People are talking about forcefull acquisation. It is totally baseless. According to our country's constution Govt. acquired the land. West Bengal Govt. used same law by which Modi is acquiring land in Gujrat, Karunanidhi is acquiring in Tamilnadu and other states also. What is the problem. This law states that if any farmer doesn't want to give up his land, but his neighbouring farmers gave up land, then unwilling farmer's land will also be acquired. There is no question of willing or unwilling. For railine if anybody doesn't want to give land, then railine will be curved? This is totally nonsense. Constitution tells that Govt. has to give proper compensation which is Govt.'s job. If Govt. deny to do that job then agitation will come. Some NGO, intellectuals went to Calcutta highcourt against land acquisation, everybody knows what happened. Calcutta HC upheld Govt. land acquisation, it was 18th Jan 2008. If it is illegal then HC could have quashed the acquisation.
Re: To Sujit, Joy
by Joy Gupta on Apr 21, 2011 06:41 PM
When Kolkata HC has conceded the fact, what makes you think otherwise? Please don't compare Modi with Buddha. Modi is professional in all such matters which can't be elaborated here. The result is visible to all.
You should know where there is a will, there is a way. The cIt ompensation was Rs. 15-16 lakh per acre was offered by Govt as compensation whereas the market value was approx Rs. 50-60 lakhs per acre. The sanctity of inadequate compensation was reflected in the 2009 LS election.
Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by Biplab on Apr 21, 2011 07:06 PM
Joy, I am not comparing Buddha with Modi at all, rather I am an admirer of Modi regarding development. Buddha is totally unprofessional. Rather I would say Bengalies are unprofessional. No other state people will cut their legs like this. I lived several states I know. But one thing I want to tell you that when market value will increase, only after completion of that project, not before. Before Tata project what was the market value and after Tata it is more. So according to law written in our constitution Govt. would acquire the land, That is why it is far better price than before Tata project. But definitely Govt. should have given more compensation. But this is one thing, still even Govt. gives more some people will be there who will object and Mamata or Biman like people will come to make people fool out of it. If you go other states you will see how Govt. is acquiring land. Actual onwers get just little, middlemen, musslemen will take away compensation illegaly, because there is no protest, that is why other state everything is peacefull, this is the chemistry. At least in Singur actual farmers got the money. And election doesn't tell anything. CPM has been winning elections after elections you know. What does it reflect? I don't agree that CPM fully rigged elections after elections. They might rig 5-10 seats, fully not posssible, but reality is that people voted CPM to power. So I just won't agree with your view.
Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 11:29 AM
bengalis are the most intelligent and that has been proved once again when they protested against this Real estate business which was masked as "industrialisation".The common men understood the motive of the Tatas and the Govt(and their undertable deals which is still kept secret) and protested against that.This has been an example to the whole country and now the central Govt is being force to think of amending the land acquisation law.
Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by pondekathi on Apr 22, 2011 12:02 PM
Intelligent?? My Foot Bengalees need lot of introspection. We are already left behind. Nobody bothers about us in the Indian context, forget about world. Every time Rabindra Nath comes to mind, “Rekecho Bangalee kore Manush karo ni.” Can you name any industrialist or businessman or entrepreneur worth the name. No please don't tell me Sahara or Sir Biren Mitra and Burns or owner of some Consultancy firm like DCPL.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 12:41 PM
Haven't you heard of Prasun Mukherjee..?/(once he was the blu eyed boy of the elfts).haven't you heard of Raja Bannerjee who own a french company which is a leading advertisnig company in the whole europe..??haven't you heard about Saurav Ganguly who has got a place in the world of cricket in his own capability.. Actually Rabindranath wrote those lines for bengalis like you who are not proud of being a bengali and becomes "omanush" to lick the feet of other nations and other races.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by poppinjay on Apr 22, 2011 03:47 PM
It is in our blood to lick others'( West's) feet and be their lacky to gain some favour or penny. And you are not an exception.We should accept the truth. We all go gaga at anything western. Western education, Western manners, Western goods etc. We flaunt and brag if any of our relative is a green card holder. Though we are avowed leftist yet we always look toward West. Even Jyoti Basu used to spend his annual holiday( to escape from sweltering heat and dust of Kolakata) in England.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 12:40 PM
Haven't you heard of Prasun Mukherjee..?/(once he was the blu eyed boy of the elfts).haven't you heard of Raja Bannerjee who own a french company which is a leading advertisnig company in the whole europe..??haven't you heard about Saurav Ganguly who has got a place in the world of cricket in his own capability.. Actually Rabindranath wrote those lines for bengalis like you who are not proud of being a bengali and becomes "omanush" to lick the feet of other nations and other races.
Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by poppinjay on Apr 22, 2011 03:55 PM
How long you and the people your ilk will lull yourseves and sing yourself self-congratulatory paens. We should confront the reality. We have missed the bus. Every state is going ahead. Except WB and it is because of the people like you who are still basking in the glory of some exceptional indviduals who are part of history.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: To Sujit, Joy
by sujit sengupta on Apr 23, 2011 12:01 PM
Thats what we are saying.All the other states are moving ahead of us because of this worthless CPOM Govt during the last 34 years.Why shouldn't we dethrone this worthless Govt and fgive others a chance to revive the state..??
I have been reading your comments last few days. I think I should write something. If I am correct Mamata signed some MoU (memorundun of understanding) with some industrialists to set up railway factories, infrastructure which I support her. Though nobody turns up but did she disclose what is written there? You are talking about disclosing the secret deal, I can tell you that if Mamata comes to power she will do same thing what Buddha did, you will get shocked. Already she started to tell that for railway line only narrow land is required, not like Tata factory, so people should give up their land for railway line. If it is so then why she stopped Barasat-Raichak expressway? For that similar narrow land was required? Do you know how much acre land was required to build Tamluk-Digha railine? It is 1500 acre and all are fertile 2-3 crops land, everybody gave up their land, 1300 acre land was acquired for Balurghat-Hili railine, all these amounts are more than 1000 acre what Tata got. So what is the wrong with Tata factory? Please don't talk nonsense, if you really love Bengal please think everything apolitcally with sense, don't see CPM or Mamata. They are doing just politics, nothing more.
Re: To Sujit
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 11:31 AM
Mamata signed the MOU which has been alreday uploaded on the Railway's own website.If you want you can read the whole of it.Nothing is kept secret there dear. Regarding Tamluk Digha line,for your kinbd information,when a few farmers did not wish to give land,the map was changed slightly to avoid taking their land.Please have some facts correcetd before posting.
in place of tata bengal will get quaotrochi. the chice is very clear in this election. if the choice had to be made between between commies and congressis, commies are a lesser devil. but bengal does not have to make a choice between these two monsters, does it? here is an idea: get out of group think, instead think for yourself before you vote.
Re: here is what you can expect in congress rule
by Biplab on Apr 21, 2011 06:28 PM
For West Bengal people it is terrible situation, in water crocodile is there and in land tiger. Where they will go? They can't leave the state, so they have to chose only where they will stay!!!!!!!!
Re: Re: here is what you can expect in congress rule
by Joy Gupta on Apr 21, 2011 07:03 PM
No overnight improvements are expected. But the downward slide will stop. There will be some efforts at least to improve things. So far the efforts were missing altogether as power made the LF too arrogant and rude.
Re: Re: Re: here is what you can expect in congress rule
by Biplab on Apr 21, 2011 07:12 PM
Never. I want change also. There will be change of one bad taste to other, nothing more. In south 24 parganas, East Midnapur 85% panchayets won by Trinamool. Please go and ask common people and you will get real answer which you can not expect, you will get shocked. They are just doing similar way what CPM was doing, even in several places it is worse. But I welcome for sake of democracy. In democracy we should not keep one Govt. for long period. I can not expect more from Mamata, becuase she is another polymorph of CPM, nothing more, people will realise soon.
