Discussion Board View article

Total 211 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
sameer deb
hoping for the good
by sameer deb on Apr 06, 2008 02:36 AM

have not watched this film , but hope its not like that stupid remake of cellular called "speed". I dont think " a few good men " deserves this.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Deepak Rajgor
pat the producer of this film!
by Deepak Rajgor on Apr 05, 2008 09:06 PM  | Hide replies

"This film is dedicated to people who not only guard the border but also freedom". I just saw this film and last half hour is interesting.

New generation in Indian army (ok in this film) has hope for "bloody democracy".

Ok this is inspired from other films but it does not stick to romantic plot either.

Producer of this movie is the one who must be patted on his back.

Samar Khan - good! only if act one of the film would have been more visual. Yet, not a bad film

    Forward  |  Report abuse
pragun sambyal
RE:pat the producer of this film!
by pragun sambyal on Apr 06, 2008 06:54 PM
I do agree with Deepak. I went to see this movie because of Rahul Bose, it being bit slow in the beginning but turn out ot be nicely crafted later on. Good issue raised in good way..GOOD movie, must be watched atleast once.


   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 08:34 PM  | Hide replies

This is a movie about the questions your conscience , An interactive No Nonsense Film ...Good Work ....kudos to the star cast

    Forward  |  Report abuse
arun mehta
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by arun mehta on Apr 07, 2008 01:28 PM
i think the producers of this movie must give u guys some sort of commission for giving this movie free publicity which im sure it desperately needed!!.......

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 08:37 PM
and Raja sen is the same person who reviewed RACE with ONE STAR , and u know RACE Did managed to gather 35 Crores in the first week itself ....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 08:39 PM
so was aap ka suroor a hit,but was it a good movie.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 08:42 PM
Shaurya is not a hit so its unfair to compare with other hits , by the way Whats this Aaapka Suroor ?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 08:48 PM
i was saying that a film being hit does not necessarily mean its a good movie.i was alluring to you saying that race must be good because of its box office collections.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 08:58 PM
but i never said that RACE is a masterpiece , i just said RACE was given a SINGLE Star by Raja Sen , and that it ...and i dont think race was that bad to be deserved ONE STAR ..

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 08:45 PM
himesh reshammiyas debut film with him as the hero,remember.auto rickshaws standing up on their hind wheels.remember.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 09:02 PM
and now who is this himesh reshammia , is he a autowala who scares dogs by imitating dogs ....Buuuuuhhhhhhhhhhh khajooorrrrr ...

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 08:43 PM
you do not really get something.claiming another persons work as your own tantamounts to stealing.and then changing the original product,vandalism!!!!thats what ram gopal verma did to sholay(ramu atleast got the rights for the film).and thats what shaurya has done to 'a few good men'.thanks

   Forward   |   Report abuse
balkrishna
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by balkrishna on Apr 05, 2008 10:20 PM
Wud like to hav a break from Masala movies than watch "Shaurya".A must watch film . Outstanding performances.Especially Kay Kay Menon.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
jayeshdavda
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by jayeshdavda on Apr 06, 2008 02:54 PM
dont fight like this please.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 03:05 PM
we are not fighting.and i have a felling,all participating in this discussion are enjoying it.this has been a good debate,don't you think???

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 10:26 PM
if you want to break from watching masala movies,watch the original,a few good men.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 06, 2008 11:13 AM
Also i repeat , I am not West hater , the simple thing is I Love my country india . Thats it.

And no more Atithi devo bhava Please atleast for peoblematic refugees , not for devils like Tasleema , she is an absolute law and order masterpeice , and say if give shelter to her whats value is she adding ? what is she good for ?

Waise hi , my country is flooded with refugees from tibet , nepal , bangladesh and other countries , So no Athithi Devo bhav anymore , please ...not atleast for the people who create problems for our country....

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 11:16 AM
did your mothe ever point out the mistakes other people made.no.she always scolded you for your mistakes.because she loves you,not her neighbours son.same way,i try to find wrongs with my country,because i want my country to improve,i dont give a damn about what attrocities other countries commit.because i love my country,not america.how does this make me overtly westernized.but you are not probably considering my opinions with an open mind.tell em,have you never.in all these years said,that the politicians of our country are corrupted.does that mean you hate our country.i think not.do you even care about how corrupted the political set up of namibia is,or uzbekistan.no.because namibia is not your country.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 06, 2008 11:29 AM
Again you started comparing ...My type of thinking is unbiased and open . if you dont give a damm to comparison , why the hell are you comparing two movies ? no you cannot compare .

