Oh, how much I wanted to vote HR out of this contest!! HR is pure evil, and will go to any extent for cheap publicity. He lives by the word controversy. He always wants to be in controversy. May be all this we are talking about him, he is sitting somewhere and laughing at us, because there is nothing called 'bad publicity', right? Also, HR owes all his success to SRGMP btw! Remember of the beginning of SRGMP2005 and end of it - and the transformation of HR from a noname music director to 'self proclaimed' rock star, who performs at huge basketball stadiums in USA?? What crap? I think if not anyone else, Vishal is the 'real' rocker (Pentagram, anyone?) of all these guys, and he didn't impose that even a single day!!
RE:Can public vote the judges out ..?
by omni on Oct 18, 2007 02:32 PM
Even ID should be thrown out another useless fellow. Only VS and Bappi Da were okay.
RE:Can public vote the judges out ..?
by Selvam on Oct 22, 2007 03:07 PM
You are right. Ismail was somewhat better in the earlier season. Ismail seems that he is supporting dog natured Himesh. Everybody should condemn his attitude and eccentric behaviour.
he don't need u for ur f* opinions. compare sonu singing with emon and sonu sucks. compare HR with aneek or any participant and listen to ur bappida. u knows. u can't ignore fact that how many hits he gave in short time. even u were dancing on those songs. isn't it? compare music of vishal/shekar's CASH with any of HRs. u knows. but u still hate him bcs... only u know y. no Indian can digest success of fellow Indian not only in India but in abroad too. try singing his songs from nose. ur ass will make more noise than ur nose. this is how much u know abt music. u knows. a muslim in Pak will call mulim in Palastine - brother. they are adding to their community. forget abt cause for time being. but u will hate ur own ppl calling gujju / south Indian / paji / bhaiya / whatever. i have also heard dravidian v/s aryan now a days. u will draw a line whereever u can. u knows. critic is a person who knows the way but can't drive. u knows. but still.....
RE:HR - HeRo
by nrm on Oct 18, 2007 12:40 PM
u idiot, dont have knowledge on music.Those who are saying that Hamesha Besharamiyya is a good singer, then I am running short of word how I ll scold them.are u a ass seller,broker.Atleast u dont compare Vishal/shekhar, sonuNigam with this proudy,egoistic,nonsense Hamesha Besharamiya.Go and study the magazines and all to get more information aout them.
RE:HR - HeRo
by Shashi Shekhar on Oct 18, 2007 02:33 PM
Himesh is a great singer and great person. The author of this article and rediff is trying to make some talk by going against the river tides. Himesh is the choice of mass not class.
RE:HR - HeRo
by jatin kapoor on Oct 18, 2007 10:26 PM
Himesh doesn't know "S" of singing....I don't know how he is still sustaining....and our crazy population has made his utterly bakwas movie a hit.Whenever i see this,I think not only Himesh,Indian people have also gone mad. remember of him singing "apne toh apne hote hain" after Aneek sang it....you can feel the difference in voice between Aneek and Himesh... A man who doesn't respect his family shouldnot expect respect in return from anyone...LOSER!!!!!
I personally feel that it doenst matter who won in the end!! The judges and many more composers who were also invited as special guests from time to time know when they see talent...and they r not going to go by who won Challenge 2007...if they have a song that Raja or Amanat can do justice to, whats to stop them from signing them on?
That said, I completely agree, that although Aneek is a genuinely good singer, unfortunately for him, his talent has been too over-shadowed becoz of Himesh's gimmicks...so much so that people hold Aneek's wiinig against him...give the kid a beak!! he sang well, one of them had to win, he won...nobody else lost either...they hav all won one way or the other...
Himesh really needs a full-time course on Personality development and etiquette...it was pathetic the way he kept on talking and talking away not giving the announcer the chance to declare the First runner-up...we all know it was Raja, but still it needs to be announced right?
Himesh also needs a psychiatric evaluation...his insecurities are so glaring, its pathetic...pls bear in mind, i am not demeaning him as a composer...he must just stick to his job...that of composing...