Re: Re: Re: Re: here is what you can expect in congress rule
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 11:45 AM
In South 24 Pargans,from the year 1980(three years after CPM came to power,the yearly audit was stopped...now when TMC captured power,the auditing process have started once agan. Gets your facts corrected before you post.
In Singur Govt. gave 12 lakh per acre and other benefits. Due to Mamata's movement Govt. raised this amount to 18 lakh. Go anywhere in India which Govt. will give this much amount of money? How much money rail is giving per acre (2-3 crops) to acquire land for railine? It is just 1.5 to 2 lakh. Mamata is telling give land in one hand and get job in other hand. But everybody knows what is the reality? She is just floating all absurd ideas which can be possible to implement. Do you know all these? Telling in vote meeting one thing and reality is different thing. If she comes then She will realise what is reality, she will get back everything what CPM is getting now. Difference is that CPM got back after 34 years, but she will get back soon.But ultimate loser will be West Bengal. Don't you think Mamata should have stopped her agitation in Singur and allowed the Nano production when Govt. raised compensation upto 18 lakh per acre? But she did not go that way, because she doesn't have feelings for that. Soon she will realise that what mistake she did.
The article writer tried to post an image that Objecting to the real esate busines of the Tatas was wrong and West bengal lost an opportunity of industrialisation. But the real fact is that the people of Singur and the neighbouring areas have understood the intentions of tatas(real estate Business) and have understood the "secret deal" between the Tatas and the Govt was only to make their real estate business succesfull.That is the reaons after the elections of 2006(where TMC had a marigin of 7000) the margin in LS election went upto 20,000.This indicates that the local people are no longer with CPM and are not being brainwashed by their campiagning in favour of the Tatas.The Tatas also campiagned openly for Budhdhubabu and released one full page and one half page ad in ABP before the LS elections but the people this time was no more to be folled and made Budhdhubabu pay for his price for doing the "secret rtrade".
Re: Rediff writer
by Biplab on Apr 21, 2011 05:55 PM
Sujit, I don't agree your real fact.Please don't talk like a nonsense. Even Mamata comes to power West Bengal's situation won't chane, because of people like you. Whole world knows that 85% construction of Nano factory was done, it was just 1-2 months to start production and Mamata gheraoed the factory with thousands of supporters like you for 15 days blocking important highway and finally Tata left. Out of 13000 farmers 11000 gave land, but still she is telling to stop factory. She did not want this factory, because who will get name and fame? Please go to Chennai outskirts, Pune, Gurgaon you will see what automobile factories are. Ratan Tata made today's Pune, he started Indica factory, now go and see how many car companies are there. Driving Tata from Singur who lost? Actually West Bengal people don't deserve this kind of factory. If Mamata comes where she will make industry? Only in Puruliya and Bankura? She has all nonsense ideas. Actually CPM ruined the state and Mamata is putting final nail to the coffin.
Re: Rediff writer
by Biplab on Apr 21, 2011 05:55 PM
Sujit, I don't agree your real fact.Please don't talk like a nonsense. Even Mamata comes to power West Bengal's situation won't chane, because of people like you. Whole world knows that 85% construction of Nano factory was done, it was just 1-2 months to start production and Mamata gheraoed the factory with thousands of supporters like you for 15 days blocking important highway and finally Tata left. Out of 13000 farmers 11000 gave land, but still she is telling to stop factory. She did not want this factory, because who will get name and fame? Please go to Chennai outskirts, Pune, Gurgaon you will see what automobile factories are. Ratan Tata made today's Pune, he started Indica factory, now go and see how many car companies are there. Driving Tata from Singur who lost? Actually West Bengal people don't deserve this kind of factory. If Mamata comes where she will make industry? Only in Puruliya and Bankura? She has all nonsense ideas. Actually CPM ruined the state and Mamata is putting final nail to the coffin.
