I Hate this Guy Himesh, But I Also Hate this Show Saregamapa, It is Supposed to be Reality Show, Bull Shit, It is Nothing But Promotional Show For Idiotic Movies Like OSO, Dus Kahanniya Etc.
First of All, Almost All Singers were Mediocre Except Poonam, Who had ComeUp with Hard Work.The Singers Like Mauli and Sumedha Were Pure Glamour Items.Aneek Even thogh Mediocre was the Best Singer Among All Singers.
The Biggest Joke and Idiotic Episode was when the Cast of Dus Kahanniya(All Flop Actors) Had Come to Promote their Movie, They were Foolishly Praising The Singers.
RE:Himesh Is the Best in Saregamapa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Mark roy on Oct 17, 2007 02:50 AM
Well....this is not Maxx but a Hindu Speakingg...its only people like you Max who brings religion, cast etcc...every one knows Amanat Ali from Pak sang really well...but u crazy lil brain dont understand anything.....and u r calling Dus kahanniyan stars are flopp...u r sayin Sanjat gupta is flopp who made Kaantee...u must be a crazyy guyy big loser.....and yeahh you all will see...who do u seee in future in bollywood from Saregama contestant
RE:Himesh Is the Best in Saregamapa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Maxxx on Oct 17, 2007 02:58 AM
Yes I am Hindu, But I am Indian First then Hindu Next, I Said I Hate Himesh, BCoz He Used All Promotional Strategy For Movies to Get TRP's and His Own Publicity, As For Sanjay Gupta's Kaante, Its a Cut Copy Paste of Reservoir Dogs, If U Know Hollywood Movies The U Will UnderStand Better.
RE:Himesh Is the Best in Saregamapa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 17, 2007 03:13 AM
Good points, Maxxx. This was a singing contest where audience get to vote. People are just too emotionally involved in this like this was a real world cup. Zee succeeded in marketing and making good money off these fanatics
Himesh keeps talking abt giving "roti" and "kapda" to all his contestants. If he doesnt watch out for himself, he's the one who'll be running around without clothes and eating cow-dung on the road in a few years
I Hate this Guy Himesh, But U Have to Accept, This Idiotic Dumbo Show Bcame Hit Only Bcoz of HR.
First of All Congrats To Aneek, Though Mediocre He Was the Best Singer Among All Contestants.
Raja Was Just Copying the Likes of Sukhwinder Singh and Kailesh Kher, He Cannot Even Bcome a Cover Version Singer.
Personally All Paki Singers Must Be thrown Out of Country, Bcoz DO Pakistan Allow Indian Talented Singers To Come and Perform in Pakistan.Taali Ek Haath Se Nahi Bajti, Taali Do Haath Se Bajti Hai.
We Know Wat Happened to Qazi Taukir, Roop Rekha, Amit Sana, Vineet and Debojit, They Are Not Even Singing Even One Song
Same Will Be the Case with Aneek, Raja and Ammanat.
RE:RE:RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Soumyajit Mukherjee on Oct 17, 2007 12:34 AM
Would love to hear you sing if you consider Aneek, Amanat and Raja to be mediore...!!!
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Maxxx on Oct 17, 2007 12:38 AM
Wat About Qazi Taukir,Amit Sana, Roop Rekha, Vineet and Debojit are Seeing or Hearing them in Any Music Albums or Films.
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by nodeax on Oct 17, 2007 12:38 AM
Its not necessary for anyone here to be able to sing in order to judge other peoples singing... when sachin plays a bad shot and gets out anyone can tell that... u dont have to be a player like sachin to know....
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Soumyajit Mukherjee on Oct 17, 2007 12:50 AM
Dont mean to hurt anybodys sentiments but I believe, Aneek, Amanat and Raja are truly good singers and should get opportunities. They are way better than 2005 contestants. We will hear a lot from the next 3 in the future....obviously they have to get over with HR and ID kind of politics
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Maxxx on Oct 17, 2007 12:56 AM
The ASame Thing was Said About Debojit and Vineet, Vineet was Called Better than Sonu Nigam, Where is he Now.
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Nimra on Oct 17, 2007 02:11 AM
Why pakistani singers be thrown out?? Did they force themselves on Zee TV?? Why would pakistan invite indian contestants. Did pakistan brag to be a secular country? Did pakistan brag to be organizing a world cup singing contest?? Having said all that Shame on India and Zee Tv one crore times. You called sa re ga ma a world contest and yet votes from india were given importance. Pakistan was not even allowed to do SMS. hahha. Zee Tv farted big time! In the end india should stop copying american shows because indians are not civilize Americans. Indians vote according to regional, religious and ethnicity grounds. Zee Tv invited Amanat to boil hindu blood so they can vote crazily. Amanat won internationally because indians and other south asians living in west are changed people now. They have been exposed to racism , discrimination and have educated themesleves. But to put a show in india on American style voting is a mockery. Amanat is the ebst singer by all means.
