everythin hes written is probably all true...bt then its so sad... that wateva tactics he played n strategies he did.. all was wrth it...cs in teh end aneek won... n raja didnt... althgh vishal n shekhar were the best mentors...i cnt believe ppl acually listen 2 ppl like hr. m nt sayin aneek is bad..hes good... bt i loved raja n then amanta 2... mm..anyawys audience pollin shld stop i guess..thats wt ahppened in indion idol too.. amit was a mch better singer bt he didnt win.
I Personally Dont Like All these Reality Shows Like Saregamapa, Which I Believe all Money Making Shows.I dont Like Himesh Reshammiya Either, But the Biggest Clown in all The Judges is Ismail Durbar.He is a Total Moron, If He thinks That Amaanat is a Better Singer than Aneek, Then He is Complete Moron, If Amanaat Did Not Get Votes Bcoz He is From Pakistan Then He would Have Been Thrown Out in the First Round itself.Amaanat is Just Another Sufi Singer From pakistan, All these Paki's Must Be Kicked out from India, Coz We Have lot of Talent in India.
I Personally dont like Himesh Reshammiya, I dont think He can Influence The People to Vote.He is Another Idiot in this Music Industry.The Duo Vishal And Shekhar Look Totally Fake in their Judgement of Singers.
Raja is a Total Sadak Chaap Singer, He Imitates Sukhwinder Singh and Kailesh Kher With Bad Voice Quality, Whenever he Sings It Looks Like He has a Bad Throat.
Although He is Mediocre in Talent, Aneek Was A Better Singer than All COntestants.
RE:Ismail Clown Darbar
by Bon Jovi on Oct 16, 2007 08:42 PM
amanat musarat and junaid had talent thats y they wwere there! otherwise if india have talent it should bring it up!starting from nazia hasan, nusrat, rahat, shaqat amanat, adnan sami, ghulam ali, sabri bros have mesmerised music lovers on bboth sides of the border due to thir talent. not coz of their nationality! What a pathetic way of writing that we dont want pakistani singers! shows what mehtal class u r! Accpet the fact music has no boubndaries it unites! and the results of this finals must have been through JUDGES and not popular votes! as regional bias came in!if they had allowed pakistan votes amanat would have won big guns! if it was WC of music Zee should have allowed all the votes!then it would have been impartial! and if aneek had won then!no body wud have questioned the credibility of the show!time will tell who perishes and who survives! It was a good a show, aneek won good enough! just dont bring in reginalism religion!!
RE:Ismail Clown Darbar
by Maxxx on Oct 16, 2007 09:27 PM
U Jerk Why Cant Paki's Invite BheemSen Joshi, Pandit RaviShankar, Amman And Ayaan Ali Bhangaas to Pakistan and tell Them To Perform, Why Should India Always Call These Paki's Jerks, Where is Equality in pPakistan, Why Dont they Invite Indian Singers, Dont See Only One Side of Coin, Coz U Belong to Certain Community, See the Entirwe Thing, Taali Ek Haath Se Nahi Bajti, Dono Haath Se Bajti Hai, WHen Did Indian Singers ZGo and Perform in Pakistan, Tell Me , I am Not Saying Eastablished Singers, But Fresh Singers.
RE:Ismail Clown Darbar
by Bon Jovi on Oct 17, 2007 04:38 AM
sobasically u want to do what pakistan is doing right? LOL it means ur democratic loosers they are democratic dictators!
Ismail Durbar.. what has he done beyond HDDCS zillion years back and Devdas one thousand years back.
The whole article looks more like one of the pieces writtent to bolster the b u l l s h i t OSO coming up till now. As for Himesh hiding his wife and daughter, what better has Ismail Gaddar done ?
RE:Ha Ha
by Bon Jovi on Oct 16, 2007 08:20 PM
gaddar? LOL whats gaddari he did? just because he was a mentor of a pakistani? HR was the mentor of mussarat where eh did gaddari with him and had him eliminated! thats called gaddari having someone under ur feathers and then leaving them on the road side1
I totally agree with the writer and have lot of respect for such Indians who speak their mind and conscience. Well done and I hope none of the Indian channels bring HR on the forum in future. To be honest being a music listener I never was carried by HR voice at all. I sometimes think where on earth did Salman Khan bring this crappy guy. I agree with what Asha Bhonsle had said about him. Thanks buddy for commenting so beautifully.
Hi all, Although I know, that it's a thing of past now, but you know that you have to learn something from the past. I completely agree with the author. I was a continuous viewer of SaReGaMaPa 2007 from the 1st episode itself. I have all the episodes with me. From the day 1, I started hating Himesh as he will simply take out the mike from all others even if he doesn't have to say a single word(You can see this thing in any episode, whenever he is there in stage). He'll wait for someone to talk and then BAMMMM, he starts his lengthy and loudy nose-singing. Till the other person doesn't quit, he will keep on shouting.