Re: Re: Rediff writer
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 11:52 AM
Biplab You may not agree but the fact reamins that Tata was there to do real estate buiness.Why the deal between Tata and Govt is still kept secret..?/why even after aggreeing in front of the Governor,the Govt did not agree to give back land..??You are talking about Gurgaon factory of Maruti...how much land was required for that..??only 250 Acres.(see it in Maruti website).Why West bengal poor people will sacrifice their fertile land for Tata's real estate business plan and make them more richer..??If Mata comes to power,she won;t need to make factories in Purulia and Bankura.She has alreday starte the proces by reopning Burn Standar and Breithwett and by dioing this she made people understand that she is willing to go for industrialisation even qwithout land acquisation.
The Tata group actually wanted to do real estate business in Singur.They got land at throw away privce from this worthless corrupt ovvt and they wanted to sublease this land (excluding their main factory land) at a very high [price,thus making a huge profit from this deal.Thats the reaosn the deal between the tatas and the Govt is still kept secret from the public till now.
Two questions to the Komreds..
1.The land was taken under "public purpose acquisation act"...so if it is for public purpose,why the public has been deprived to know what deal the ttas made with the Govt..??
2.. After quiting Singur..Tatas are still holding on this land paying Rs 1 crore lease amount every year.What is the reaosn for this recurring expense when they have offcialy quited..?/Is it because that the Tatas have alreday taken money from the vendors and are commited to them to give this land..?/and the Govt in return has also done a "secret deal"..undertable dealing and so the Govt is also commited to give this land to the Tatas.(Thats the reason Budhdhubabu is saying..Tata's will only do factory in this land"...
Re: Real estate Business
by subhasis banerjee on Apr 21, 2011 04:23 PM
In their Bijawada Convention CPIM politburo strongly supported point raised by Mamata! Most of the member present their a leftist party shouldnot and caannot support this type of Hooligun Approach from an elected government. Moost of them conveyed strong reservations about keeping Buddhadeb Bhattacharaya as the leader of CPIM in west bengal. But Buddhababu and Mr. nirupam Sen some managed with the help of Yechury who lives a extravagance life. Yechury knows it better that unless the Party remains in power it would be impossible for them to suck West bengal poor people. As far as polls in bengal is concerned Nano is dead issue. Most of the people who are son of the soil now agree that the vats land of 1000 acre was grabbed for such small car ( which is already a flop show by the TATA's) with maa fide intentions of teaching Singur people who voted out CPIM from power previously. So dont stop making hue and cry.. Some people posting here carrying Bengalee like title may not hailed from bengal. They may be bangladeshis, from asam or out side India. Take my words Buddhababu is an "Enemy of the People" in the eyes of local people. He is going to ousted from power to come back never. Nano and Buddhadeb Bhattacharaya are now lost case . Forget both of them !
Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 05:34 PM
Please do not be narrow minded & negative in doing politics, when something good is happening. therefore West Bengal is lagging behind other states in West Bengal. Only because of Mamta Banerjee's negative politics such a huge project of Nano shifted to Gujrat, otherwise, west bengal would have been hugely benefitted economically, would have given thousands of people employment. When Modi Govt. in Gujarat took the project, their opposition party supported that, they did not act like Mamta Banerjee. As far as poor people in West Bengal is concerned, Left Front Govt. came to Power because of them, Left Front only started Land reform Policy. Left Front Govt. was never strong in the Urban, therefore, whimsical leader like Mamta should not talk about poor people in West Bengal, she only make false promise to fool people
Re: Real estate Business
by subhasis banerjee on Apr 21, 2011 04:23 PM
In their Bijawada Convention CPIM politburo strongly supported point raised by Mamata! Most of the member present their a leftist party shouldnot and caannot support this type of Hooligun Approach from an elected government. Moost of them conveyed strong reservations about keeping Buddhadeb Bhattacharaya as the leader of CPIM in west bengal. But Buddhababu and Mr. nirupam Sen some managed with the help of Yechury who lives a extravagance life. Yechury knows it better that unless the Party remains in power it would be impossible for them to suck West bengal poor people. As far as polls in bengal is concerned Nano is dead issue. Most of the people who are son of the soil now agree that the vats land of 1000 acre was grabbed for such small car ( which is already a flop show by the TATA's) with maa fide intentions of teaching Singur people who voted out CPIM from power previously. So dont stop making hue and cry.. Some people posting here carrying Bengalee like title may not hailed from bengal. They may be bangladeshis, from asam or out side India. Take my words Buddhababu is an "Enemy of the People" in the eyes of local people. He is going to ousted from power to come back never. Nano and Buddhadeb Bhattacharaya are now lost case . Forget both of them !
