Discussion Board

Revealed: Why Censors bleeped 6 words in Amartya film


Total 163 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Story editor
How long?
by Story editor on Jul 15, 2017 10:13 AM  | Hide replies

How blind can you guys become in the support of one loud mouthed man and ideology that you shoot down global achievers across fields who make perfect sense?

When our kids will ask why were we going gaga over the likes of Yogi Adityanath and why we did not stop India from being a Hindu Taliban, we would not have an answer. Prof Sen has hit the nail on the head.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Amod Karnik
Re: How long?
by Amod Karnik on Jul 16, 2017 12:29 AM
Pls use your real name here. So that we know your identity. I have forwarded this message to the Mumbai crime branch cyber cell.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
P S SHAH
Re: How long?
by P S SHAH on Jul 16, 2017 12:50 AM
Story editor, the coward with no real name and identity,How blind you are that you support one of the most bias and color blind man who has done nothing for Indian economy and has always only criticism for the current government. He is a man of only theories having absolute no practical knowledge at all.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
sss
shameful
by sss on Jul 15, 2017 12:35 AM  | Hide replies

Its shameful that people of the stature of Dr(prof) Amartya Sen needs to get censorship clearance from petty film producers like Pahlaj Nihalani. And that too for his own personal views.
When Mr Nihalani comes out in media and speaks about law he should ger a proper lawyer who will advise him . Being the chairperson of a film certification board he dosen't even know that he can only give U,A and not allowed to screen clearances . Not allowed to screen can be challenged in supreme court . Since he knows that of it goes to court it will be cleared he have done this.
India is watching silently and understanding how anybody in BJP can talk any rubbish about not only our nobel laureates but even about the father of the nation !
Shame Shame ...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
KARAN
Re: shameful
by KARAN on Jul 15, 2017 06:06 AM
The person Sen has been anti hinduthba, anti RSS person whose ways at NAlanda forced people to throw him out.In a Hindu majority country if we donot preach our values,can we do it in Saudi.Also if somebody does not have understanding of some value or concepts,honorable are those who become silemt,and den is not a honorable man.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Story editor
Re: Re: shameful
by Story editor on Jul 15, 2017 10:11 AM
One should be anti RSS and Hindutva, it has nothing to do with what Hinduism stands for

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RAJKUMAR
Re: shameful
by RAJKUMAR on Jul 15, 2017 08:46 AM
Dear SSS,
nobody is above law.All are equals and so is Dr SEn. So ,kindly do not give the superiority logic.
Secondly. The censor board has done Dr Sen a lot of favour or else , he would have been flooded with defamation/libel/hurting religious sentiments.
Thanks!
Rajkumar

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:43 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:43 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:43 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:43 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:43 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
narendra murthy
Re: Re: shameful
by narendra murthy on Jul 16, 2017 12:44 PM
See these bunch of intellectuals have fed themselves fatly on missionary money. This old chap is always uttering nonsense about Modi and BJP government even before 2014 elections with a clear agenda. Its not a child's play that you should be allowed to spit venom against a particular community for your own benefits and expect others to remain silent. NDTV has been airing this censorship news on their headlines continuously for reasons best known to them. Please find out if this guy is also a convert just like Prannoy and Arundhati. Finally there can never be a one way road for too long. Don't whine when you are asked to show neutrality. Nobody cares about Nobel Prize. That Pakistani girl is another example. She praises fundamental Islam and is revered by Indian siculars. They deserve to be shown their place. Jai Hind.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RSrinivasan
Re: shameful
by RSrinivasan on Jul 15, 2017 08:57 AM
Nobel prize was given to him not for defaming our Nation and vast majority of Hindus. Secularism does not mean support all other religions and ditch Hinduism.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
NAGRAJ KV
Re: shameful
by NAGRAJ KV on Jul 15, 2017 09:44 AM
SSS.. useless..!!... Sen is also uselss.. only talk.. no contribuion..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
pranab banerjee
Re: Re: shameful
by pranab banerjee on Jul 15, 2017 10:06 AM
Mr.SSS,
The word shameful should be applied to you not Nihalani who has done the right thing.
Amartya Sen has no stature.
He is technically a worthless person.
A man who dares to show his nation in poor light deserves no staure.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Kundapur Kumar
Amartya Sen
by Kundapur Kumar on Jul 14, 2017 09:27 PM

