It's quite natural to call this film as unimpressive or boring because people like the "have popkorn and pass time" kind of cinema now-a-days. The real passion or sensitivity is almost missing in us. I'm not sure this film could be termed as a CLASSIC or not but surely it has made its mark in its own way in terms of visual excellence, tremendous performances and fabulous music.
Re: Guzaarish
by Hmm on Nov 25, 2010 08:20 PM
an interesting screenplay and story is the soul of a movie.. visual excellence, tremendous performances and fabulous music are value adds, but cannot be a substitute for a good story and screenplay..
It is not right to generalize and say people like popkorn or pass time movies.. the proof is movies like Rajneethi or Rang de Basanti..
people always patronize a story that they can connect with.. not everyone can connect with non realistic characters and non realistic situations..
Re: Re: guzarish is not that great
by madanmohan siddhanthi on Nov 25, 2010 04:29 PM
The best movie in 2010 is SCAM India - as this has so many sudden changes and also so many players and criminals .The advantage is even if you join a bit later does not matter new scam you can see - as each scam life cylce is less than 24 hours . All are live chaarectors and there were no story writes and the stroy is unreaveled . The cost of producing this is few billion crore .Mers Bharat Ma----
These so called great actors are calling it an “awesome movie and it is a genius work of SLB”, in reality they are just promoting this. Any sensible common man can say it s crap and most boring movie which neither has any message to the mass nor leaves any long term impression if you come out of it. If you say these things out of your common sense, you are made a fool. You must forget your integrity and say “it is a very good movie” because it is a SLB movie and there is a so called great and pretty actress Mrs.Rai Bachhan who has never given any hit till now on her own. Even if the movie has very little sense in it, it is just because of Hrithik, nothing else…
Re: worst movie ever made
by shahin ghani on Nov 25, 2010 04:03 PM
GUZARISH IS A PATHETIC MOVIE !!!!!!!!!! UTTER RUBBISH !!!!!!!IN THE NAME OF GR8 CINEMA IDIOTIC CRITICS LIKE TARAN ADARSH( TRUELY CONVINCED IS DUMB COMPARING IT TO CLASSICS)ARE TRYING TO MAKE US BELIEVE THIS TRASH IS A CLASSIC.TRUELY MELODRAMA AND PORTRAYING DISABILITY IS OVERRATED IN THIS COUNTRY .JUST ACT LIKE A DISABLED MAN AND HERE GET THE AWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!! VOWW . FORGET IT BEING A CLASSIC ITS THE GR8TEST TORTURE ONE COULD LIVE SITTING THROUGH THAT NONSENSE BHANSALI U TRUELY LET US DOWN.GO ALONG WITH THESE SELF STYLED IDIOTIC GROUP OF PEOPLE KNOWN AS CRITICS AND THE GR8 SHABANA AZMI AND SHOW THIS RUBBISH TO SOME ALIENS THEY MIGHT POSSIBLEY CROWN U ONE OF THEM .A BUNCH OF LOOSERS TRYING TO INFLUENCE OTHERS WITH THEIR VIEWPOINTS. SORRY GUYS WONT HELP GUZARISH IS ONE OF THE MOST RIDICULOUS MOVIE EVER MADE. THE BOX OFFICE AND THE INTELLIGENT COMMMON MAN WHO CAN NOT BE CHEATED AND DOESNT GET CARRIED AWAY ARE QUITE CAPABLE OF JUDGING A GOOD MOVIE AND BAD MOVIE IT HAS ALREADY GIVEN ITS VERDICT GU. IS ONE OF THE GREATEST FLOP IN RECENT TIMES. EVEN YEARS LATER WHEN GENERATIONS MIGHT BY MISTAKE END UP WATCHING THIS RUBBISH CLASSIC(HAHAHAHA) THEY MIGHT START BEGGING FOR EUTHANASIA FROM SUCH TORTURE.CLASSIC(HAHAHAHAHAHAHA)THE ONLY SAVING GRACE IN THIS MOVIE IS HRITHIK THOUGH I DONT THINK IT IS AN OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE HIS ACTING IN LAKSHYA WAS BETTER.AS FOR AISHWARYA THE LESSER SAID THE BETTER.PATHETIC AS USUAL. TARAN MIGHT GET A CLASSIC SLAP FOR SUCH A STUPID SUGGESTION!!
Re: Re: worst movie ever made
by vishal mishra on Nov 25, 2010 05:01 PM
perfectly put in words.BAKWAAS MOVIE.ONLY HRITHIK WAS just above average.Taran adarsh is demeaning his reputation by compariong it to classics.
Re: worst movie ever made
by Anuj Tikku on Nov 25, 2010 02:34 PM
true & now taran adarsh has this funda of comparing it with classics & starting a debate.. In reality its a rubbish movie
I watched Guzarish yesterday and I am disappointed.I have seen SLB's earlier works and I will still put BLACK at a higher place.The film is ok and poignant but overall it's like Bhansali held himself back from unleashing a flurry of emotions.May be he wanted to keep it subtle but he miscalculated and though we see a lot of potential emotionally powerful scenes the impact is lesser because of a superficial treatment of a highly emotional theme.Before we jump to the conclusion of it being a great classic we need to understand that just by taking a great plot and having powerful performances doesn't make a classic.Treatment of this theme left a lot to be desired.
