I liked the film. The chemistry between Kareena and Saif is so evident, if you dont see it, you're not looking. I think people who write comments should think before they do so. Muslims are muslims, regardless, just as caucasians are caucasains, hindus are hindus...Give me a break. If you go into any film and come out taking it seriously, your parents should forbid you to watch them. It was good, remarkably better than I thought, with good messages and lots of great scenes, albeit some obvious plot holes. No movie in the world is 100% original, bollywood or otherwise. EVERYONE takes ideas or thoughts or dialogues or scenes from everyone else, whether it be other films or different forms of media altogether such as novels or poetry. Get off your soapbox before the weight of your helium-filled heads makes it crash and burn. Good grief...
it is a pathetic movie.. they stretched 5 min story to whole 2.40hrs.. nad why these rediff guys are praising it so high.. may they got ransom money. plz dont give such a review if you have not watched it
It seems Bollywood has no idea about who is Shia and who is terrorist, those who did 9/11 were not shia’s and those who do terrorism are not shias.
Terrorist first of all are not Muslims and secondly if they are Muslims then they are for sure not shias, but they are someone who just follow Quran and no other Islamic religious scholar, Prophet or Imam.
The terrorist named “Haqil” is Kurbaan says “Ya Ali Madad”, means that person follows Imam Ali and is Shia, but Shias are not terrorist, in the end, there is a song “Ali Maula” which is again portraying that terrorist shown in movie are Shias.
Shias are not terrorist, whole world knows this, Taliban, SIMI or whoever they are follows Wahabism, spoiling the name of Islam and Muslims.
Director, Producer and script writer has hurt the sentiments of Shias and they must apologies to Shias on the media and in written form.
Re: Producer Direct of Kurbaan are ignorants
by Sunil Bhandari on Dec 14, 2009 09:04 PM
muslims are synonymous with terrorism- however hard one may try to cloak it with glib words- shia or sunni- does not matter- for the rest of the world all muslims are seen with suspicious and with good reason
This is the most horrible movie and has so many loop holes. I know most hindi movies have loop holes, but unlike this movie, they don't pretend to be a serious movie nor are based on real events. Rediff must be taking money or licking a** to give these false reviews and cheat its readers
Re: Re: Re: Horrible Movie!!!
by vishwaka karantha on Dec 07, 2009 12:05 PM
i agree i cant understand why rediff pleased this movie so.. may they got ransum money... pathetic movie, indian style, 5min story they stretched for 2.40min..
I have completely lost faith in Rediff reviews. Giving more than 3 stars to a film that lacks in all areas of film-making has damaged Rediff's credibility. This proves that the Rediff reviews are funded by producers and directors. Too bad for Rediff!