The bench asked, "Is the minister (Raja) saying that the prime minister's suggestions are arbitrary, unfair and capricious"?
If that is what he wrote, that is what he meant. There is no reason to tone down the meaning simply because someone is senior in age. The message will then lose it's meaning and content!
everyone except the SC knows that manmohan has zero political authority. If SC cannot understand this basic fact, they should resign en masse and see some psychiatrists.
When did SC turned baby sitter for PM/people and question them on how to write letters? What right does G S Singhvi and A K Ganguly have on question Raja for using words? Is it not breaching freedom of expression? Probably someone should file cases against these biased judges.
Re: Re: Baby sitter SC -- Funny
by subbu on Mar 02, 2011 10:25 PM
no its a gr8 joke that sc is trying to teach letter writing also to these stupid politicians. sc is trying to stoop to the level of 3rd rate politics
Re: Baby sitter SC -- Funny
by Raj on Mar 02, 2011 10:15 PM
SC is mentioning how telecom minister should write to Prime minister both of which are constitutional posts.
Re: whether raja is only corrupt poltician in india
by subbu on Mar 02, 2011 10:20 PM
i think MK is not higher caste. he is a barber by birth. Don't be so judgemental. first know abt the background of the people u have highlighted here. law does not see caste but can see money
Re: whether raja is only corrupt poltician in india
by subbu on Mar 02, 2011 10:21 PM
i think MK is not higher caste. he is a barber by birth. Don't be so judgemental. first know abt the background of the people u have highlighted here. law does not see caste but can see money
Re: Re: whether raja is only corrupt poltician in india
by Kishan Tiwari on Mar 02, 2011 10:20 PM
its the otherway round, Law is strict on higher caste (are they really higher) and soft/liberal on lower (privilaged) caste.
To be precise.. money matter and nothing else.. otherwise, cant be anay Mayas, Lalus...
Supreme court should know that respectg has to be earned and commanded not demanded. Manmohan Singh has reached the nadir of humanity by siding with perpetrators of various scams. He does not desreve any respect.
SC is right in admonishing Raja over his intemperate letter to PM. I hope SC will admonish the PM too for not stopping Raja from looting the nation under his very nose and despite his original objection!
PM committed bigger mistakes by allowing his ministers to loot public money. Not only that. PM is hampering the investigation efforts by appointing favorable CVCs who are actually involved in the scam. This highlights that PM is also dirty and shd go to jail along with Sonia and Raja.
How is that relevant to the matter at hand? What the SC has to determine is if there is enough ground to nullify the spectrum allocation. Any idea? Any one? Why do we always have to have a very touchy feely approach to everything? I find this ridiculous.