Yes my mother scolded me for my mistakes , but she again taught me if something wrong happens to you , you should hit back hard , an eye for an eye , thats kind of attitude i have. Almighty insaan ko kuch bhi banaye bas darpok na banaye ..thats it......

I dont give a damm if Shaurya was a copy of "A few good men" , and also i dont give a damm that there'was a copyright violation or not , the thing that matters is whehther the movie is addressing its message or not . if "A Few good men " people files legal proceeding let shaurya production go over it .

and i you want our country to improve , bro there are n number of ways to do ?

That it .....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 11:48 AM
i know there are n number of ways to improve,but it has to start from identification of our mistakes,otherwise,what will we improve on.also, i believe you are lying a bit here.and speaking of an eye for an eye,the greatest personality of th last century,mahatma gandhi(not einstein,but gandhi)had onec said'an eye for an eye makes the entire world blind'now you will probably say you dont like mahatma gandhior believe in his ideals.remember,its not for nothing that a man of einsteins stature speaks of a man in the below quoted words
'generations to come will scarcely believe that one such as this,in flesh and blood,ever walked on this earth'.
you cannot improve if you dont realise your mistakes,identify your faults.we,as a community,need to do that.and stop calling anybody with a liberal view 'westernized'.no.they are just liberal.
but i think this is common.same happened with the likes of vidyasagar and raja rammohan when they tried to improve the condition of wemwn in this country.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Bijoy
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Bijoy on Apr 06, 2008 01:22 PM
I knew you would say this... but, my idea of copying in school exam was just a thought of comparision... But, all you care about is negativity of our country.. I am not sure, whether you are just a talker... or, you do something when you talk... Kyunki, I have got so many characters like you in frnds circle, who talk all day that India is this and that... and, when the time comes to do, they are the first to jump red light. I really respect your emotions about our country... but, when I saw today that you have actually taken discussion till VidyaSagar, and RajaRamMohan Roy... I have this feeling that you are just a talker with so many facts twisted according to your mind. Thats a perfect description of Pessimist. Turn around.. .see Our lovely country in new way... you will see lots of light around here. By the way, if you really care about INDIA... you wouldn't have said that Shaurya is copy of Few Good Men... because Shaurya is so original... see the theme... doesn't that happen in our Army... Are not our Army full of politics? Do you know how do people fight for Good postings...? But, if you are pessimist.. you will not see that... our indian army is integration of entire india... (great example of national integration)... go find anywhere and do googling (which you have been doing till now to put that masala in your discussion)... you will not get this kind of unique army anywhere in the world.. and during the any kind of war like situation..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Bijoy
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Bijoy on Apr 06, 2008 02:08 PM
Abhjit.. I think you are here to just prove your point... You are here to win over discussion... well... you are free to do so...
But, let me tell you one last thing... you have still not understood real meaning of my comments... my comments are still not pointed towards negativity... but, positivity... there are no comments pointing to... what have i done... what is me... but, general thing. And, all I m trying to tell that movie was good if u don't think about the english version. Cheating, Googling, and Talker were terms used to give an example... but, you caught only them... Well, this is you...
Congrats... that u fought against reservation...
(I actaully thought that I would tell about myself... but, just leave it... you won't understand, and ignite this discussion further...)
For the sake of discussion, I enjoyed this a lot... so, no hard feelings... good going guys...

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 02:25 PM
how does'abhijit,you googled the facts','abhijit,you are only a talker,i believe',convey a general sense.now that you have realized i am not merely a talker,you hide behind tour words being in a 'general sense'.also,patriotism is a slippery notion.a person can kill somebody from another religion and call himself a patriot,hitler called himself a patriot,and thought that the germans are superior to any other community.what happened after that is known to all.selfindulgence destroys a community.also,i never said that there's nothing good about india.read my post carefully,i mention quite a few indian movies that i thought were good,original but did not get noticed(blue umbrella,manorma,dor,also others as well).what i also do at the same time is point out the mistakes.also,a movie is an art.it is not limited by boundaries.what is a good movie is a good movie in any country.when i saw a few good men,it did not make me feel how gr8 the us army is.i just enjoyed the movie.i dont go to a movie thetre to watch a patriotic movie,i go to watch a good,intelligent and entertaining movie.
also,cosider a scenario.you study very ahrd for an exam and get good marks.but the guysitting next to you,who entirely copied your paper,also got equel marks.would you consider him as good a student as yourself??i dont think so.so with sourya.