Re: Re: Real estate Business
by sujit sengupta on Apr 21, 2011 04:33 PM
Rightly said.In their Vijaywada convention,mst of the left leaders had this suggetiin that fertile land cannot be taken for industrialisation and Govt should not interfare for acquisation of land for Pvt parties(Only for railways they can). Only Budhdhubabu didnot understand this and now most of the left leaders are speaking in the line of Mamata.In fact yesterday,Ashok Mitra,an old Leftist leader also said that even if a single farmer objects then Govt should not acquire land.
Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 05:34 PM
Please do not be narrow minded & negative in doing politics, when something good is happening. therefore West Bengal is lagging behind other states in West Bengal. Only because of Mamta Banerjee's negative politics such a huge project of Nano shifted to Gujrat, otherwise, west bengal would have been hugely benefitted economically, would have given thousands of people employment. When Modi Govt. in Gujarat took the project, their opposition party supported that, they did not act like Mamta Banerjee. As far as poor people in West Bengal is concerned, Left Front Govt. came to Power because of them, Left Front only started Land reform Policy. Left Front Govt. was never strong in the Urban, therefore, whimsical leader like Mamta should not talk about poor people in West Bengal, she only make false promise to fool people
Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Joy Gupta on Apr 21, 2011 05:41 PM
Sen,
In Singur, the people were against the forceful acquisition of fertile land. Also, the compensation paid was inadequate. So all Mamata did was to ride the public sentiment and the people came out in support.
Nano factory could not even provide jobs to 1000 locals whereas it would have taken away the livelihood of about 15000. The only benefit the locals could have got was in the form of small eateries, tea & cigarette stalls.
Hence there was no negative politics. You may think so because you didn't have anything to lose. But for those whose lives were at stake, they have shown their support for Mamata in 2009 LS elections. Hope you remember that.
Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 06:13 PM
i think, you have no knowledge about an Automobile industy, how much employment can be generated from the main plant, & also most importantly, it's ancillary industries itself can generate thousands of jobs, therefore, firstly gather knowledge before making any comment, secondly, for your informations, Agricultural development has been highest during the Left Front Govt,they are the highest producer for some of the products in the country, therefoe Mamta Banerjee can only do negative politics & hinder state's development
Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by sujit sengupta on Apr 22, 2011 12:00 PM
It sems it is you who have no idea how an modern automobile industry runs.Please gets your facts corrected.Maruti in Gurgaon required only 250 acres for their car factory(They did not have any plans to real estate business like the Tatas had).In today's automobile industry 1 emplyment is created per 1 crore of investment.So for 1500 crore investetment by the Tatas, a maximum of 1500 employment could have benn generated.No locals had been garunteed by the Tatas to get jobs in their factory.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by pondekathi on Apr 22, 2011 12:12 PM
Sujit u have brains, but is used in a non-productive way. Go to the fringes of Kolkata say about 30 kms from the city say Ghutiarishaief,Janai, uttarbhag etc. Stay there enjoy the benefits of 34 yrs of Left front rule. Better still start a family nearabouts Purulia, the solid infrastructure will wow you. Lal Saalam. (Now,if you don't understand that I am being sarcastic Thumbs up to your non- productive brain
Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Joy Gupta on Apr 21, 2011 07:00 PM
You are free to think anything. But you should also know that in automobile or ancilliary industries you don't employ every tom, dick or harry. you only employ experienced people. So my figures about employment generation for locals was not an incorrect estimation. Besides it was not my estimation only but the experts.