As soon as Aneek came in the show, he started his shouting more loudly. Then one day it happened. He told that Aneek is in love with Diya Mirza (Remember, he asked Aneek, 'tumhe diyaji se kuchh kahna hai?' ). Thus he started his politics to give him more n more votes from girls. After Diya, he linked up Aneek with Sumedha (the most suitable female playback singer). Even he made Amaanat come to the triangle. Though, Ismail darbar never started this issue, he was also enjoying this unnecessary show. But, later Ismail cleared it in one show that all this was just a drama. Still HR kept his nuances running. After that, one day the beauty Goddess came to the show. Yes, I am talking about Deepika Padukone. That day, when Amaanat sang and Deepika came to stage. Himesh reminded(?) Amaanat that he is linked up with a girl (Sumedha, who was already voted out) and
RE:Completely agree
by sumitraj singh negi on Oct 16, 2007 06:11 PM
......and he doesn't need to have an eye over Deepika. Then the bubbly boy(Aneek) came and sang. After that again Himesh played his politics. he asked Aneek unnecesarilly, " Aneek, ye gana tumne mere liye gaya hai ya kisi aur ke liye?" Poor chap Aneek, he has had to do,what his mentor was asking him to do. Now, again the girls voted more n more for Aneek.
Next episode, SaReGaMaPa saw 22 actors and actresses in the stage. Again, in the end of the show, HR made all the beauties to stand with Aneek while it was truly a day for Amaanat (Tujhse naraaj nahi) n Raja (Sapne me milti hai). also, he made Aneek to give statement that "Mardon ki votes nahi chahiye, Aurton ki votes chahiye".
Now, comes up the Big day. HR told the public first that Aneek is younger brother of elder brother RAJA and asked Aneek to touch feet of Raja. The whole crowd was cheering up for Raja. Now, HR fired a silly question to the public that,"agar chhota bhai aur bada bhai aapas me lade, to jeet kiski honi chahiye?" Obviously from heart everybody would have answered this in favour of Chhota bhai. But, the public choosed to remain silent instead of giving the answer. Himesh got the public mood, so suddenly he changed his tone and told, "Bade bhai ki hi honi chahiye na".Now, the biggest fault of SAREGAMAPA happened. Aditya told that rest of the world has voted more than 3 crores. Then he told India has voted more than 10 crores. In this way, the total votes would have been more than 14 crores. Phoooshhh
RE:RE:Completely agree
by sumitraj singh negi on Oct 16, 2007 06:11 PM
Phoooshhhh...... Then he told that out of the total 10 crores votes (?) , the winner is........ And there was no cheer-up, the whole crowd got silent. The only people dancing there were, Himesh, Aneek and his parents.
How, we can forget that unnecessarily he showed the way out to Mussarrat by making him sing 'Signal, pyar ka signal' in the comedy song competition. How he forced Mussarrat to make Bobby deol his favourite actor just so that he could sing ' Koi jane, koi na jane'. And when musarrat was out, he simply blamed it on Raja and told him that 'Raja should feel guilty, Raja should be ashamed of himself ' and so on. How can a person insult another and that also in the wake of songs they have sung last week. Why he was so jealous of Raja? Don't know the answer? Check for the songs sung by Raja, Amaanat and Aneek.
For me, the result would have become of a more value if it was like ---- Amaanat/Raja (No.1/2) and Aneek (No.3).
I agree to it....It's Himesh who made Poonam loose her self confidence when she was performing so well.If she reached there it's not coz her modesty was the topic of discussion but coz she had a talent .I wish Aneek , Amanat & Raja the best and so do I do for Poonam who is a good singer and I just hope her talent let her reach heights which she deserves.
I know that most of the shoot to fame charaters do behave the way Himesh is behaving, He is not only a shame full character but a snob. Aboundance of wealth has created an ediot that will be difficult to disloge so soon.
Absolutely true... after reading this article i dont have anything more to say about it. next time atleast pls do not let the mentors talk about abything but the performance and the singing of the contestants and let the public vote based on this and not anything else. The public should not be distracted from the very basic concept of the contest. Gr8 article...
I agree with the writer about HR hiding his poor quality of singing behind heavy music. In fact he should have stuck to being a music director only...I am sure he is liked by a large number of people.....but that does not necessarily make him a good human being. He always comes across as spoilt brat angling only for publicity and trying to make the loudest sound byte. He is a typical upstart who knows that he only has to blow his trumpet the loudest...because anyone else with ears for good soulful music is surely never going to do that for him.