   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 01:43 PM
i watch a movie for its entertainment value,i dont need a film to make me understand the value and valour of our soldiers.and neither did i need to google for any of those facts.
alluding to my just being a talker,i would like to tell you something.do you know that during the antireservataion protests in kolkata,the students were actually beaten up by the police(unlike in delhi,where waterjets were used).well,i was part of those protests,and was injured and along with a lot of other students,arrested.i wonder if any of the other people who here are professing to love their country to such an extent that they don't see any of its faults,or ignore them altogether,have actualy done as much as i have done.
also,there are things to be learned from every culture."a know-all community is the flagbearer of a dead society"(rabindranath tagore-library-short essay).by the way,you wont find it on google.we need to learn from the west much like they need to learn something from us.
and talking about cheating,what if the invigilator caught you in the act,wont you be thrown out of the hall??same with saurya,it has been caught.

Forward   |   Report abuse
Bijoy
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Bijoy on Apr 06, 2008 01:37 PM
they don't remember those politics... everyone suddenly unites...
So, Mr. Abhijit... NO COUNTRY IS PERFECT... IT IS JUST WE PEOPLE WHO THINK.
Logo ko hamesha dusro ki cheeze achchi lagti hain. Aur, log yeh bhool jaate hain.. ki yeh ek general saying hain.. means... agar tumhe dusro ki cheeze achchi lagti hain.. to at the same time... unhe bhi tumhaari kuch cheeze achchi lagti hogi... So, my point is that... EVERY THING HAS SOMETHING GOOD... INSTEAD OF THINKING OF OUR BAD THINGS... AND COMPARING WITH OTHERS, THINK ABOUT OUR GOOD THINGS...
So, guys Shaurya is great movie... I don't care if it is copied or not... all i care is that it had a great display of emotions... feeling of goodness... Shaurya... feeling of friendship... (Rahul Bose, and Kay Kay Menon... a.la. suddeb shaadi in night)... and feeling of dignity... feeling of pride... and feeling of our country... Man! Few Good Men stands nowhere... It is bullshit to see other country's army... when I love my own country... We are the Youth of our country... and country relies on us...
PEACE...

Forward   |   Report abuse
KAPIL MATHRANI
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by KAPIL MATHRANI on Apr 06, 2008 07:47 AM
Whoa...I guess the discussion between Abhijit and Observer is better than both the movies themselves!! Anyways..My two paisas...(or two cents, Abhijit?)...Mr. Abhijit- I so pity you for putting us Indians in such a bad Light...buddy, you have forced to become so westernized that you've almost fogotten the atithi devo bhava thingie...i wish you wouldve seen the test match between India and SA that concluded yesterday....you shouldve seen the ovation AB De Villiers got for his double hundred from the crowd and players alike...espescially considering that the writing was already on the wall for Indians right from the 1st session! Well, the point here is that for some very trivial issues, you have actually over-shadowed the whole VALID point that observer is trying to make...you mightve gotten your facts correct, but you have got your Heart at the wrong place, unfortunately...You could do better with a bit more passion for your own country...yes, i repeat-bit MORE Passion. Sub-consciously, you have developed some sort of pity for India, which is wrong...
And I love 'Few Good Men'...ive seen it 3-4 times i suppose, and it sure is a masterpiece...
----Peace----

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 09:37 AM
and talking of atithi devo bhava,i nust tell you,tasleema nasreen was also a guest of our country.and she has now 'fleed' from our country and taken shelter in switzerland.criticizing my country doesn't mean i dont love my country.have you never been scolded by your mother.does that mean she doesn't love you.she does.introspection is not such a bad thing after all.'koi bhi desh perfect nahi hota,ose perfect banana parta hai'.but if we dont see its faults,how are we going to make it right,how is our country ever going to become perfect.never be hurt by criticism,try to learn from it.

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 09:21 AM
i am glad that people have been entertained,i just wanted to spark up a debate and have my one good day of fun.as for cheating,i never did.as for shaurya's claim that we are free to steal because we have been cheated reminds me of college seniors who always justified ragging saying they had been ragged.as for my heart,its very much in the right place.but no community is above criticism.also,you must have overlooked a point i made,the fact that other countries might ridicule us because of the naivity of 'a few bad men'.i cannot let that happen.my patriotism,you see is,is not misplaced.also,good original movies are made in india as well,butwhoever cares to watch them.blue umbrella,manorma-6 feet under,dor...but whoever cares to watch them,they would rather watch some remake of a hollywood film.that his why,filmfare awards shahrukh khan and not pankaj kapoor,because we hardly care about justice.

