Re: Terrorist!
by golo on Dec 16, 2010 10:14 AM
It is not terrorism in today's sense of the word. They did not want kill unrelated innocent people. They were not cowards. If one goes by your logic then whole human history is nothing but terrorism.
Re: Terrorist!
by First Last on Dec 07, 2010 01:20 AM
Not that your poor linguistic skills warrant a reply, but I would oblige. People with zero patriotism only would find a patriotic film a terrorist one. So, the question is - what do we call people with zero patriotism?
Hi!Instead of criticising the film and its makers let us see it based on the actual story of the Book Do Or Die by Mannini Chatterjee.This is the real story of Masterda Surya Sen and one should not be critical about it.Every ounce of the story is true and acting inspiring.It should put us in shame if we do not do justice to the film by watching it.The director,the cast and every body who even have a skighest role to play or be a part of the film deserves praise for bringing back the memories of the forgotten hero Masterda whom atleast each and every Bengali will remember if not the entire Indains.
Re: Must See Film to Know How hard Earned Our Freedom Is
by madhuri mishra on Dec 06, 2010 06:05 PM
it doesn't matter if a movie is loyal to the book it is based on. what matters is whether d movie by itself is good or not.
Re: Re: Must See Film to Know How hard Earned Our Freedom Is
by Swarup Roy on Dec 06, 2010 10:30 PM
Hi!The movie is really worth watching.I am sure anybody watches would understand the value of freedom that we have got.It is beautifully acted and made.
Re: Re: Must See Film to Know How hard Earned Our Freedom Is
by First Last on Dec 07, 2010 01:41 AM
It does not matter either if one's name is copied from (once) a leading actress of Bollywood. What matters is whether the person herself is beautiful or not.
Re: Must See Film to Know How hard Earned Our Freedom Is
by Chunilal on Dec 07, 2010 04:49 AM
dont make hero out of a terrorist. he who kills innocent people is terrorist and surya sen did the same
Re: Re: Must See Film to Know How hard Earned Our Freedom Is
by parag amodkar on Dec 07, 2010 09:25 AM
You are a true Indian Sir..So Accrdng to your history we got freedom bcos of our very first pm. who was Picking up cigratte butts left over by brits.dance to their tune.give the freedom speech in english after "fighting" the brits.I am sure in a given situation like 1930 you would have shown your true charater.
Re: Stop Acting, Abhishek Bachan.
by First Last on Dec 07, 2010 11:09 PM
Sayed! Good posting. Your opinion about Abhishek is well noted. After all, you can also have an opinion.
Re: Re: Lagaan 2
by Patti Kazhuvery on Dec 06, 2010 01:20 PM
As in AB Senior without makeup??? or Rajni Saaru with tons of Makeup and some snazzu Robot effects?
Well it does not come as a surprise that Raja does not know of the Chittagong uprising . For 90% Indians the freedom movement starts and ends with Gandhi when in reality he was one of the many cogs in that wheel . Bengal has given India thousands of Martyrs / freedom fighters who are now lost in the Gandhistic propaganda of the scan tainted congress party . As for Teenagers fighting for freedom , Mr Sen would be surprised to know that most of the actual freedom fighters were teenagers (eg Khudiram Bose ) The Anushilan Samity was founded to train these fresh minds . When the older and supposedly mature ppl are more interested in gaining power and only concerned about profit and loss these young ppl with fresh ideas were the actual saviors for India .
Re: Raja Does not know
by Atanu Raychaudhuri on Aug 02, 2011 03:09 PM
At least raja Sen is honest and admits he did not know much about this episode in India's history. KHJJS may not be a classic, but it is an important film and should be seen. The sacrifice made by so many Indians for an independent future cannot be over-emphasized. The whole "freedom fighters vs terrorist" debate is meaningless and we shouldn't even get into that. It is a pity that some of the views expressed here expose a holier than thou attitude; come on, Gandhi wouldn't have been able to do even half of what he did if people like Bhagat Singh, Azad, Rajguru, Subhas Bose and the Azad Hind Fauj, Surjyo Sen and his team, and so many others who died for India hadn't instilled fear in the British mind. Ashutosh Gowariker deserves praise for having attempted to tell the story of such brave men and boys to the new generation. We need national pride in these times of corruption and self-centered existence.
Re: Raja Does not know
by Atanu Raychaudhuri on Aug 02, 2011 03:09 PM
At least raja Sen is honest and admits he did not know much about this episode in India's history. KHJJS may not be a classic, but it is an important film and should be seen. The sacrifice made by so many Indians for an independent future cannot be over-emphasized. The whole "freedom fighters vs terrorist" debate is meaningless and we shouldn't even get into that. It is a pity that some of the views expressed here expose a holier than thou attitude; come on, Gandhi wouldn't have been able to do even half of what he did if people like Bhagat Singh, Azad, Rajguru, Subhas Bose and the Azad Hind Fauj, Surjyo Sen and his team, and so many others who died for India hadn't instilled fear in the British mind. Ashutosh Gowariker deserves praise for having attempted to tell the story of such brave men and boys to the new generation. We need national pride in these times of corruption and self-centered existence.
Re: Raja Does not know
by Chunilal on Dec 07, 2010 04:52 AM
dont glorify a terrorist act, khudiram killed an innocent british lady. how did he become a freedom fighter?
Re: proud
by Shri Hegde on Dec 06, 2010 07:35 PM
You should be and so should every Indian. It's so sad that the X-Gen doesn't have a clue, what sacrifice many thousands did for them to live the way they live today.
