I salute Ms.Sunita Narain for putting things in proper perspective. She is erudite, crisp in her presentation of facts and has compassion in all her writings. There are whole communities which have to depend on leather from dead cattle. The tanning industry across states will be finished. The Kolhapuri chappal industry will be finished. As it is Government is not able to create jobs for people and here you are destroying whole industries for an ideal which the Government may or may not be able to fulfill - Protection fo the Cow. What about the rampant malnutrition prevailing in our country and the protein deficiency. The more protein rich the diet the less the number of children. protein acts as a natural family planning agent. Do all you can to protect the cow but to not allow dead cow's cadaver for tanning is not right. One has no right to destroy livelihoods of thousands in this country because your religious beliefs do not permit cow slaughter. There will be widespread unrest in society and children will die of malnutrition. A bitter summer of discontent is in store ahead.
Re: Why I would not support a ban on meat
by Harish Manwani on Apr 05, 2017 11:05 AM
You are very correct, but unfortunately in the mobocracy we live in, people will kill human beings to protect cows. Apparently this is what their Gods have taught them.
WHY WE ARE THINKING OF OUR PROFIT AND LOSE,OUR RELIGION,WHAT IS RIGHT AND WRONG FOR US.WHY CANT WE THINK ABOUT THAT COW,HIS PAIN, WHICH WE KILL FOR US.WE CANT JUSTIFY KILLING IN ANY MANNER WEATHER IT IS OF ANIMAL OR HUMAN BEING
Re: KILLING
by MHS on Apr 04, 2017 05:24 PM
Beta, what you are saying is no different from the conflict between religion and science; which has been going on for many centuries.
Re: KILLING
by Harish Manwani on Apr 05, 2017 11:04 AM
Your community is very careful not to kill even insects, but doesn't think twice before sucking the life out of human beings. Don't even talk about pain. It rhymes with your name.
WHY WE ARE THINKING OF OUR PROFIT AND LOSE,OUR RELIGION,WHAT IS RIGHT AND WRONG FOR US.WHY CANT WE THINK ABOUT THAT COW,HIS PAIN, WHICH WE KILL FOR US.WE CANT JUSTIFY KILLING IN ANY MANNER WEATHER IT IS OF ANIMAL OR HUMAN BEING
we should not kill and eat any animal because we telling for human life and have human right commission and so why we will not be serious for other animal along with human
Re: ANY ANIMAL
by Dams on Apr 04, 2017 02:43 PM
Dear Mr. Mohanta, As we have carinorous and omnivorous animals in the world. the same category applies with human being also,, hope this will release bit of your confusion.. I am not saying being carnivours is good but, that is the cycle which is being followed since the primitive age..
Re: ANY ANIMAL
by Vijay Sahani on Apr 04, 2017 03:17 PM
It is not necessary that every human being has the same values as you have. If you want to ban killing animals ban all animals not selectively what the "majority community" thinks as holy.
All my dear friends.. Please note I also don't eat meat but the thing is for some people of certain states it's a staple diet for them.. The same way Dal and chaval for North Indians.. So certainly people who are having it since their childhood consider this as their staple diet, hence they will surely object it.. They are not wrong my dear friends..