And lastly, Sa Re Ga Ma Pa has always been a talent hunt show, a musical show and I urge and implore that the producers stick to that and tell the Judge(s)(HIMESH) to stick to that...puhleeez we really dont want to know who is in love with whom, do we? Its not a filmy magazine...its a musical show...c'mon
I personally feel that it doenst matter who won in the end!! The judges and many more composers who were also invited as special guests from time to time know when they see talent...and they r not going to go by who won Challenge 2007...if they have a song that Raja or Amanat can do justice to, whats to stop them from signing them on?
That said, I completely agree, that although Aneek is a genuinely good singer, unfortunately for him, his talent has been too over-shadowed becoz of Himesh's gimmicks...so much so that people hold Aneek's wiinig against him...give the kid a beak!! he sang well, one of them had to win, he won...nobody else lost either...they hav all won one way or the other...
Himesh really needs a full-time course on Personality development and etiquette...it was pathetic the way he kept on talking and talking away not giving the announcer the chance to declare the First runner-up...we all know it was Raja, but still it needs to be announced right?
Himesh also needs a psychiatric evaluation...his insecurities are so glaring, its pathetic...pls bear in mind, i am not demeaning him as a composer...he must just stick to his job...that of composing...
And lastly, Sa Re Ga Ma Pa has always been a talent hunt show, a musical show and I urge and implore that the producers stick to that and tell the Judge(s)(HIMESH) to stick to that...puhleeez we really dont want to know who is in love with whom, do we? Its not a filmy magazine...its a musical show...c'mon
i think you didn't listen to amanat. he is more versatile andoriginal.aneek and raja are wonderful singers but lack originality. when sonu nigam is around the industry may not need aneek. when sukhvinder is around we may not need raja also. but, did you see big shadow of any of the singers in amanat's voice. i couldn't. thats what music lovers want. original voice.
RE:aneek deserving?
by omni on Oct 18, 2007 02:36 PM
Aneek was voted by millions to win. If a few people think Amanat is better doesn't mean anything. Aneek was the best singer much much better than other 2. His songs Tuhitu, sandese, tumko paya, Ya Ali, etc etc were too good to be matched by Amanat. Even Taja got better and better. Amanat deserved only 3rd place
RE:himesh
by dimple kotak on Oct 18, 2007 06:16 AM
I truly agree abt Himesh. but dnt b too judgemental abt gujju crowd. Vishal (from vishal-shekhar duo)Anil ambani, mukesh ambani all are well educated, english & hindi savvy. I m very very sure tht even u can come up wth gujju success. One himesh is fool tht dsnt mean all gujju's are fool.
Nothing personal but I wanted to make my view clear.
Why do they resort to fake singing in Live performances. Sa Re Ga Ma Pa claims that millions all over watched them live, singing away to glory on Grand FInale (including Akshay Kumar belting out one of his latest hits, oh, c'mmon, gimme a break!). Check on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyigOkTfHx4
When he gave the music for Tere naam and after that numbers of hit music to movies I really liked his spirit and dedication towards his work but after that when he sing some of the songs it was ok but after that he started irritating by singing his every song this s-u-c-k-s. He started making a love triangle for Sumedha with two guys, this was a complete shit, if instead of Sumedha if it would have been his sister did he would have do this? He is sick, need rehab.
RE:HR good composer
by Om on Oct 18, 2007 12:31 AM
Rediff waalon ne pehle hi likh diya ye mahesh ke personal views hein, phut gayi rediff ki, ki himesh baawla shirt utaar ke na aa jaaye, phir bolega Jai Mata ki lets Rock, abe is b-h-u-tn-i ke himesh ko bolo theele, abe shirt to aise khool ke ghumta hai jaise Sylvester Stallone ka chela hai, dhukun ko bolo abe button bund kur le thund lug jaayegi, saala iski hurkutein dekh ke saregama hi dhekna bund kur diya kai logon ne. Ulti aati hai ise dekh ke, c-h-u-t-i-a
