Re: HI 2 All
by sanjay kapoor on Jan 04, 2010 12:32 AM
Why does credit only go to Aamir? Was he the director, the producer, the writer, the editor, the composer, was there no crew of hundreds of people? You Aamir Khan fans are completely blind!
Re: HI 2 All
by caneda on Jan 03, 2010 03:59 PM
The correct right to give a comment is to only those who watched movie & read the book too. So I request all to read the book (5 point someone) before giving any personal credentials.
Re: Re: HI 2 All
by cheguevera on Jan 03, 2010 11:09 PM
slumdog millionaire was based on Vikas Swarup's Q&A. but didnt Simon beaufoy get the writing credits and OScar????....abhijat desrves his role as a script writer. and chetan's name is already mentioned in the rolling credits!!!...as promised in contract!!
people those who hv read the novel n seen the movie know that it is injustice to chetan bhagat !indian film directors who copy sould be ashamed of doing such a crap thing
Re: give chetan a credit
by Ramesh Kapoor on Jan 03, 2010 01:08 AM
No harm is done when a producer of a movie acknowledges the truth and credits the story and its source.
Re: Re: give chetan a credit
by bitu thomas on Jan 03, 2010 05:11 AM
yes but the acknowledgement shouldn't be hidden at the end of a movie when everyone has walked out of the theatre.
Re: Re: Re: give chetan a credit
by cheguevera on Jan 03, 2010 11:11 PM
ok, we will ask them to add a photo and a mala around it...when the movie opens...if it makes chetan happy!!! contract says rolling credit...chetan signed it...end of deal!!!
Re: 3 Idiots' producer shouts at media
by Shashank Jaiswal on Jan 02, 2010 06:14 PM
Well, its normal to take credit for your original work if it is a success. Why the hell would u waste ur energy in fighting for a thing which did'nt give good results. Only a crazy person will do that. Its as simple as that...
Re: Re: 3 Idiots' producer shouts at media
by cheguevera on Jan 03, 2010 11:12 PM
slumdog millionaire was based on Vikas Swarup's Q&A. but didnt Simon beaufoy get the writing credits and OScar????....abhijat desrves his role as a script writer. and chetan's name is already mentioned in the rolling credits end of the movie!!!...as promised in contract!!
I think this movie has cashed in on the popularity of the novel 'Five Point Someone' by Chetan Bhagat inspite of denying that the movie is based upon it. If the movie was not said to be based on FPS (although unofficialy), it would have never recieved such a grand opening, because truely speaking, from the promos it looked like an ordianary college movie with bollywood crap. It's clear that more and more people are turning up at the theatre to watch this movie becos of its connections with the novel. So Amir and company should be thankful to Chetan Bhagat, for the success of their movie instead of threatening to take legal actions against him.
Re: 3 idiots
by proudly indian on Jan 02, 2010 11:06 PM
exactly!!!! Many people were talking about this movie and wanted to watch it after reading the book !!!!!
