All communist co-workers, just for cheap publicity and media attn. What a comparison budda and modi. What Modi did? He uses the force to control the riots. Riot erupted after radicals killed 59 people. Here Budda sent his men with modern arms and ammunition to kill poor villagers. Since last one year thousand of people missing. Girls and women%u2019s are brutally gang raped and killed. Many burned alive and buried. Many men are still missing. Media complete blocked out of Nandigram. No opposition or social activists allowed visiting. Where was all this CPM s publicity agents hiding until now?
Shame to hear if some one projects you all intellectuals. So what we call real Intellectuals - fools?
Its a real shame for the people living in a Democratic set up, and if the accept the act of brutality itwill only show the true character of the communist in India... CPM ita a shame... Where has the media and the Yechuri, Karats n Bardhans have hibernated... at the time of Gujrat they were the loudest voice to be heard though at present they have gone in their hibernation and a totally silent...Name a state where this Communist and its followers are not creating Voilence.. Andhra, Orissa, Chattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Jharkhand, Bihar, Maharastra, Karnatka, etc, etc.. its a real shame a and murder of democracy. Down with Communist...
The intellectuals of Kolkata protested against the Nandigram issue but no one of them ever visited Nandigram in the last 1 year to stand by those who were forcefully evicted,murdered,harassed,raped and fined heavily (even for tilling their own land) just they were supporters of the CPIM.The crocodile tears shed today (14.11.2007) were absent for the past one year.Is this protest just to be on the front page of newspapers and footage on television.Why these intellectuals with their intellect brain did not take any proactive stand to stop this violence that was going on for the last 1 year.
RE:Protest by
by LaX Ray on Nov 14, 2007 06:28 PM
When entire calcutta, along with the left protested of what was done in Iraq, did they visit Iraq first. Dont raise technical questions. The shameless act needed a public protest and people of Bengal did it. Hats off.
RE:Protest by
by Debopam Rakshit on Nov 14, 2007 06:38 PM
people of bengal havent done it. majority of the people are strongly behind the left front govt and buddha babu. Only a handful of intellectuals are doing this for cheap publicity.
RE:Protest by
by LaX Ray on Nov 14, 2007 06:57 PM
ALso if you had little bit of knowledge about bengal as well as India's cultural side, you might have known Mrinal Sen, Aparna Sen, Shubhaprasanna, Shankha Ghosh needs no publicity.
RE:Protest by
by Reema Mondal on Nov 14, 2007 06:44 PM
Mr RakShit More than a lakh of people were presnt in todays procession. It was silent procession, totally without any political colour, politcal leadership. This is probably the first time in independent India that such a huge apolitcal rally has come out
RE:Protest by
by Pranta Pathik on Nov 14, 2007 08:08 PM
Reema do you know there is how many zeros in lacs. I have TV in my home and Ican see the the length of your socalled Mahamichhil.
RE:Protest by
by LaX Ray on Nov 14, 2007 06:47 PM
Yes, and FYI, there was no Biriyani packets and Rs 100 per head distributed like normal political party meets. Lets not criticize the people who dared to protest.
RE:RE:Protest by
by Debopam Rakshit on Nov 14, 2007 07:02 PM
Please add some more to your knowledge of history. A much larger number had joined Late Utpal Dutta and many others during the severe food crisis in Africa. It was an apolitical procession of intellectuals in this city itself raising funds for the children of Africa. This is just one example. And one more will you see tommorrow when more than double the number you have mentioned will gather with Soumitra Chattopadhyay and Sunil Gangopadhyay to protest the atrocities of TMC and Maoists in Nandigram and hail the struggling peasants who have returned home after 11 months.
RE:Protest by
by LaX Ray on Nov 14, 2007 07:08 PM
you politicized again... yes i do know that the number tomorrow will be more.. it can be double, triple ... but everyone knows the difference. Common man coming on their own urge out of frustration and matador and lorry filled people picked up from entire state always has a difference. This goes true for all, not only lefts, right green blue all are same in that respect. Head count in a political meet DOES NOT COUNT.
