Hello Buddha agredd that decision is wrong? But why reason?If he does then he losses Power as well as People undertsand CPIM has taken wrong decision (thorugh this incident) .Now they are describing everyone that It s an Issue Police fired theire only for defence them.
RE:Cause
by Anshul sharma on Mar 21, 2007 06:18 PM
Pls let us c a canvas :
1. As we all felt, the need of hour for Kolkata is industrialisation.... so.. buddha has been in action and has been addressing the same. Success is enveyable.
2. For setting up industry it needs land. so where is the land. Who will think for it? People who are in the corporate world for more than 5 years now can understand that u cann't dectate the corporates to set up the factory in the jungle. they have their own kindda parameters in line with the business needs. So now, u have to balance with current scenerio and the future bengal. so how to go about it... Budha is on it.... but on this strategic call... he has been facing some hindrances ...o.k....anything and everything is RED...including the so called opposition so.. u have to adapt... finetune ur policies in the perspective of the common men.
...........don't u think he is doing this only...so why is this hue and cry ?? We Bengalis are always opportunists... I am talking about all classes. But this is not the time to play any ugly game man... be with him ... huge task is ahead... we have to pass thru' the mental blockage of last 30 years... so not an easy task... We have to be with him .. with our input on disasters. Let's us help him in analysing the ground scenerio better both on his internal party end and the scenerio is there in the ground. Everything is so RED everywhere. So let's help him in finding some Chinese way of development. It will take time but I am really sure if and only if Buddhadev is there, we could give a better and prosperous Bengal to out next generation. Something in the new direction is needed and he is doing that only. Something is going wrong for the time being but don't question on his capability and wishes. The gainers from this system and the very loosers of this systems will stop him going. So some more fights are expected here in this Bangabhumi... but atleast let's believe in Buddhadev and his way of development.why his way ?? it's the way we all had been expeting thru' out. So now stop blame game and let's belive on ourselves first that we are on right track.
RE:RE:Cause
by Samrat Das on Mar 21, 2007 08:13 PM
Dear Ansul, You are again right no one is going to build his company in jungle. But I think being a corporate person we shouldn't forget the social resposiblity.
I know how I will feel if any one come to my home any say evacuate the building immediately as there some industry will be build.
I know for some good thing to achieve we have to give some sacrifice. But there should be proper planning.
You are taking it in a full corporate view try to view it like victim & place your view then. I strongly feel you will change your opinion.
Just one question to all the ppl who believe buddha should resign..who would be the CM of Bengal if he resigns..dont get carried away by the heat of the moment..agreed Buddha has to take the moral responsibility of Nandigram massacre but if he resigns who will be the CM ? do u think Mamta can be a CM ? if u have followed wat has happened in bengal since Singur episode started it is clear that there is no one in the State except Buddha who can lead a resurgent Bengal..Mamta is nothing but a fanatic who doesnt believe in any sort of discussion..she could have done farmers far more benefit by coming to the table for discussion when she had the chance rather than calling bandhs after bandhs..have u heard her speeches..she doesnt have any solution to the problems, she doesnt have any roadmap for development of Bengal..can we trust her to lead Bengal..hear both Mamta and Buddha speak and u would know why we need Buddha..dont talk about President's rule..if President's rule was not imposed in Gujrat when it burnt for 7 days there is no reason to impose President's rule in Bengal..
RE:Why shuld Buddha resign
by prashant on Mar 21, 2007 05:03 PM
Dear Ritwick,
The question is not whether Mamta the right choice for CM. ot having any choice does not mean you allow those who arranged for genocides to stay in power. Even till the other day, Commies were crying for Babri masjid demolition. Why are they not showing the same empathy towards all those who have been butched and raped by their cadres? If Commies think thay can do whatever they want and get away with it, they are sadly mistaken. They have created the monstor of Naxalites to destabilize Indian democracy to help their chinese masters. The same Naxal monstor will start lynching each and every commy now.