RE:RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 17, 2007 03:16 AM
A Paki Muslim advocating fair play, civlized behavior, and equality! What a joke!
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by getyourfacts on Oct 17, 2007 02:25 AM
I am an Indian and a Hindu but I agree with Nirma.India needs to vote based on talent and not based on Caste,Everytime I see Bengali's(Most of them..not all) fighting and voting for Bengali candidates...
RE:RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Maxxx on Oct 17, 2007 02:34 AM
U Seem To Say Ur Pakistan is a Secular Country, It is the Most Moronic Dictatorship Country inthe World.U People r Morons Who Cannot Even Bring Democracy, First Solve the Problems About Ur Country and then Comment About India.
If Hindus Did Not Vote, Amaaanat Would Have been Out in First Round, He Came Upto Finals, That Tells that Hindus Voted in favour of Amaanat.
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Nimra on Oct 17, 2007 12:07 PM
maxx, you seem to be a retard!!! Who said I was a paki or a muslim??? Who said pakistan was a secular country. Actually they call their country Islamic republic shit of something. Amanat never got votes from india. Zee kept him for two reasons: 1) to boil hindu blood and instigate patriotism. 2) Only donkiest of donkeys could kick him out because he is way to good and far more seasoned than that haji ali begger voiced raja and sonu nigam sister-aneek.
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by deepak on Oct 17, 2007 04:26 PM
Actually the retard par excellence is you Nimra..you are the one whose clearly the Islam freak and the ghaddar who dont even recognize Indian greatness in inviting these Paki singers...did u see how ordinary Indians were offering puja for Amanat?? well well no one expects you to find goodness in Indians...no Pakistan is not secular far from it..its a country where fatwas are issued against the arts, where little girls are locked up in Laal Masjid and provoked to commit suicide...Good going Nimra ! and btw didnt your illustrious army kill 3 million fellow citizens in E Pakistan..remember????
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by Mark roy on Oct 17, 2007 02:52 AM
You will see Amanat in bollywood sooon ....cuz he sings all kind of song..You will seeeee....Aneeq cant replce Sonu, shaan, Kunal, KK.....
RE:Saregamapa Was SuperHit Bcoz of Himesh
by swati girdhani on Oct 17, 2007 06:51 AM
Well Pakistani singers sure did do well in the show. but lets be realistic guys, you can't expect them to win. I followed the show pretty keenly and would admit that all the three finalist were good. One marninally better than the other depending on the listener. So obviouslly Amanat wasn't better than either of the Indians by leaps and bounds. But mind you we still supported him. He came in top 3 bcoz of Indian voting. And regarding the secular issue, just a teeny meeny fact Raja is also a muslim, but gained the highest votes in India. By secular we mean that all Indians are equal irrespective of there religious background. But definetely Pakistani can't expect the same favour. I'm 200% sure that if a hindu pakistani(some do exist) and an indian muslim would have participated in a show in pakistan , the ppl there would have still supported the hindu pakistani. Because nationality is one thing and religion another. india is secular belive me, we might not be perfect but i'm pretty sure you guys with your despisible behaviour should be the last one pointing fingers.
Himesh constant ranting of the love triangle is embarrassing at the least. what the heck??? these are 1-20 year old boys & girls who the parents have put up for a singing contest, not a stupid romantic soap opera !! Sa Re Ga Ma Pa is a great show but in the future please do not strut these young girls as sex symbols in skimpy clothes and keep their romantic interests if any private. And dont bring Himesh with his Uparwala in the show.
RE:Himesh a bore !!
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 17, 2007 03:25 AM
It was all done with the agreement of all contestants and their parents involved. Parents have to be involved because India is still a backward nation. Folks, don't take it so seriously
Himmesh R sucks!! He should have thrown out of SAREGAMAPA long back. Because of his lousy behavior, Asha Bhonsle had left SAREGAMA. Once I really liked his music, remember Tere Naam of Salman Khan. But now, I hate this guy. I have never seen such an arrogant, lousy, loud music director. What does he think; he is a legendary music director? Forget about it. He is no where near to Laxmikant-Pyarelal, Kalyanji-Anandji, Naushad, SD & RD Burman, and OP Nayyar. He is even no match with AR Rahman and Vishal-Shekhar. I respect Vishal-Shekar alot. Such a wonderful, well-mannered pair of music directors! I loved Ismail Darbar for Hum Dil De Chuke and Bappida is astonishing and unbeaten since 1980s for his disco beats.