RE:Protest by
by James Joyce on Nov 14, 2007 06:58 PM
DO u know who these people are? Mrinal Sen, Aparna Sen, Mahasweta Devi are one who had been leftist all their life. Who the hell are u to describe them as cheap publicity? Who are the Left Front? It consists of RSP, CPT, Forward Block. All of them have condemend the killing save CPIM. So where is the left front. Learn, think, read, know and then comment or just Shut up and wake up or go to sleep with sweet dreams that all are behind Gov..
RE:RE:Protest by
by Debopam Rakshit on Nov 14, 2007 07:05 PM
Do you know Soumitra Chattopadhay - who has opennly said that he supports the home coming of the poor peasants after 11 months albeit by whatever measure? Do you know Sunil Gangopadhay who has asked why the blokage in Nandigram was kept alive by TMC and Maosists for 11 months. Do you know an economist called Amartya Sen who has openly proclaimed that industries should be built on agricultural land. As far as I know, Mr Sen has a better understanding of developement Economics than Aparna Sen (with due respect to her.)
RE:RE:RE:Protest by
by LaX Ray on Nov 14, 2007 07:10 PM
Yes we know all you mentioned. Also my mind ( which is not yet brainwashed ) tells me that these questions are very valid. Some more questions should have been asked.. what was govrnment doing in past 11 months. If this is going on in a place for last 11 months whats the success of the govt in that state.
RE:RE:Protest by
by sushant kumar on Nov 14, 2007 06:34 PM
we just dont need token protest, we need to wake up a shameless government led by Buddhu Babu n a spine less prime minister Manmohan Singh.. Shocking, when the people in the country are buchered in the name of Communist idelogies, the Prime Minister is travelling to Russia to discuss bi lateral issues and Nucleaur Deal with US. Dr. Singh please first make ur house in order before thinking over Neighbours.
Hon'ble Judges of the Calcutta High Court for god sake please intiate a suo motto enquiry into Nandigram and prosecute all the guilty... Pls. do take action and quick action, people are at your mercy with a shameless Legislature, Spineless Executive...
RE:Protest by
by sandip banerjee on Nov 14, 2007 06:56 PM
My dear Amitava,
We are losing track of the moot issue - what was the state administration doing? Was there a break down of administration machinery? If so, then wasn't the Governor right in admonishing the administration (much to the dislike of the political parties) And... if not, is this proper administration?
These were the people till the other day used to dance along with Left in Congress bashing.What went wrong.I will not believe that a place called :NANDIGRAM: has suddenly awaken their slleping moral.Whatever one may say there is no doubt that Budhababu is very much culturally literate APARNA OR NO APARNA.These masked commu nist(Intellectuals) know no less than others that the CMP Caders are to day out of control gaining the fruit of power for so many years. Budhababu will NEVER support brutality in any form becouse he is not masked communist and have nothing to hide.His fault is that unlike Joytibabu he want West Bengal to rise in economy through Industry.First Singur and now Nandigram HE made it clear that there will be no economic development in Nandigram but still the so called BVhumiandolon group are militant.There is no doubt thet NAXAL did infiltrate and overtly went ion connivence with these group of Bhomoandolon and created terrorism.Why cant these intellectuals join hand and ask people to resist uncalled for BANDH day in and Day out.I am not a communist but I support Budhababu in his persuit for West Bengal economic development.
RE:Intellectuals and their facade face.
by mailme alladin on Nov 14, 2007 06:52 PM
I'm not sure if you got my point. It's always better to protest against a overspeeding driver, than protesting against him after he commits the accident.
RE:Intellectuals and their facade face.
by Reema Mondal on Nov 14, 2007 06:37 PM
Dancing with the Left does not mean that everyone will become partners in Buddhababu's crimes. Moreover, whatever has been happening in Nandigram for the last 11 months only mark the failure of the state administration. It comprises suffering of the CPM and also the non-CPM supporters. Buddhababu intellectualism is just a facade because he cannot rise above his party. He is a CM of CPM and not of West Bengal. We are sad because this is not the Buddhababu we have been seeing for years. This is not the same person who had quit Jyoti Basu government calling it a team of contractors. Thank God they were killers like the ones present in today's ministry
RE:Intellectuals and their facade face.
by Debopam Rakshit on Nov 14, 2007 06:40 PM
tats exactly the spirit. We the people of bengal are strongly behind buddha babu.
