I agree with all the people except Roy Thomas. When compared among the three finalists Aneek has sung songs which were originally sung by Sonu Nigam (mostly). While Raja has sung songs by Sukhvinder Singh, Kailash Kher, Udit Narayan,A R Rehman. Whereas Amanat can sing songs originally sung by Sonu Nigam, Shaan, Sukhvinder Singh, K K, Udit Narayan, Shafqat Amanat Ali and on and on and on..... Now you can tell when compared with these present day singers who is more versatile and who is required in the industry.
RE:Amanat is the Real Winner
by Roy Thomas on Oct 25, 2007 01:41 PM
kavi, I really feel pathetic about your post. Firstly, Aneek's voice is the most conventional voice and can suit any actor in this industry. Raja's voice is un-conventional he looks good only when he sings kailash kher's, rehman's, sukhwinder's songs I would put raja in a category with Mussarrat who is also the master of unconventional voice. The episode where Mussarrat got eliminated there voting was purely biased on nationality feeling as Raja's horrible performance gave him higher votes compared to Mussarrat's excellent performance. Most of the guru's never expected Raja to get thru that but well its all voting game so people did the choice. Now when the same people had chosen Aneek as winner I find there are few people who are not able to digest it. Get a hajmola for yourself guyz... :-p
RE:Amanat is the Real Winner
by Apr on Oct 25, 2007 11:06 AM
you might have heard Aneek singing only Sonu Nigam songs...i heard him singing songs sung by himesh(Apne, shakalaka boom boom)...mohd rafi(bheege raath)...rabbi(Bulla ke jaana)...ya ali, jaane kya chahe mann (zubeen)...pyaar karke(Labh janjhu)..o o jaane jaana (Kamal Khan)...in dino (Soham)...eka chatura (kishore kumar)...so dont comment with your half cooked knowledge..and dont just comment coz you like amanat and you dont like Aneek...idiot
People saying here that Himesh intentionally pulled down raja if thats true then its equally true for vishal-shekhar who most of here have given the certificate of being honest.. Let me ask you guys, when the Om Shanti Om special was on just couple of weeks before the grand finale Raja was given the most successful song "Dard-e-disco" and Amanat was given another Super-hit "Ankhon mein teri" who r still ruling the Charts and does anyone remember which song Aneek was given.??? any answers.?? Now this was the crooked game played by Vishal-Shekar and you know what the public is intelligent infact it was the GREAT Himesh Reshamiya who stood up and voiced his concern against this partiality and the public supported him. So people who are saying that Himesh deliberately tried to pull someone down is absolutely rubbish as if its true this has been same with the opponent guru VISHAL-SHEKHAR they too have been always finding ways to pull down Aneek. At the end of the day only thing that matters is the winner. ANEEK has been declared winner and it was indeed a fair result. People who are saying its not a fair result they actually dont know to play a fair game. Anyways, Himesh Rocks
RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by neha kothari on Oct 24, 2007 02:42 PM
Dear.. What reviewer says is absolutely true. HR is a player.. I watched last contest also and he played a big game where he sang and asked to sing the same and gave first opportunity to a singer who is not from his team and second opportunity to his pupil.. You know what first opponent did mistake the second opponent can correct easily and he has ample time to recall the song.. SO he is like that.. Moreover regarding result, I know that junta selecting singer is always wrong. Its not based on skill but on choice and Calcutta too big than a Jaipur.. Aneek is from Calcutta you know.. But I truely believe if judges judge it would have RAJA for his consistence performance..
RE:RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by Roy Thomas on Oct 24, 2007 06:21 PM
Neha, even if you go by judge's decision Aneek's overall rating has always been much higher than Raja. Raja has done basic mistakes of singing N number of times and the same has been highlighted by Himesh, Ismail Darbar which was seconded by his own guru Vishal-Shekhar, why? because they all have deep knowledge of music. Raja was No.1 rated by the public for past couple of weeks infact so if I go by your concept public alwasy is wrong then when Raja was no.1 in votes then also public was wrong.?? is it.???
RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by maitreyi upadhyay on Oct 24, 2007 07:54 PM
ROY... M A TRAINED SINGER.. N I KNW THAT RAJA IS A V.GOOD SINGER..INFACT ALL SINGERS ARE GOOD.. BT THE FACT WILL REMAIN A FACT THAT ANEEK'S VOICE DOESNT' SUITE ANY HERO'S .. HIS VOICE IS CHILDISH..HE IS A VERY GD SINGER..NO OFFENSE BUT RAJA IS ALSO THE SAME.. BUTTT MY DEAR RAJA IS MESMERIZING.. ANEEKKK KA NEVER COME TO RAJA'S LEVEL.. AND HE HAS ALSO MADE MISTAKES.. AND YEAH...MISTAKES ARE POINTED FOR RAJA AS PPL XPECT A LOT .. ALRYT... MISTAKES OF ANEEK HAV ALSO BEEN POINTED.. PUBLIC IS ALWAYS RONG.. ALWAYSSS... ITS JUS CZ OF INTERNATIONAL VOTING ANEEK GOT UPP..OTHERWISE RAJA IS THEE WINERR... FACE IT! N HIMESH .. HE SUCKS.. GOD DAMN PLAYER..EVERYTIME HE DOES THAT.. LAST TYM ALSO WIT VINIT.. VINIT HIMSLF ADMITTD THAT THERE WAS NO GIRL.. SAME WIT ANEEK.. NO GIRLL.. HE'S A PLAYER A BIG ONE..! N HE DOESN'T NO S OF SINGING.. NTN AT ALL.. A WOLF.. DOING "OOO" ALL THE TIME.. HIS COMMENTS ARE ALWAYS RONG.. MOST OF THE TIMES.. PPL CAN'T SAY ANYTHING CZ THEN THIS BAND BAJA WIL START AGN WHICH DOESN'T STOP.. SHOUTING ALOUD DOESN'T MAKE PPL HEAR HIM.. !!!
RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by Roy Thomas on Oct 25, 2007 01:33 PM
Upadhyay Ji, firstly after going thru your reply I am not at all convinced about you being a trained singer. Aneek's voice may sound childish but this technique is far better than Raja, Aneek's voice will mature within a year time, He is just 19 man just think before what you are gonna post. Even the Opponent guru Vishal-Shekhar repeated this comments that whenever aneek sings its like listening to sonu nigam. I will not be wrong if I say today sonu nigam is No.1 singer in bolly industry. Well I think this is enough to prove that Aneek was the deserving winner and by the way I know one thing JANTA KI AWAAZ MEIN KHUDA KI MARZI HOTI HAI... Himesh and Aneek ROCKS babyyy..... OOOOoooo huzuuurr... tera tera teraa surooooor.... :-p
RE:RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by Apr on Oct 25, 2007 10:58 AM
trained singer? hahaha ...do you mean that all trained singers can be a good judge? Remember how many times Vishal-Shekhar haave commented about Aneek that he should be at a recording studio recording studio....its just that you dont like Aneek it doesnt mean that he is a bad singer...so keep it cool
RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by kavi verma on Oct 24, 2007 11:36 PM
come on man. the song which Vishal-Shekar gave Aneek to sing is a damn good song. If you don't remember it then its your fault. I think you dont have an ear for good music. I think you like to sing with your nose.
RE:HIMESH ROCKS :-)
by Roy Thomas on Oct 25, 2007 01:57 PM
If the music sells in market and if I can make millions from you people I wont mind to sing from nose. I think this is what exactly Himesh thinks too. Ultimately jo bikta hai wohi chalta hai.. :-p
if u r a true music lover,u will come to know that although all 3 r good singers but raja is the most talented & unusal singer.he is a singer who sings to make a relation with god.whenever he sings he make u hold the t.v.& u can't do anything else.so,raja you r a divine singer & really himesh has made u lost the game but u r the real champion & winner.
RE:RAJA PULLED DOWN INTENTIONALLY BY HIMESH
by soniya amin on Oct 25, 2007 11:17 AM
yes u r right till now when i listen that songs which was sung by raja.his face comes infront of me & i can't do anything.u r a champion.three cheers for raja.hip hip hurray.
Himmesh has done some think very awkward 2 say all ages n he was very partial.Aneek was also behaving extraordinary.This decision take by Zee is absolutely wrong.
RE:Saregama pa
by Roy Thomas on Oct 24, 2007 11:57 AM
its the decision of the the people not zee tv since your favorite didnt win so plz dont have this impression that its zee tv's decision.
All Amanat fans too should sign the petition as amanat was also a contender for No.1 Over one million supporters and fans of Raja in India alone belived to have boycotted zee t.v. since the fixed result was declared.Seventy to Eighty percent messages posted on saregama forum and other forums were for Raja. This shows how much support is for Raja. With such big fan following and supporters and voters in Raja's fold, it is unrealistic if anyone else espicially Aneek with so weak support winning saregama. See youtube even the grand finale was not fully live.So the result can never be trusted. RAJA IS THE WINNER AND HE IS THE PEOPLES NO.1 CHOICE. ANEEK CAN BE ONLY ZEE T.V. AND HR'S CHOICE.
RE:Over One thosand five hundred members of Raja Hasan Fans Club from saregama discussion board alone have signed the petition against fixed result by zee t.v.
by on Oct 24, 2007 09:07 PM
Iagree totally with every one and want to be part ofthis pettition against Zee and Himash the creep.
What I can make out of this article is its sounding more of a sort of frustration. Himesh is a star and infact we all made him a star. Its our habit when one rises to the sky we all try to pull him down. Why.? No idea, may be because we are jealous of him/her being there forgettig that we the people give out our hard earned money and buy his music from the market. Sa re ga ma pa was a no.1 TRP only because of the triangle masala added by HR and I think its not fair. As far sumedha's embarrasmet concerned at this level they are stars and they should be ready and aware of such things which will be their part of life so long as they are in limelight. Personally I feel HR has come a long way and fought against all odds and he is undoubtably the most successful composer of bollywood today. HR ROCKS. :-)
I remember very well, when India lost the match against Bangladesh, The SMS mania rocked..and one of them was..."Don't blame Indian team, Blame Indira gandhi who has formed Bangladesh". So, If at all if some one has to be blamed it is Salman, who has got Himesh into the Industry and doing nothing when this creep is creating non-sence. Mr. Salman agar mard hai toh Car bhikariyon pe nahee Himesh pe chadaa aur uski boltee band kar...kam se kam boltee..." I hope u got it.
RE:It is SALMAN'S Mistake !! Indeed...
by Drishya Goyel on Oct 23, 2007 09:15 PM
nice one..funny but i hope it was true..and u know what salman wouldnt have had to go to court for running over himesh..he would have got a national award..lol