RE:RE:Why shuld Buddha resign
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 21, 2007 05:20 PM
Dear Prashant,
Its easy to get carried away with such thoughts but do remember someone has to be the CM..u cant just ask a CM to resign without having someone with the capabilty to run a state..this nandigram issue would soon die a slow death as had so many issues in past(sorry for being so harsh and heartless but its the truth in India) but progress of Bengal cannot be stopped and should not stop..this progress is perenial and we need someone who has the vision..i dont know if u have every hear interviews of Buddhadev..he is the man who has the vision and can lead bengal..look at the bigger picture..dont focus on this nandigram issue alone..
RE:Why shuld Buddha resign
by biz Narayan on Mar 21, 2007 05:14 PM
Between bengal and marxist barbrians, Bengal could be put before its marxist goons. The marxist firing sqads and their supporters are sucking bengal instead of being the only alternative.
RE:RE:Why shuld Buddha resign
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 21, 2007 05:23 PM
the CPM cadres have been terrorising ppl in Bengal for the last 30 years..In Bengal CPIM goondas were considered the last word..this is nothing new and this problem was there during the last tenure of Buddha..at that time everyone was praising him big time..now when the same goondas create problem again we r crying for his blood ? why this hypocrisy ? pls remember the CBI probe has shown that Police didnt kill.it was the CPM cadres who were responsible..
Knowing the shamelessness, dishonesty and intellectual acrobatics of CPM, it is foolish to assume that the socalled intellectual CM would resign in 2007. May be after 50 years, CPM would own Nandigram as "a historic blunder" (as they did about "Quit India" movement).
The least Buddhadev can do is to drop the "Buddha" from his name and the word "Marxist" from the name of his party. His comrades in Maharashtra and other states should stop sermonising and protesting against anti-people SEZ projects in their respective states. At least there is a limit to doublespeak.
Buddha is the only and last life line of the resurgent bengal. Infact no other state in India has a gentleman like him as CM today. Further pepople who are demanding his head today are just opportunists and they themselves are not credible , leave alone their so called party and their ideology.
RE:BUDDHA
by bobby on Mar 21, 2007 04:06 PM
Such genocide in the name of development is unimaginable. Jallianwala Bagh was in British era while here the barbarism was planned and carried out by the government, the police and the CPI-M (Communist Party of India-Marxist). Haldia Development Authority (HAD - headed by CPI-M MP Laxman Seth who is responsible for the MASS KILLING) is exerting its power to terrorize people. Now Budhadev is using the party cadre base as Hitler Used Gestapo. West Bengal citizens, Vote against CPM, for its case of extreme brutality, where CPM Goondas denied the medical aid from reaching to poor, CPM and its cronies killed, women & children, and watched them die slowly by bleeding, If this is what you call development, we don't want it. CPI (Chor party of India) should be KICKOUT of west Bengal if west Bengal public really wants some welfare of them to be done because even they are also aware that during the rule of this communist they had been listed as DYING CITY .So wake up West Bengal & just prove to the world specially India, where we all are being considered as bunch of jokers because of our unwilling to learn from our mistakes. Even when we eat rice daily we need different types of vegetables, curds, dals, fish, so why we people of west Bengal dont be brave enough to just change the government & give chance to other, how can we decide whether other are capable leaders or not if we dont give them chance. I hope my message will go to all good people of kolkata & west Bengal who really wants development of WEST BENGAL. If god is their (I know he is their) its just beginning of end of an era of cheating, cruel, bogess govt who had totally brought us back in all sector of its rule of 30 years
RE:RE:BUDDHA
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:34 AM
WE WILL ELECT BOBBY's DAD Mr. BOOBY AS THE NEXT CM OF BENGAL AND HE WILL PERFORM AN EXCLUSIVE NANGA NACH WITH MAMATA BANERJEE ....
RE:RE:RE:BUDDHA
by prasenjit mukherjee on Mar 22, 2007 10:26 AM
You COm cadres are habbituated performing NANGA NAACH with your MOTHER AND SISTERS. that's why u r suggesting others to do this.