Forward   |   Report abuse
Bijoy
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Bijoy on Apr 06, 2008 02:27 AM
Abhijit, and Observer... I loved the discussion you guys had. It is good to see few good men fighting for correctness. Movie is exactly about it... hahaha! Guys who love India and and indian army... watch shaurya... and guys who love other country's army.. watch "A Few Good Men". Guys who think Race, and Welcome were great movies... this movie is not for you... because this movie doesnot have wacky, out of nowhere, bullshit 30 minutes at the end, but one of the greatest acting show. Just look at Kay Kay Menon at the end... he is an actor.. bloody, simply awesome.
And, one more thing... after watching shaurya, if you are planning to see the original (abhijit must be smiling), I suggest not to... because... you won't get that feeling of ownership...
(BY THE WAY I SAW "A Few Good Men", AND I STILL LIKED IT, SO I FEEL IT IS NOT COMPULSORY TO COMPARE BOTH OF THEM BECAUSE BOTH ARE EQUALLY GOOD) (Aur, Abhijit... One good tip... Bachpan mein jab tum exam mein copy karte the... to itna sochte the kya? Tumhe bas pass hone se matlab hota tha... right! lol... So, just chill man... abhi movie dekhne se matlab rakho... legel advising mat karo... sorry.. no hard feeling... okay!)

Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 06, 2008 10:57 AM
Look who is teaching Moral Science . Abhijeet

I will give your answers one by one , you typically obsessed western mind .

Where where you when airport security staff asked then defence minister George Fernandes to remove the cloth (dhoti) which according to them is a confusing peace of cloth ?



Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 09:00 PM
Thats what we call Re engineering , It happens everwhere .. Rocket Science , Engines , Software . Moral Science (One try to imitate and replicate the ideals and whats good , the thing is either you fail imitating or pass , its up to individual ) , so instead of pulling ones legs that you copied blah blah blah ..praise him and motivate u did a good job and next time you do the same , be careful and learn from mistakes ...Good Luck ....

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 09:29 PM
rocket science doesnt come with copyright.you probably know nothing of softwares.only open source softwares can be creayed or improved upon by another company(linux,vlc,e.t.c).however,does ibm have the right to create windows 7.no.it would be sued by microsoft.you should get your facts right.no other company(unless tata sells rights)can manufacture nano.thats why ferari sued mclaren,for stealing technology.its illegal.get your own facts right.

   Forward   |   'Report abuse' disabled by moderator
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 06, 2008 12:18 AM
SO u are worried about IP han , and you are worried that poeple would call u cheater ?

Go and ask who gave them IP rights to patent Neem , Tulsi and other indian herbs in the name of theirs ....you are favoring a bunch of jokers
We as an indian do not need to show anywhere anything , The history of Engligh Colonial rule where they looted/cheated Our Country ...So you go , watch and recommend "A Few Good Men" , Lets other watch Shaurya ...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 12:34 AM
NOT CALL ME A CHEATER,YOU GOT ME WRONG.ITS ABOUT MY COUNTRY.I DONT WANT PEOPLE TO HAVE A PICTURE OF INDIA AS A COUNTRY OF CHEATERS.



Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 12:27 AM
AGAIN,NEEM AND TULSI ARE NOT MAN MADE PRODUCTS THAT CAN BE PATENTED.AND ALSO,I SEE YOU HATE THE WEST.YET,THEY I FEEL THAT THEY SOMETIMES SHOW MORE RESPECT TO INDIANS THAN INDIANS SHOE THEMSELVES.LOOK AT THE WAY THE AUSSIES GAVE STANDING OVATIONS TO SACHIN TENDULKAR.WOULD WE EVER STAND UP TO APPRECIATE LARA OR PONTING.NO.
ALSO,HOW CAN WHAT THE BRITISHES DID 50 YRS AGO STILL BOTHER YOU.AN EYE FOR AN EYE ONLY MAKES THE ENTIRE WORLD BLIND(GANDHIJI).HATRED IS BAGGAGE.TELL ME,IF YOU HATE THE WEST SO MUCH,WHY DID YOU STUDY ENGLISH,THEIR LANGUAGE.DO NOT PREACH SOMETHING AND PRACTICE SOMETHING ELSE.

