Undoubetly the worst critic of all time...I have observed his reviews since a while and i do also read other reviews and i have realized that how bad this guy is..other reviews go bad too once or twice but this guy consistently delivers bad reviews.crazy stupid guy..doesnt know what he is watching or writing
RE:Guys If Raja Sen's
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 02:17 PM
his review is wonderful.the responses of the viewers show why theres not a single indian movie in imdb top 250,they are satisfied with ordianry stuff.
RE:Guys If Raja Sen's
by kuldeep singh on Apr 05, 2008 09:12 PM
ek bengali(raja sen) hi bahut tha bakwas karne ke liye...ek bengali supporter aur pal liya isne(abhijit)!!...poora vishwas hai ki yeh raja sen hi hai naam badal kar... !
RE:Guys If Raja Sen's
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 09:32 PM
wow,anti bengali,thats what this has come to!!!!others posting.pls take note.ironical that people making racist comments actually like movies on communalism...
RE:??
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:50 PM
he is just a paratrooper.but who cares,ita a hindi movie,anybody can be anything.do they have much to do with reality???
Whenever RAJA SEN says " Dont watch a movie" I would recommend people should go and watch the it. This guy has no clue about Bollywood movies and i think he should quit rediff voluntarily. Thanks Raja Sen. Bye for now.
RE:kapilvyas@rediffmail.com
by ayon banerjee on Apr 05, 2008 12:26 PM
I wholly agree with u.Raja Sen has no clue about Bollywood and Indian audience sensibilities/tastes.Even I go as per this,i.e. when Raja Sen condemns a movie,I am sure the movie would turn out to be a superhit,so I go to watch it, and vice versa..
RE:kapilvyas@rediffmail.com
by Amresh Verma on Apr 05, 2008 12:53 PM
its a very good movie, right from the script to the cinematography to the casting. performances are very good and k k menon will be remembered for this role. raja's reviews have been too bizzare, can't say how he analyses movies. probably, he has been a movie buff who is too enthusiastic to display his knowledge of foreign flics, which is copied from whom. i thought raja will understand this because he is also a writer, which again is an art form, that no two pieces of art should be compared and should be given some respect by looking at them as individual works. raja, a good movie is a good movie, why do you try to create negative influences by displaying your knowledge of hollywood movies, you end up making a caricature of yourself as oflate people have started watching movies that earn some flak for you. so thanks for being atleast any kind of help for people. cheers.
RE:kapilvyas@rediffmail.com
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:54 PM
HE HAS TO COMPARE THE TWO,SINCE SHAURIYA IS NOT ORIGINALBUT A RIP-OFF OF THE HOOLY WOOD MOVIE MADE WITH LITTLE CHANGES.BUT THESE CAHNGES DID NOT MAKE THE MOVIE BETTER,IT MADE IT WORSE.SO THE COMPARISON.HE IS BANG ON.
RE:Just one point
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:51 PM
this review is wonderful.the responses of the viewers show why theres not a single indian movie in imdb top 250,they are satisfied with ordianry stuff.
Raja r we readin review of Bollywood movie or Hollywood Movie .I blv you are getting job of columinist in Rediff due to ur source becuase u dnt have nay skills and ur film reviews r pathetic
RE:Raja ji hamein Baksh doh ..........pls reviews likhna bund ker doh
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:54 PM
HE HAS TO COMPARE THE TWO,SINCE SHAURIYA IS NOT ORIGINALBUT A RIP-OFF OF THE HOOLY WOOD MOVIE MADE WITH LITTLE CHANGES.BUT THESE CAHNGES DID NOT MAKE THE MOVIE BETTER,IT MADE IT WORSE.SO THE COMPARISON.HE IS BANG ON.8m3n3
those people who are surprised at shauriya being a lift off of the hollwood movie,'a few good men'.the pretentious amir khan,who likes to show off that he is a perfectionist is actually doing a movie(ghajini,i believe you have heard its name) is a direct rip off of the famed nolan masterpiece 'memento'.yeah,he is hiding behind the original rip-off,the tamil 'ghajini',but no kidding.so after oldboy(zinda),usual suspects(chokolate,cheesy name by the way),the are now about to vandalise probably the best movie made in the last ten years.and then to the lame indian moviegoers,who haven't seen memento,he will pose as someone who does different kind of movies.
RE:stealing....amir khan does it too
by aaa sasa on Apr 05, 2008 01:24 PM
Listen buddy i have seen both Gajni and memento , i agree they are build on same concept but are not same, the writer himself agreed that he heard the concept of Memento and wrote story of memento, memento runs from end to first and the so called masterpiece end with no conclusion as such there is no killer whom hero is searching,he is simply killing innocent people who he think is killer. So go get your information rite and then comment on indian moviegoers
RE:stealing....amir khan does it too
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:42 PM
you are right,ghajini is not told in reverse order.but that is because it requires craft and guile to make a movie that way.that is whay memento is a masterpiece,and has a rating of 8.6 on imdb and ghajini has 1.also,yuo probably didnot get memento.leonard is searching for his wifes murderer,just that the doesn't know that he has (probably,teddy's claims are not above suspicion)killed him already but doesnt remember.but bollywood cannot dishout something that dark,otherwise people like you wont get those movies.so,in ghajini,the hero gets his revenge.same thing happenend with partner.its lifted from hitch but is not a scene to scene rip-off.and thats why its so bad.same with bunty and bubly and catch me if you can.hindi movies take the audience for granted.otherwise,how can some movie show conmen actually renting the taj mahal,and the director cosiders this to be either funny or clever.its neither,its just plain stupid.i dont ned to get my facts right,you need to get your opinions right.
RE:stealing....amir khan does it too
by aaa sasa on Apr 05, 2008 02:35 PM
some movies are made for fun not for thinking, i agree to the point bollywood never makes dark movie and i see no reason why it should when 90% of people go to movie to enjoy not to leave them disgusted and confused, recent times bollywood has come a long way RDB and Taare zameen par did which is still lacking in most of Indian directors hit hard and still make it enjoy. Some movies are made stupid and enjoyable and are expected to be that way, Do you expect to use brain while watching scary movie series, About the rating Imdb rating is viewer rating we Indians hardly follow it for reviews so you can't compare indian and foreign movie rating in Imdb, otherwise if you see Jalsa rating now it is 8.2 because only few people have voted.
RE:stealing....amir khan does it too
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 03:30 PM
its not about a movie being enjoyble or not.its about a movie being entertaining and intelligent at the same time.was catch me if you can not entertaining?yet it did not have to resort to something as stupid as renting the white house for marriage.was sixth sense not entertaining???was it stupid???you probably didnot understand something.memento is a movie liked by critics and viers.check its rottentomatoes top critics ratings.also,entertainment is a slippery notion.himesh reshammiyas aap ka suroor was a hit which proves a certain section of people found it entertaining.does it mean it was a great movie???no!!!but prestige was entertaining and intelligent at the same time.
RE:RE:stealing....amir khan does it too
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 03:44 PM
and if stealing the plot of a movie is not such a bad thing,then why did everyone criticize ram gopal verma's for remaking sholay. well,there atleast he said he was remaking it,when it comes to copying from hollywood,filmmakers blatantly take advantage of the indian cinegoers ignorance and feel of'every thing indian is good' and pass them off as original ideas.much like amir khan will ruin memento and call ghajini an original.