RE:BUDDHA
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:35 AM
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. SOME MISCREANTS ARE TRYING TO PROJECT A NEGATIVE IMAGE OF BUDDHADEB. BUT FINALLY IT'LL FLOP.
RE:BUDDHA
by biz Narayan on Mar 21, 2007 04:03 PM
Does Budha has the courage to act against the marxist firing squads and criminal gangs ? The marxists are the biggest sycophants and oppurtinists... Budha doesn't score here too.
In the name of development NOBODY gave him power to murder people where he tried to acquire land forcefully without thinking of proper rehabilitation.
If he dies today, donot you think Bengal Govt will not run or development will stop?
Bengal was developed state before communists came to power. Before Govt mechinery was barbaric. So, people wanted change. Communists came to power and made whole state undeveloped closing the doors of all industries for last 30 years.
come on guy. if you are not comRED, then donot become a slave of REDs.
RE:RE:BUDDHA
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:34 AM
THE MAOIST GUY IS BACK WITH HIS BLABBING MOUTH FOREVER.... HOW DO YOU JUSTIFY TEH SCORES OF PEOPLE YOU GUYS MURDER EVERY DAY ALL OVER THE COUNTRY? SHUT UP ...
RE:Buddha sits there to throw out George Bush.
by biz Narayan on Mar 21, 2007 03:58 PM
Great people have grandeur purpose, if Buddha can't throw out George Bush then let him be a martyr along with the communist firing squad.
Mamtha Banarjee must be from Bengladesh...seem she has changed her name to fool bengal people and ruin the state completely....must be an paid agent from bengladesh...CBI should investigate for the sake of people of bengal...otherwise she will mislead rural people and make bengal a begger state..
RE:MAMTHA
by prasenjit mukherjee on Mar 22, 2007 10:30 AM
u know what ,basically Budhdha is from Bangladesh (Faridpur) and he does not consider as his own country. That is a reason he could mastermind the genocide here.
RE:MAMTHA
by bobby on Mar 21, 2007 04:07 PM
Such genocide in the name of development is unimaginable. Jallianwala Bagh was in British era while here the barbarism was planned and carried out by the government, the police and the CPI-M (Communist Party of India-Marxist). Haldia Development Authority (HAD - headed by CPI-M MP Laxman Seth who is responsible for the MASS KILLING) is exerting its power to terrorize people. Now Budhadev is using the party cadre base as Hitler Used Gestapo. West Bengal citizens, Vote against CPM, for its case of extreme brutality, where CPM Goondas denied the medical aid from reaching to poor, CPM and its cronies killed, women & children, and watched them die slowly by bleeding, If this is what you call development, we don't want it. CPI (Chor party of India) should be KICKOUT of west Bengal if west Bengal public really wants some welfare of them to be done because even they are also aware that during the rule of this communist they had been listed as DYING CITY .So wake up West Bengal & just prove to the world specially India, where we all are being considered as bunch of jokers because of our unwilling to learn from our mistakes. Even when we eat rice daily we need different types of vegetables, curds, dals, fish, so why we people of west Bengal dont be brave enough to just change the government & give chance to other, how can we decide whether other are capable leaders or not if we dont give them chance. I hope my message will go to all good people of kolkata & west Bengal who really wants development of WEST BENGAL. If god is their (I know he is their) its just beginning of end of an era of cheating, cruel, bogess govt who had totally brought us back in all sector of its rule of 30 years
RE:RE:MAMTHA
by abhishek bose on Mar 21, 2007 06:11 PM
dude there is a difference between 14 and jallianwala bagh .. do not dramatize it .. also how coem we are not asking - who fired rounds at police - thought that should be investigated as well
RE:RE:RE:MAMTHA
by prasenjit mukherjee on Mar 22, 2007 10:28 AM
Yes the difference is there were no rape cases in J'bagh but these cadres have raped number of women here
people who are demanding resignation of Buddha are either not resident of bengal or are criminals or agents of some hidden agenda. As for the intellectuals whether they exist or not in the political map doesn't matter much. Let them be busy with dance, song,poetry and movie.