Dr Sen considered as an expert adviser to the UPA govt could not show any direction to then MMS govt. However still he is soft cornered to non NDA political parties. He is more of a politician than an educationist.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
NV VENKATRAMAN
Amartya Sen
by NV VENKATRAMAN on Jul 14, 2017 06:39 PM  | Hide replies

Dr Sen has a sub- conscious antipathy towards the present government in Delhi. That's amply clear from his view points at different times. But, he fails to look at the larger picture and has a repetitive tendency to equate everything wrong with the Hindutva group. He has a convenient memory to omit the left oriented violence, which is a greater threat to the country.
After going through the story, It is felt that Shri Nihalani has a point.
Our media have unfortunately made a villi on out of him, though I do not agree with many of his banal censorship in certain other pictures.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rahul Balagopal
Re: Amartya Sen
by Rahul Balagopal on Jul 15, 2017 08:11 AM
India can only survive if we all believe in unity in diversity. So whatever left does, sectarian violence will end our county, left violence just requires policing. Sectarian violence never ends, see Palestine, Africa, Syria, Kashmir etc.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
dhananjay kritu
Re: Re: Amartya Sen
by dhananjay kritu on Jul 15, 2017 09:19 AM
All the countries you mention, violence perpetrated by a singly community?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
amit shah
Re: Re: Re: Amartya Sen
by amit shah on Jul 15, 2017 11:20 AM
in India the situation is more alarming as the single community you refer to has an able partner in the leftist_losers here making for a deadly anti-national combination.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sane Voice
Censorship in India
by Sane Voice on Jul 14, 2017 06:26 PM  | Hide replies

It is very clear that the censor board is operating under the instructions from Nagpur. They are quick to clear a film on IG. Will they do the same thing if a film is made on Godhra riots with all the players shown in their true colors?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
logical indian
Re: Censorship in India
by logical indian on Jul 14, 2017 09:00 PM
It is clear. When khangress was there also it was same only

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Sane Voice
Re: Re: Censorship in India
by Sane Voice on Jul 14, 2017 11:54 PM
It was the same under khangress and continues under sanghis. What is the difference between khangress and sanghis? Both of them are doing the same thing and sanghis have the audacity to claim whatever they are doing is THE RIGHT THING--be it vyapam scam, gau rakshaks, etc.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
amit shah
Re: Re: Re: Censorship in India
by amit shah on Jul 15, 2017 11:23 AM
if both are same, then why only object, ridicule and protest against one and taking for granted by the other? selectivity, hypocrisy, sycophancy? take your pick, all are the same.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Nisar Dhenkar
AMARTAYA FILM
by Nisar Dhenkar on Jul 14, 2017 06:22 PM  | Hide replies

SINCE BJP IS IN POWER. THOSE WHO ARE AGAINST THEM. THEY TRIED TO HUMILIATE PEOPLE , THOSE WHO ARE IN THEIR FAVOUR THEY WILL HELP THEM. THEY ARAE TRYING TO HARASS PEOPLE . AMARTY SEN IS REPUTED MAN GOVT SHOULD BE PROUD ON HIM

    Forward  |  Report abuse
logical indian
Re: AMARTAYA FILM
by logical indian on Jul 14, 2017 09:02 PM
Reputed for? Writing bakwaas in name.of freedom of speech

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Kundapur Kumar
Re: Re: AMARTAYA FILM
by Kundapur Kumar on Jul 14, 2017 09:37 PM
What are the Proud thing? He used to come to India on govt. expenditure as if he will improve the economy of the country. Every one knows he is utterly failed.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
NAGRAJ KV
Re: AMARTAYA FILM
by NAGRAJ KV on Jul 15, 2017 09:41 AM
if you want you be proud...? many doggs come and go.. we are not bothered....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 163 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message