I believe this Raja sen is a dumb ass. I just don't understand how could people like him get a job to write reviews. I would suggest nyone to go and watch this movie, moive got a message at the same time it is not like a documentry. What i like most about this movie is that it shows a unbiased stand of different strata of society. one last comment about Raja sen, people like him make public to loose faith with people who write reviews. It seems Raja sen write reviews by taking money, and yash raj being the numero uno production house would not let raja sen loiter around there campus. Poor show Raja sen.
The movie is okay, can be watched once. That the director has not 'justified' terrorism is a good thing, and the message in the end is also positive. I'd give it 2.5 to 3 stars.
This is a good and quite different Movie. As a practice, every movie which so called "Raja" Sen rates less, that is definately worth a watch. Thats the way it works.
I deserved better for the 100 rs i spent on this crap called NEWYORK....Directors like anurag kashyap and Ramgopal verma wait for years alltogether to get their first hand at directing a movie ....and craps liek kabir khan go on making such a big budget joke ..and dear Indian junta ..!!! desperate to prove to themselves that such a hyped movie cant' be bad..so Raja sen must be nuts....!! ....all losers here only desrve karan johars and yash chopras of teh world ...(and we talk of winning OSCAR some day ....hmphh..lol.. )
I agree its an old wine in a new bottle,,but where the heck Gangster came in,,,Mr Raja Sen m impressed with your english but film knowledge..n trust me guys its a best performance till date by Katrina,,earnest performances by both John & Neil,,,& we all know Irrfan is ever dependable,,go watch the flick rather going for such amateur critic's review...all the best for your future reviews Mr Sen,,n trust me u'd need it....
PEOPLE WHO DONT ART OF GOOD QUALITY CINEMA SHOULD STOP SENDING REWIEWS TO REDIFF .I WAS SURPRISED PEOPLE NOT LIKING EVEN CHAK DE ON REDIFF .NEW YORK IS EXCELLENT MOVIE JOHN ,NEEL,KATRINA R EXCELLENT ,LOT OF SESPENCE,LOT OF GOOD MUSIC ,A MUST TO KEEP AS DVD AFTER RELEASE
Guys.. we being in USA have face this situation, and we consider this movie is the perfect and very good movie, you people bein in india cant understand what we have gone thru. I liked the movie a lot.