RE:RE:RE:fools
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:38 AM
Kashyap is right, People like you have no idea what they are talking. We have hidden Maoists - Bhaskar and Uttamkumar posting all sorts of nonsense about this issue
A writer who is known to plagiarise, a playwright often scripting plays to please his foreign masters (read not idealogical masters but good pay masters), a person whose lips can speak about poverty and criticise another head of state has hitler, a head of state who arranges lumpen elements of his party to create a scene when a head of another state visits his home state should never resign his CM's post. After sucking the blood of all people who oppose his party, now his blood thirst is so much he has to drink the blood of his own partymen and women. He has to stay as the head of the state till all the people can be enslavened to foreign mercenaries. Only then, he will be satisfied and will bow out of office on his own, like his mentor.
Bengal's female decoit and number one gunda.....mamtha has stage managed it...she would kill her own mother if it serves her purpose...and put the blame on ruling party...since her fast did not work..she has resorted to this very silenlty...
RE:stage managed by oposition
by bobby on Mar 21, 2007 03:55 PM
Such genocide in the name of development is unimaginable. Jallianwala Bagh was in British era while here the barbarism was planned and carried out by the government, the police and the CPI-M (Communist Party of India-Marxist). Haldia Development Authority (HAD - headed by CPI-M MP Laxman Seth who is responsible for the MASS KILLING) is exerting its power to terrorize people. Now Budhadev is using the party cadre base as Hitler Used Gestapo. West Bengal citizens, Vote against CPM, for its case of extreme brutality, where CPM Goondas denied the medical aid from reaching to poor, CPM and its cronies killed, women & children, and watched them die slowly by bleeding, If this is what you call development, we don't want it. CPI (Chor party of India) should be KICKOUT of west Bengal if west Bengal public really wants some welfare of them to be done because even they are also aware that during the rule of this communist they had been listed as DYING CITY .So wake up West Bengal & just prove to the world specially India, where we all are being considered as bunch of jokers because of our unwilling to learn from our mistakes. Even when we eat rice daily we need different types of vegetables, curds, dals, fish, so why we people of west Bengal don%u2019t be brave enough to just change the government & give chance to other, how can we decide whether other are capable leaders or not if we don%u2019t give them chance. I hope my message will go to all good people of kolkata & west Bengal who really wants development of WEST BENGAL. If god is their (I know he is their) its just beginning of end of an era of cheating, cruel, bogess govt who had totally brought us back in all sector of its rule of 30 years
RE:RE:stage managed by oposition
by Ayan Acharyya on Mar 21, 2007 04:04 PM
opposition have ruined half of the bengal even when not in the throne, if u kick out left front, these mamata et al will completely ruin the bengal.
RE:RE:RE:RE:stage managed by oposition
by Maha Stud on Mar 21, 2007 06:15 PM
the result is in front of u dude ..... they were kicked outta KMC .... isnt it ??
but agree dat this lakhan seth sud be lynched in broad day in front of all ...
RE:RE:RE:stage managed by oposition
by mariappan on Mar 21, 2007 04:31 PM
Dear Acharya, What is left there in bengal to ruin. The last thing left was the modesty and humanity of ordinary people and that too has been vandalised now.Every institution has been corrupted with convoluted forms of idealogy, every human has been debased of his intellectual capabilites by the state, the traditions and culture of tagore, swami vivekananada and Swami Ramakrishna paramahamsa is anathema to the left, the great music and classical dance forms of bengal has been replaced with cheap western shows, you dont have a satyajit ray in today's bengal. The alumni of prestigious bengal colleges are towering tall all over the world, but the present day students dont know where they stand with respect to students of other states leave alone other developed countries. If you still think there is something left in bengal to ruin, then i appreciate your optimism.