RE:Bad name for Budha !!
by rupu dhru on Nov 14, 2007 07:04 PM
Yes he is a good CM. In each and every incident people are slapping on his face and he is accepting these slaps with smile. He never reacts in these cases. Indeed he is a good CM
When constitution was dedicated to nation on 26th Jan , it was told all of us will have same status, now in this age we should work for it. For this all of us (including press) should oppose any Gunda raj by any political party , else these gundas will kill us one day for speaking truth.Nandigram violence has to condemed with all means as the state is supporting Goons who are creating problem thier. Please oppose this incident else Political parties will make us second grade citizen.
RE:bengal needs change badly
by indranil hansda on Nov 14, 2007 06:23 PM
We all know that it is only these cadres who resort to all forms of violence to help CPM win elections. The real verdict of the people is never reflected. Let's have an election under President's rule and we'll find out how many people hate them!
RE:bengal needs change badly
by Debopam Rakshit on Nov 14, 2007 06:43 PM
last election was held under central force and central officers. Even Mamata declared that elections have been free and fare and she was confident of victory. The result - CPM gained 25% more seats. This only shows that opposition parties used to rig 25 % votes earlier.
RE:the 2nd gujarat
by Reema Mondal on Nov 14, 2007 06:40 PM
Modi and his supporters killed in the name of religion and here Buddha and this cadres killed in the name of CPM. My dear, whats the difference. poor people are being killed, raped, looted and mudered.
RE:RE:the 2nd gujarat
by Amol Gupta on Nov 14, 2007 07:11 PM
Modi never killed any one.. dont go on media reports.. what about the sikh genocide in Delhi in 84
RE:the 2nd gujarat
by pretatma on Nov 14, 2007 06:28 PM
ofcourse, Gujrat is better economically because of its close proximity to commercial market 'Mumbai' , not because of any exceptional qualities which others don't have.
RE:the 2nd gujarat
by Amol Gupta on Nov 14, 2007 07:10 PM
How dare you compare any tom dick and harry with great Narendra Modi.. he never killed any one... he is real genuine.. person.. and sole responsible for development of Gujarat
RE:when people will know to CPM
by indranil hansda on Nov 14, 2007 06:21 PM
We all know that it is only these cadres who resort to all forms of violence to help CPM win elections. The real verdict of the people is never reflected. Let's have an election under President's rule and we'll find out how many people hate them!
RE:intellectual
by RAM NAIK on Nov 14, 2007 06:12 PM
Hi Manojit, I completely agree to what you have written.... Bengalis are idiots..especially Chatterjees, Mujumdar and Mukherjees....
RE:intellectual
by sandipan mukherjee on Nov 14, 2007 06:19 PM
mukherjees and chattrjees are idiots like NAIKs. go and have a lick on bong's feet...full, you will have a cultural enlightment.
RE:RE:RE:intellectual
by RAM NAIK on Nov 14, 2007 06:24 PM
All Bengalis are in MENTAL ASLYUM for what their are doing in Nandigram...Killing poor farmers...hardworking farmers... Good Rabindranath Tagore and Satyajit Ray did not leave to see the Nandigram's massacre..
RE:intellectual
by sudipto mukherjee on Nov 14, 2007 06:36 PM
I think this intellectual movement is an eye-wash arranged by CPI(M) themselves to cover up/neutrialise part of public reaction.You know,'somebody has already moved ,so, sit back and see what's happening'- that's they they trying to acheive.
RE:intellectual
by Sanjay on Nov 14, 2007 06:24 PM
Monojit , i feel u don't have much respect for bengalies so stop singing the national anthem(if u anyway sing it)
