The article is well written. there could be some facts that all may not agree however one thing is for sure that if RSS alias BJP stays in power for long, they would declare Nathuram Godse as the father of nation and a true patriot over Gandhiji and P Nehru. All know the 'No Role' played by RSS in the freedom fight.
Re: Re: Valid Points
by rajarshi banerjee on Feb 12, 2018 04:56 PM
So typical of you like your party to shoot & scoot. No replies to my comments further except hahahahahahahahaha.......the easiest way to dodge when one runs out of logic & argument.
Re: Re: Re: Valid Points
by MindSpace on Feb 12, 2018 07:11 PM
Don't worry about 'Shoot and scoot" guys. You have put your point Brilliantly! You will find many such "andh bhakts" of various political parties in India!
Re: Re: Re: Valid Points
by naraen ganapathy on Feb 13, 2018 01:27 AM
Whatever process took place for selecting people for internal positions of party and accepted within then INC is their internal matter. Irrespective of differences he might have had with other Congress stalwarts Sardar is a Congress stalwart, there is no need of paint and he died of illness, not killed for having some difference as you imply which makes credibility of your comments questionable, and anyway there nothing to credit BJP for anything in your comments. How on earth would Modi know what would have happened if Patel was PM? Instead of dwelling in the past and predicting things which didn't happen, hope he will focus on present day needs of our country.
Re: Re: Valid Points
by Satheesh KR on Feb 13, 2018 08:58 AM
In India you should not talk about our culture and hndus then you will be called as communal. Even after independence people are still living like british era slaves and blindly support one family and support their screwing up of our history just for vote bank politics and apeasement of one comunity.
The author does have some valid points but he has been highly economical with the truth. He provides versions of both Durga Das & Maulana Azad but conveniently is silent about the actual voting process that took place when finally the prez of the then INC was being selected when Nehru managed to secure just two votes while 17 votes went in favour of Sardar Patel.
Secondly, he paints Sardar as a Congress stalwart. Sure he was the HM under Nehru but he had serious & big time differences with both Gandhi & Nehru especially on the issue of doling out 55crores to Pakistan at that critical juncture. More importantly Sardar had a decade before written several reminders about Tibet & China's designs on Tibet along with other border areas which the then PM did nothing except sitting on. Sure Sardar banned RSS which was subsequently overturned by the courts but as an upright person, whatever difference he would have had with anyone, nothing justified the killing of a human being. So again, here the author chooses to completely side step on this issue & only highlight the convenient portions.
Thirdly, Simla Agreement of 1972, bartered away everything that India had gained militarily during 71 creation of Bangladesh. It was stunning role reversal where Mrs. Gandhi for reasons best known to her handed over all the 93000 POWs on a platter to Gen. Ayub Khan without negotiating anything else except for no third party intervention which we all know how much Pakistan wou
Re: Some valid points but been economical with the truth
by Satyajeet Singh Yadava on Feb 12, 2018 03:27 PM
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahaahaha!!!!!Ki Dada,Modi Moshai kee korchhe,Pakistaner Jannye????????????
Re: Re: Some valid points but been economical with the truth
by rajarshi banerjee on Feb 12, 2018 03:52 PM
Mr. SSY, what could your fav. party do with Pakistan all thru the 56yrs of their rule?
Re: Some valid points but been economical with the truth
by rajarshi banerjee on Feb 12, 2018 03:32 PM
would follow in the future years.
Fourth, the Nizam of Hyderabad & the State of Travancore too did not want to accede to Indian Union as they would lose they humoungous amount of wealth which was amassed by them. What did Sardar do, he threatened them with sending the army in & they had to sign the instrument of accession. Kashmir did not join the Indian Union till 1947 Aug but whether it was purely because Hari Singh wanted to remain independant or there were other reasons, the jury is still out there to be decided.
Fifth, the word jumla should not be coming from the author who seems to be leaning heavily towards one party. The party that ruled India for well over 55yrs & gave us hundreds of jumlas over the 6 decades calling out a under 4yr old govt is the worst example of pot of the blacksmith calling the kettle black.
If my aunt would have been a male he would have been my uncle, mister Utkarsh. Ifs & buts have no significance when you try to equate Patel's descendants with Nehru's. How on earth do you know that Patel would have followed exactly the same trend of dynastic politics which Nehru upto his 4th generation chooses to follow? So please lets not go predicting on something which never happened. What if that had happened is a totally different matter as both probabilities exist. Lastly but the most important pointer, if Mr. Utkarsh wants to put corrupt under inverted commas & justify the loot of 9 lakh crores of public money, hardly anythin
Re: Some valid points but been economical with the truth
by jeni anto on Feb 12, 2018 06:46 PM
india is more biased towards politicians from north. it is good if india is ruled by a south indian just like rao did wonders as pm
Re: Some valid points but been economical with the truth
by naraen ganapathy on Feb 13, 2018 01:25 AM
Whatever process took place for selecting people for internal positions of party and accepted within then INC is their internal matter. Irrespective of differences he might have had with other Congress stalwarts Sardar is a Congress stalwart, there is no need of paint and he died of illness, not killed for having some difference as you imply which makes credibility of your comments questionable, and anyway there nothing to credit BJP for anything in your comments. How on earth would Modi know what would have happened if Patel was PM? Instead of dwelling in the past and predicting things which didn't happen, hope he will focus on present day needs of our country.
