He has done a good thing to bengal by teavhing a lesson to gundas...and roudiesim...police have killed not the inncocent..they are all roudies...not the law abiding citizens..police are also humans....dont they have right ot protect their life and the country's
RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by ravi kumar on Mar 21, 2007 04:03 PM
u sob john...in bengal there is absolutely no law and order...cpm goondas are ruling this state..jypti basu, budha etc are soft spoken, hard criminals...they are as corrupt as an politician of UP....the cpm goondas speak about bengals culture,lit et etc..but i fact they themselves are corrupt, super corrupt politicians...
RE:RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:44 AM
As if there is so much law and order in other states of India. How about our friend Reddy and his cronies in Andhra? Everyone knows what a big goonda he is. How about Jayalithta and Karunanidhi? How about Lalu, Mulayam, Modi, ... The list goes on... Do you live in Jupiter?
RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by Biswajit Ghoshal on Mar 21, 2007 03:48 PM
John - when you don't know don't guess. The people were not killed by police, but by the CPM goons - who fired from behing the police on the peaceful congregation. The CPM goons also raped at least 17 women - many of whom are 11 - 15 years' old. Some of those goons have later on been captured by the villagers and handed over to police. Today's Statesman edition reports that one such CPM activist, Sahadev Pramanik have confessed to raping a 13 year old girl and a housewife on 14th march. Yesterday it reported that a mother witnessed that behind the police-line CPM activists molested and took away her 11 year girl, who is still missing. Today's Anandabazar reports that a woman has reported to NCW that she was raped by CPM goons until her son was able to come and rescue her.
In WB CPM activists have gone beyond the control of the leaders - it is a CPM frankenstein now which works alongside the police.
RE:RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by ritwick sanyal on Mar 21, 2007 04:29 PM
Well Mr Biswajit..u r partly right but saying that the congregation was peaceful is anything but wrong...the women and child were put in front of the protest rally so that the Police doesnt shoot..the Bhumi Ucched Committe members with bombs and pistols were behind the women and children and they started hurling bombs once the police tried crossing the bridge..u r absolutely right in claiming that CPM cadres attacked the women and children and they were the ones who are the root cause of this masaccre..not the police as it was claimed initially (CBI has enough proof for this)..now please understand that these CPM cadres are also resident of Nandigram and they were driven out of their homes and villages by BUPC members..they were trying to regain their lands and it was a fight for survival..but i do feel that Police should not have been used as a scrapegoat..there would not have been so much hue and cry if it was a fight between CPM cadres and BUPC members which it actually is...just because Police was there in the middle there is so much of hue and cry..the main culprit here is Lakshman Seth ..its he who suld be hanged and not BUddha..though buddha is morally responsible as he is the head of CPM
RE:RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:43 AM
Who said it was peaceful? These guys were fully armed. This is what Mamata did in Keshpur. She is the criminal of first kind. Don't talk nonsense
RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by bobby on Mar 21, 2007 03:48 PM
CHILDREN AGED 1 YEARS, WOMEN WHO STOOD INFRONT & LOST THEIR RESPECT ARE CRIMINALS.WELL SAID JOHN I KNOW UR COMMUNIST BUT DONT BE COMMUNIST ON THIS SUBJECT OR ISSUE BECAUSE ONE WHO IS HUMAN IS GREAT NOT ONE WHO IS COMMUNIST OR ANY.
RE:RE:WHY SHOULD HE RESIGN
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:42 AM
Booby,
IF SOMEBODY USES CHILDREN AND WOMEN AS SHIELDS, THEY ARE COWARDS, NOT THE POLICE. IT WAS DONE INTENTIONALLY TO MAKE THIS INCIDENT SENSATIONAL. STOP ACTING LIKE A BOOB...
RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharjee's resignation
by bobby on Mar 21, 2007 03:44 PM
ANY ONE BUT NOT A DEVIL LIKE HIM.ITS BETTER TO HAVE A CRIMINAL OF STATUS OF ABU SALIM,BABLU SRIVASTAVA, HATH KATA DILEEP, ETC IN HIS SEAT BUT PLEASE PLEASE PLASE MAKE HIM PAY FOR HIS IGO FULL CRUEL ACTIVITY, PLEASE DO SPARE HIM HANG HIM LIKE WE DID TI DHANANJOY , PLEASE MIRA COME OUT & ASK FOR BUDDHA HEAD IF UR REALLY A WOMAN OF SOME CREDITABILITY, THAT WHAT YOU SHOWED US WHEN UR BESR FREIND U & SALIM MADE A POOR BOY DIE.
RE:RE:Buddhadev Bhattacharjee's resignation
by ABC XYZ on Mar 22, 2007 05:26 AM
BOBBY BARI JAA .... DON'T SPIT RHETORIC. IF HE GOES, IS YOUR DAD GOING TO BE THE NEXT CM AND DO A NANGA NACH WITH MAMATA? SILLY GUY... SO, ALL THE FOREIGN INVESTMENTS WILL BE DONE ON YOUR DAD'S FACE VALUE. STOP BS