HATRED IS BAGGAGE.

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 09:45 PM
rocket science doesnt come with a copyright.when it does,it cannot be reproduced.like india cannot make a mig or a mirage or a sukhoi.likewise,ibm cannot create any version of windows(only open source softwares can be produced by other companies.for the same reason,ferari sued mclaren(stealing technology, a case that mclaren lost and was dockeda whole lot of points.)like wise,under copyright infringement act,nobody can remake a movie without permission.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Observer
RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by Observer on Apr 05, 2008 11:08 PM
By the way i dont need to ask you what software is all about , my career has always been software all the way , we cannot create Sukhoi and MIG , but we can always assemble components and assemble TEJAS , IBM cannot create Windows on it own , but have u heard of UBUNTU , if not go through it once and then you will come to know what re engineering is all about , Open Source software are nothing but a collaberative approach to build softwares , an obviously if different poeople work on a same entity no one can claim on it , I Myself is a open source contributor , if u replicate the intellectual property without paying royalty , then obviusly you are liable to face legal proceedings involved whatsover .
And the last no body can make a movie without permission , whose permission is there a copyright involved ? no there's not

So go get a life , and Watch Shourya ....is a must watch .

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 12:07 AM
THERES A COPYRIGHT INVOLVED.EVEN IF YOU ARE MAKING A MOVIE FROM A LITERARY ADAPTATION,THERES COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY INVOLVED.WHICH SHAURIYA DIDNOT OBTAIN FROM A FEW GOOD MEN.AND LINUX IS OPEN SOURCE,SO UBUNTU COULD MAKE LINUX.THATS THE VERYPOINT I AM MAKING.THE COPYRIGHT TO INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IS COSIDERED THE UNIQUE PROPERTY OF THE PERSON FOR UPTO 100 YRS.

AND THIS IS CLEARLY MOVING AWAY FROM THE POINT.I BELIEVE YOU ACCEPT THAT SHAURYA IS AT THE LEAST,INSPIRED BY,A FEW GOOD MEN.THEN WHY CAN'T THE DIRECTOR JUST MENTION THAT IN THE CREDITS OF THE FILM.THERE ARE SO MANY HOLLYWOOD REMAKES OF JAPANESE,KOREAN AND SOMETIMES OLD ENGLISH MOVIES.BUT THEY ALWAYS MENTION IT.GO TO IMDB AND CHECK OUT THE LIST OF FILMS FROM WHICH QUENTIN TARANTINO COPIED SOME OF HIS SCENES.BUT NOBODY SAYS ANYTHING ABOUT HIM BECAUSE HE OBTAINS THE RIGHTS AND MENTIONS THEM IN THE CREDITS.WHY CANT BOLLYWOOD DIRECTORS JUST SAY THAT THEY ARE REMAKING A FILM.WHY DO THEY HAVE TO CLAIM THEM TO BE ORIGINAL.YOU,BEING EDUCATED,SHOULD REALISE THAT WE ARE BEING CHEATED.ALSO,IT HURTS AS AN INDIAN WHEN OTHER PEOPLE SAY THAT WE STEAL.

Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Five Stars , A Must Watch
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 06, 2008 12:11 AM
WHAT I WANT TO SAY THAT BOLLYWOD MOVIES SHOULD PAY THE ROYALTY,MENTION IN THE CREDITS THE MOVIE THEY ARE REMAKING AND THAN THEY ARE FREE TO DO WHATEVER THEY WANT.

Forward   |   Report abuse
partha ghatak
UNFAIR CRITICISM
by partha ghatak on Apr 05, 2008 08:09 PM  | Hide replies

i don't know why u need to compare the two movies continuously mr sen. u meantioned the facts once that the movie has been lifted -that should be enough- i do not know why samar khan and his crew has the responsibility to live up to few good men. why should he care whether u have seen the english movie or not? its not as if its sholay. a few good men is one of my favourite all time movies and i'm gald at least saamr chose a good story. by the way - i hope the ''knowledgeable'' people who are supporting raja sen know that ''a few good men'' was originally a hugely successful play before it was made into a movie and that a lot of dialogues are from that play. but i have seen no one in usa criticize and cry that -oh why did u use a play -why -why why.there can be two kinds of screenplays -adapted and original. so samar khan chose to adapt -big deal.judge him on his product man - not comparisons with rob reiner's film.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:RE:UNFAIR CRITICISM
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 08:27 PM
because they got the rights for the play,but shaurya didnt.it doesnt even say that its inspired from a few good men.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
lancer
guys
by lancer on Apr 05, 2008 07:37 PM