RE:I hate Himmesh R
by nodeax on Oct 17, 2007 10:38 AM
all the above messages which are reported as abuse are mine.... sometimes these moderators are too much... their delicate ears cant take the harsh truth
With HR's tactics, I felt that Aneek would loose out on winning SaReGaMaPa. Aneek was undoutedly the most versatile and consistant singer and never had a bad day on stage. I really wish he belonged to Vishal-Shekhar than to HR. ID appears to be out of work....heard of any movies with ID as a music director in the recent past...? He wanted to make use of Amanat's success for his own profit, which did not happen and so he comes out with cheap comments about the show
Lets hold the spirit of SaReGaMaPa alive and pray that these two rotten mentors dont appear in this show again
Whoever you are, Mahesh...Just adore the article you have written...
last year...when one of the contestents sang the song...."sun zara soneye sun zara" from movie "lucky". everyone said that "first of all they dont like the song and the music is the worst. and also said that they dont know who the hell has composed it.
"it was composed by Adnan Sami"
this year....when adnan sami was here himesh reshamiya said countless praising words for adnan...
Mahesh has written the perfect article. I was happy to read as it was exactly the way I felt. Anyone who watched Sa Re Ga ma will srely agree with Mahesh. Great job, Mahesh!
RE:Perfect
by vishal n on Oct 16, 2007 11:10 PM
I have emailed Zee TV to not throw HR out of the Next SaReGaMa. i would suggest everyone shoueld do the same.
RE:RE:Perfect
by vishal n on Oct 16, 2007 11:11 PM
Correction !!! .I have emailed Zee TV to THROW HR out of the Next SaReGaMa. i would suggest everyone should do the same.
RE:Perfect
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 16, 2007 11:21 PM
I would rather have Ismail Darbar thrown out who bad mouthed the organizers and Zee TV. What a loser this guy, Ismail is!
RE:RE:Perfect
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 16, 2007 11:23 PM
Just imagaine the entertainment value of a show with judges like Ismail, VS etc. Very boring. I definitely watch it for HR. Very curious to hear what he has to say. HR speaks from heart.
RE:Perfect
by shraddha bhosale on Oct 16, 2007 11:36 PM
Yes, Mahesh has written the best article. I am feeling so bad for Raja who deserved tp be winner, but with HR's marketing strategies for Aanik, he lost. We hate you HR ... we will never see ur movie nor listen to ur songs, as u cant sing ...just shouting loudly cant prove ur point. ppl here are not dumb ..
RE:Perfect
by Soumyajit Mukherjee on Oct 16, 2007 11:58 PM
With HR's tactics, I felt that Aneek would loose out on winning SaReGaMaPa. Aneek was undoutedly the most versatile and consistant singer and never had a bad day on stage. I really wish he belonged to Vishal-Shekhar than to HR. ID appears to be out of work....heard of any movies with ID as a music director in the recent past...? He wanted to make use of Amanat's success for his own profit, which did not happen and so he comes out with cheap comments about the show
Lets hold the spirit of SaReGaMaPa alive and pray that these two rotten mentors dont appear in this show again
Himesh has his shortcomings. With age comes experience.So lets give him the benefit of the doubt.I believe he will correct himself as he gains more experience in public forums. As a singer he is fabulous.
Now I have to seriously consider cancelling my subscription to this magazine whose publisher bad mouths an entertainer by engaging in personal attacks. Shame on Peri. What a childish guy this publisher is.
RE:Outlook
by Amol Joshi on Oct 16, 2007 11:00 PM
HR is one of the biggest FOOOL in this industry... its insult to the word entertainment if is associated with HR. It was pathetic watching and hearing a single word out of this stupid guy...He is one of the biggest a**h*le I have seen in recent times... come what may but HR is the synonym for "a looser".
RE:Outlook
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 16, 2007 11:19 PM
Ok, but it is very unprofessional and uncalled for a respected publisher to engage in personal attacks on a public figure. I can understand not liking a performer but there is no need to attack his family, lifestyle etc.
RE:Outlook
by Ram Chauthariya on Oct 16, 2007 11:28 PM
"propoganda". What the heck are you talking about? He is an entertainer and I think he does a great job in that. The other judges say 2 or 3 lines and give marks. HR speaks and entertains.
RE:Outlook
by Partha Choudhury on Oct 16, 2007 11:38 PM
"HR speaks and entertains" - what he does is called incessant blabbering - it's all about him and half the time in that program is wasted because of that clown! He is partial, he is political and he hinders the spirit of art! If you call his presence entertainment, then I'd suggest you start a seperate talk show with him and spare SaReGaMaPa.