RE:RE:RE:RE:stage managed by oposition
by on Mar 22, 2007 02:05 AM
I completely agree with your opinion.Buddha does not want industrialisation . He only wants bribe from the companies.Actually his We must know the fact that about 60% of industries that are closed in India over last 30 years are in WestBengal.Mamata is an honest characterShe thinks for the people and has never sought for luxury. She has many educated and honest members in her party unlike CPM.Buddha got only 40% marks in college.Jyoti Basu was also not great scholar .He was sent to England for study like many rich person's unscholar child.He never practised law .He ruled for 24 years.CPM has already announced that that Buddha will rule here atleast 24 years.Actually CPM seek for different qualities.Buddha is a fluent liar like most of the CPM members and supporters.That qualifies him as CM.CPM supporters do not think West Bengal as well as India as their home.Someone has asked in this page whether Mamata is from Bangadesh.Yes Mamata,Sougata Ray and many other leaders of TMC as well as Congress have origin in Bangladesh.But so are Buddhadeb, Jyoti Basu(Who thinks Bangladesh as his home),Somnath Chatterjee,Biman Basu, Asim Dasgupta, Subhash Chakraborty etc.None of CPM members ever have wanted development of West Bengal.You will be surprised to know that people who come here from Bangladesh get ration card within one month.More than 50% people in urban areas are rooted from Bangladesh and the villagers are easily forced to support CPM.Still in Kolkata CPM is not majority because moderately educated people of Kolkata do want this type of ruling.But there are some fools who are brain washed by CPM .Buddha over the past few years spoke(lied) about his intension of making WB industrialised.But he has the tough job of gathering huge money for his party and smothering oppposition (as this is the rule of Communism). We are not extremist.If a person can be given death sentence for a rape or murder then think why cant we demand atleast ban on the party and all of its members who claimed lives for atleast 250 people (if not more).I think the people who still support the rulling party are behaving like criminals who supported Nazi or the rule of Stalin.CPM supporters say that villagers started the fight . If that was the case then why no police and cadres were injured.If Buddha does not know then why 5000 police with guns loaded went there.He also told atleast twice that if villagers do not want to give the land ,land will not be aquired .Police are trained to shoot at air or at most at the legs at chaos .But it was seen that bullets went through the bodies and at certain cases bullets were aimed at genitals.Women were raped, children were brutally killed.After killing many bodies were thrown to the river after cutting the bellies so that dead bodies do not float.Every one wants to live.The villagers would become poorer if they had to give the land.So why would they give the lands when CM cannot say what would happen there, how many people would get job(not necessarily from village, and of course from other place who support CPM ). Over the last 30 years CPM was the main cause for depletion of industries.Now they see new oppurtunity for snatching money. They cannot resist themselves.They never required people's consent. They never have been morally correct in history.Here someone who has no idea about WestBengal's past and present situation has described Mamata as dacoit.Well this 'dacoit' has never killed or raped any person.This 'dacoit'does not snatch money neither this person takes any bribe.She lives simply.If she is called 'dacoit' only because she has guts to protest unlike puppets like Congress leaders there must be another fairer meaning of the word 'dacoit'.I would like to say to the Bengalee supporters of CPM that communism never has been meant for development of any country.Communists see party's power as their first priority and people and country as their last priority.Even if you get advantage because you are supporter of CPM I believe we including you will be happier if Bengal is ruled by some honest people.Believe me there are plenty of honest and capable people who neither need to tell lies nor need weapons to rule the state efficiently.I personally had good impression about this new Buddha Govt. at first.But as the days passed I came to know that this is the same CPM Govt with same intentions with the new face.
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:stage managed by oposition
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:40 AM
STOP TALKING BS. HAVE YOU SEEN THE HOUSE BUDDHA LIVES AND THE BANK BALANCE HE CARRIES OR THE TIMES HE MADE TRIPS TO FOREN LAND? This is the last thing even his bitter enemy can say that he is corrupt. IF YOU HAVE ONLY TO MAKE RHETORIC GO JOIN MAMATA's NANG NACH PARTY OR JOIN JAMAET ISLAM (CONVERT TO ISLAM)...