Mishraji You seemed to be knowing history so well........who gave us the first Jumla.....Garibi Hatao???? Rediffji Kindly ask this question to Mishraji.
Re: First Jumla: Garibi Hatao
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 03:04 PM
The slogan Garibi Hatao given by Late Indira Gandhi, then PM of the country was the biggest jhumla in the history of Indian politics.
Re: First Jumla: Garibi Hatao
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 03:04 PM
The slogan Garibi Hatao given by Late Indira Gandhi, then PM of the country was the biggest jhumla in the history of Indian politics.
Re: Re: First Jumla: Garibi Hatao
by Satyajeet Singh Yadava on Feb 12, 2018 03:30 PM
She gave 1 JHumla,but Sevakjeeeee has opened Pandora's box full of JHumlaaaaas & Acronyms??????????????????????
Re: Re: Re: First Jumla: Garibi Hatao
by rajarshi banerjee on Feb 12, 2018 03:57 PM
So 1 jumla is justified. You mean to say it is ok for X to murder 2 people since Y has murdered 4 people? Two wrongs never make a right. Please it was not just one jumla, there were thousands of jumlas since 1952 till present given by Congress, so let not the pot call the kettle black.
Re: Re: First Jumla: Garibi Hatao
by Ashim Manna on Feb 12, 2018 06:59 PM
Same "jumla" thing happens today also that is by Modi. So many "jumla" giving by modi also.
Utkarsh Know the difference between fact and fiction. You have based your silly article on fiction. Looks like you are a committed Congress member and adore Rahul Gandhi. The choice is yours. But soon you will go into oblivion.
it is very pity that many senior politicians are destroying facts and presenting wrong pictures to country people, such politicians have started a new trend of giving legitimacy to false cheap publicity, it cant be ignorance but a deliberate act....
Re: Mishraji himself is whatsapp expert it seems
by vidwan soni on Feb 12, 2018 03:13 PM
You fool, you have less understanding it appears! Only RSS people have yours-like mind.
Re: Mishraji himself is whatsapp expert it seems
by vidwan soni on Feb 12, 2018 03:14 PM
You fool, you have less understanding it appears! Only RSS people have yours-like mind.
Re: Mishraji himself is whatsapp expert it seems
by vidwan soni on Feb 12, 2018 03:14 PM
You fool, you have less understanding it appears! Only RSS people have yours-like mind.
People of this country came to know that PM, Modi is a liar and he is not at all capable for PM post. It is better to resign from this post and make the way for a capabale PM, like Advani, etc. But before he resign he should explain or justify Rs. 59000 crores deals of Rafale deals.
Re: Modi is a liar & should resign as PM.
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 02:36 PM
Commie babu, the people of this country has given an absolute mandate to the person in whom they have faith, trust and confidence and has rejected commies almost everywhere in this country. You people can not do anything except continuing your never ending kraaaa......kraaaa.....kraaaa.. all the time and can have have only bald, vague and wild allegations without absolutely anything to substantiate any of your allegations.
Re: Modi is a liar & should resign as PM.
by sunnyp on Feb 12, 2018 02:40 PM
People of this country voted him for PM knowing very well his capabilities. Ask explanation from Cong rass who and why stopped them from finalizing RAFALE ? Try and find out Why industries fail to survive leaving millions un employed in commie world WB and Kerala....
Re: Re: Modi is a liar & should resign as PM.
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 03:09 PM
This commie Babu and his other colleague useless, jobless komaaaaali has habit of pointing their dirty fingers at others but will never say a single word against the party and ideology they blindly support. Fortunately for the country, the party they blindly support has only 16 seats in both house of the parliament out of total 786 seats and for years they are continuously rejected by the people of this country almost everywhere.
Re: Re: Modi is a liar & should resig
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 03:10 PM
This commie Babu and his other colleague useless, jobless komaaaaali has habit of pointing their dirty fingers at others but will never say a single word against the party and ideology they blindly support. Fortunately for the country, the party they blindly support has only 16 seats in both house of the parliament out of total 786 seats and for years they are continuously rejected by the people of this country almost everywhere.
Re: Re: Modi is a liar & shou
by P S SHAH on Feb 12, 2018 03:10 PM
This commie Babu and his other colleague useless, jobless komaaaaali has habit of pointing their dirty fingers at others but will never say a single word against the party and ideology they blindly support. Fortunately for the country, the party they blindly support has only 16 seats in both house of the parliament out of total 786 seats and for years they are continuously rejected by the people of this country almost everywhere.