Guys the movie is pathetic, it potrays hindus as villians n glorifying a muslim soldier,military justice is evenhanded in delivering injustice without the prejudice of the religion. we have seen many cases till now but the flim potrays as if a muslim is victimised.good movie for the psudoseculars.

jai hind

    Forward  |  Report abuse
hemant srivastava
army belief
by hemant srivastava on Apr 05, 2008 05:09 PM

this is total area of understanding. we know that our millitry is one of the grand number all over the world.
army belives about the truth and sacrifice for the people

    Forward  |  Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
must stop
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 03:52 PM  | Hide replies

if lifting the plot of another movie is not such a bad thing then whydid every one criticize ram gopal verma for remaking sholay.
he atleast said that he was remaking sholay.when it comes to hollywood movies,the directors, taking advantage of the average cinegoers ignorance,claim the movies as original.

much like amir khan will claim with ghajini.only few will know that its a rip off of memento.

he might then also claim to make"different kind of movies".

    Forward  |  Report abuse
partha ghatak
RE:must stop
by partha ghatak on Apr 05, 2008 07:55 PM
gadha abhijeet - i think u never read the papers coz for a long time amir khan is going abt saying its a remake of the south indian movie -and he has paid full money to obtain the rights. since his screenplay is a remake of the south indian movie -and not of memmento - i don't think he has any reason to answer that.i hope u know the difference between story n screenplay when it comes to rip offs. guess ur a shahrukh khan- his movies are sure original -coz no where else in the world are movies as trashy as oso,kank,k3g etc made.

partha

   Forward   |   Report abuse
abhijit bhattacharyya
RE:must stop
by abhijit bhattacharyya on Apr 05, 2008 09:07 PM
let me ask you something.do you know partner has lost the copy right case for lifting hitch.but they were not the same screenplays,right?they were hugely different.yet it lost the case.likewise,memento can still slap a case against amir khans ghajini.and i am not a shahrukh fan, not after he says that hollywood movies are all style and no substance...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
baarud
RE:must stop
by baarud on Apr 05, 2008 08:27 PM
Hey partha! Why u drag shahruh khan here! It is between u and abhijeet!! Bechara sharukh is lashed out by "critiques" in every single hindi movie related article!!! Spare him this time!



   Forward   |   Report abuse
asder cryuio
code red for samar khan
by asder cryuio on Apr 05, 2008 03:41 PM

this is one of the worst bollywood copy of a hollywood movie ever.a few good men was briliant movie with a tight script and good acting.the only reason tom cruise won't go to bad actors hell is because of his performance in a few good men.and samar khan had to go and cheapen this story to the level of hindu muslim rivalry.only someone who has never seen a few good men will consider this a super movie.go and watch the original and forget this one.

p.s: if you dont understand the subject of this post then u truly havent seen a few good men.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
shorya is very good movie
by on Apr 05, 2008 02:42 PM  | Hide replies

Though its not original still it is fantastic movie. the questions raise in this movie are brilliant. plz watch it

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Sagar Raghavan
RE:shorya is very good movie
by Sagar Raghavan on Apr 05, 2008 05:26 PM
I agree with you, as we need to watch good movies. We need to have showcase what is happening in the country even if we have to lift the story form somewhere else. The army are at fault at some places

   Forward   |   Report abuse
harsh joshi
for which movie is this review?
by harsh joshi on Apr 05, 2008 01:41 PM  | Hide replies

this review is for shurya aur for few good men?
why cant he keep emotions in control and wright what he is suppose to......dear mr Raja sen please stik to one movie at one time...

    Forward  |  Report abuse
RE:for which movie is this review?
by on Apr 05, 2008 01:46 PM
HE HAS TO COMPARE THE TWO,SINCE SHAURIYA IS NOT ORIGINALBUT A RIP-OFF OF THE HOOLY WOOD MOVIE MADE WITH LITTLE CHANGES.BUT THESE CAHNGES DID NOT MAKE THE MOVIE BETTER,IT MADE IT WORSE.SO THE COMPARISON.HE IS BANG ON.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 211 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >   >>
Write a message