Maruti's Gurgaon factory has an area of 300 acres, and a production capacity of 700,000 cars. At Manesar, Maruti's factory area is 600 acres and capacity of 550,000 cars annually. What was Tata's projected capacity at Singur? 250,000. Why Tatas required so much of extra land when they had to manufacture only one model? Maruti manufactures at least 5 models in each factory. Who has more ancilliary unit requirement?
Sen, I don't talk like an illogical commie. My posts are backed by solid facts and analyses.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 10:32 PM
you are wrong, Gurgaon & Manesar, Combined Factory area is 900 acres, & the combined Capacity is 7,00,000 cars per year.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 10:34 PM
you are wrong, Gurgaon & Manesar, Combined Factory area is 900 acres, & the combined Capacity is 7,00,000 cars per year.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Guest on Apr 21, 2011 10:34 PM
you are wrong, Gurgaon & Manesar, Combined Factory area is 900 acres, & the combined Capacity is 7,00,000 cars per year.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 10:34 PM
you are wrong, Gurgaon & Manesar, Combined Factory area is 900 acres, & the combined Capacity is 7,00,000 cars per year.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Real estate Business
by somenath_2 somenath_2 on Apr 22, 2011 11:38 AM
I am not agree with your views. In singur, in Maruti's plant there is no anciliary units, all inputs are coming from nearest locationsw. but TATA wants to buildup all inputs because they want to delivered the products at a lower cost.It will be benefited end consumers. freight part is not value added for the company as well as conumer. TATA wants a model plant in singur to delivered good quality products at cheaper cost. I have seen the detailed project report which is viable by TATA
Re: Real estate Business
by K Mohanan on Apr 21, 2011 04:03 PM
Now since Tatas have ran away with their bags and bagges from Singur, the unwilling farmers, who were forced to part with the land by Goondas of Ruling Party, should be given back the 400 acres of land.
Moreover since Buddadev has already accepted that the land acquisition in Singur, through threat and intimidation, without the consent of the owners of the fertile land was a Great Blunder, there is no alternative with the Government but to give the land back to its original owners.
Re: Re: Real estate Business
by sujit sengupta on Apr 21, 2011 04:17 PM
Absolutely right.If Budhdhubabu had done that even 6 months back..Left front could have won a few more seats in this election.But after all..he is "budhdhubabu"...and has made this undertable deal....so now he has entered a blind lane..where he has pressure from the Tatas(who in turn has taken money form the vendors to get that land)...and none of them can return from this point.
Re: Re: Real estate Business
by sujit sengupta on Apr 21, 2011 04:17 PM
Absolutely right.If Budhdhubabu had done that even 6 months back..Left front could have won a few more seats in this election.But after all..he is "budhdhubabu"...and has made this undertable deal....so now he has entered a blind lane..where he has pressure from the Tatas(who in turn has taken money form the vendors to get that land)...and none of them can return from this point.
Re: Reasons to praise Narendra Modi which Anna Hazare may not kno
by Suresh Babu on Apr 21, 2011 03:42 PM
12% GDP growth is corporate growth and not for the poor people.
Re: Reasons to praise Narendra Modi which Anna Hazare may not kno
by guru on Apr 21, 2011 03:31 PM
Dear Mr.Gaurav, Do not praise Modi in public, Kahin Nazar naa laag jay.
