I don think Raja qualifies to be a movie critic as it seems like he has given a very biased personal view,.. The movie is a decent watch and must say has a message if u want to uncover it... good performances and crisp storyline.
Re: Raja has got it all wrong
by avinash singh on Jun 29, 2009 12:33 PM
i too agree with Abhishank; i saw this movie last saturday and really liked it. Movie should atleast 3 stars, rating of one is not justified at all.
Re: Raja has got it all wrong
by true blue on Jun 29, 2009 01:29 PM
Raja sen is not fit to be a film critic..t.his guys is so messed up in his head... this is a good movie wid very well told story, good performances, nice screenplay ...only the endin is possibly a lil lame....
bt raja ....wtf... since u dnt realise anythin good spare us th torture of readin ur reviews
from yashraj, its not as great as Chak de India neither its like superflop Tashan .... earlier movies were made on issue of hindu-muslim and here its america-muslim,.. its so so one time watch ..if you compare to latest flicks this is def watchable....
why you people fight somuch... Raja sen is just like one of us, he gave his opnion.... to follow or not to follow its upto you... everyone is entitled to his/her opinion..... chill out guys...
Re: one time watch...
by Bipul Kumar on Jun 29, 2009 03:38 PM
If he is like one of us then he should be writting in the comments section and resign being a movie reviewer. A reviewer can go wrong 20% of the time but not 99% of the time.
Come on..Looks like a personal grudge that you have against someone.Films good and its doing good.Atleast let the industry start breathing again brother.
Through out the moview i was searching for the direction ogf the moview , what it wanted to say, if at the last three paragraphs were not there it was really impossible for anyone to guessthe movie about... Sometimes it was pleasing America and India so that Sensor could pass it and sometime sticking to the what they want to say.. A pathetic acting by Katrina...
I saw the movie and can confidently vouch for this review to be nonobjective. Not 1% of it is true but purely Mr. Sen's personal opinions that do not qualify for a movie reviewer. Though not a great movie its one of the better ones. Credit goes to the central theme which has been crisply put forward
