won it for india.munaf was also in the team
Re: Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in t
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 05:03 PM
The pitch was different it was more suitable for fast bowlers but this is more suitable for spinner's.
Why did New Zealand pick 2 spinner's.
Who is more famous for it's spinner's, New Zealand or India, Why didnt MS DHoni pick Amit Mishra considering Daniel Vettori picked Jeeten Patel.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance
by ram kumar on Mar 28, 2009 05:06 PM
may be dhoni wd have read the pitch incorrctly.wat abt shewag .being in the ineternational scene for so many years.cant he read the pitch properly.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 05:11 PM
Bur Viru Sehwag did not select the Team coz he hates Munaf patel coz he had a fight with him in Duleep Trophy match for which Munaf Patel was fined.
Viru Sehwag would surly have selected Amit Mishra.
Amit Mishra also belongs to Delhi dare Devils and Viru Sehwag is captain of Delhi dare Devils and he was the best bowler for Delhi dare Devils in last edition of IPL:-)
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance
by SachinTheGreat on Mar 28, 2009 05:11 PM
Bur Viru Sehwag did not select the Team coz he hates Munaf patel coz he had a fight with him in Duleep Trophy match for which Munaf Patel was fined.
Viru Sehwag would surly have selected Amit Mishra.
Amit Mishra also belongs to Delhi dare Devils and Viru Sehwag is captain of Delhi dare Devils and he was the best bowler for Delhi dare Devils in last edition of IPL:-)
Re: Re: Re: MS DHoni is responsible for poor performance in this
by Ravi Chandran on Mar 28, 2009 05:09 PM
But, people also say here, Dhoni is aloof. That could be more likely true, considering some very stupid actions being taken.
Batting position 1 & 2 those who can be behind the line of the ball when on front foot & above it when on the back.Bat comming straight onto the ball not from the slips No.3 (1 Down) : Best batsman in the side/Sheet Anchor who can get aggressice f need be No.4 Agrresive stroke player No.5 Agrresive stroke player
No.6 Keepr/Batsman , abiity to face second new ball
No.7 All rounder - Better bowler than a batsman No.8 All rounder - Better bowler than a batsman All Rounder - Preferably stock bowlers who can maintain line & lenght over long spella to keep the wcket takers fresh.Could be a medium pacer /spinner depending on conditions
No.9 Wicket taking bowler -Spinner
No.10 Wicket taking bowler -Pacer
No.11 Wicket taking bowler -Pacer
12TH - An excellent fielder
hope al wil agree that it is No.5 onwards is a grey aea with us, specially due to lack of GENUINE all rounders.