America want expoint this country and for this Mamata Banerjee has been appointed as their agent. She will loot Bengal as well as India and deposit in Swiss Bank. She is liar and most corrupt politician in the country.
Re: Mamata Banerjee is American Agent in India
by Sujit G on Apr 21, 2011 04:02 PM
Suresh, hope you are from Southern Part of India, where most people are corrupt - see from the top to bottom, TN, AP worst politicians with worst ideology. So you sothie please dont put allegation to bengali's atleast Mamata Banerjee against whom no corruption charges has been filed. Discuss your bullshit thoughts with your southy brothers
Re: Re: Mamata Banerjee is American Agent in India
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 06:03 PM
you have no idea about the money power of TMC, do not be biased for Mamta Banerjee, they are spending crores of rupees, helicopter in the election, do u have any idea how much money is spent per hour for helicopter, wherefrom such huge sum of money is coming, first u get to know, before making any biased comment
Re: Re: Mamata Banerjee is American Agent in India
by Ranaji Sen on Apr 21, 2011 06:03 PM
you have no idea about the money power of TMC, do not be biased for Mamta Banerjee, they are spending crores of rupees, helicopter in the election, do u have any idea how much money is spent per hour for helicopter, wherefrom such huge sum of money is coming, first u get to know, before making any biased comment
Re: Re: Mamata Banerjee is American Agent in India
by Joy Gupta on Apr 21, 2011 05:26 PM
TN, Andhra, Karnataka & AP don't have a leader at all. In AP, Jagan Mohan is trying hard. Hope he turns out to be a better person. But it seems to be next to impossible given his family legacy.
negetive is her politics. She loves violance and wants to win election with the help of centre,MNC, media, etc. by making distorting remarks towards left parties. People will reject her. She turnishes the image of Bengal with Railway ministry.
Re: Mamata is a product of media !
by Sujit G on Apr 21, 2011 03:59 PM
Tuhin - think quality. Who loves violence? Nandigram, Singur, Garbeta, who started violence? Leftist has ruled with the help of Congress in WB so many years. Only after the honeymoon was over with the remarkable judgement of Karat, you see the leftist at WB and kerala are no where. It was our fault that we have not protested these idiots before. You like asses will never recognise the betterment of Railways during her tenure atleast for Eastern Railway. Open your vision and think broad.
Re: Mamata is a product of media !
by Channakesava Murthy on Apr 21, 2011 03:00 PM
you are totally wrong, the people ruled this state since 33 years and they couldn't do industrialization and can they do it overnight, dont send wrong message against the leader until, unless do proper analysis of the state agony under this communist people, ideology is good but people are not good in CPI-M, I feel there is not true democracy in west bengal though we are under wonderful constitution.
Re: Re: Mamata is a product of media !
by guru on Apr 21, 2011 03:09 PM
TATA hasd an ambitious project to manufacture an 100% indeginious car affordeble to the masses & which could have brought significant industrialization in that region, What problem she had? She is short sighted & having IQ below average lady.
Re: Re: Re: Mamata is a product of media !
by sujit sengupta on Apr 21, 2011 04:03 PM
Tats only had the ambition to do Real estate Busines at Singur which the people understood.They threw away the real estate business man who snatched the ferttikle land of the poors for their own benifits.
Re: Re: Re: Mamata is a product of media !
by Dada Kondke on Apr 21, 2011 03:12 PM
but she has a "brain", and in every occassion she points it that only she has a brain
Congress and Trinamool Congress is looting our country. These looters should be voted out of the country. These leaders, Mamata, Rahul, Sonia, Pranab, etc. are few names but almost all the congress party leaders have Black money in Swiss Bank account. They should be voted out to save not only West Bengal but also the whole nation.
Re: Looters of the nation should be voted out.
by sujit sengupta on Apr 21, 2011 04:04 PM
Who has looted our country..??people like sarla Maheswari..who has got a 300 crore Rs scam has looted our state.
