How much money has Farah Khan and her team has paid you to write such a crappy review. You may not have liked it, if your taste is masala movies. But, it is stupid to criticize brilliant direction and cinematography.
It takes words and and only words to criticize any form of art. But it takes lot of hard work, focus dedication and sweat to make one. For every film maker making a film is just like giving a birth to a baby, and criticizing one is just like saying the baby is black, wheatish or ugly or fat. So we should accept every film/baby in its own individuality/identity and should not push over view good or bad on others. As everyone has its own taste to admire, what not appeal to you might do wonders for other. Beauty lies in the eyes of beholder.
RE:Pain goes in making a film
by william collins on Nov 11, 2007 11:18 PM
forgive us for our shallow comments.....we are not able to come up to your esteemable notions of esotoric detachment.....but after all you see we are mere humans,pebbles who if we disturb your lake of complacense are terribly ashamed
I wonder can anything be more boring than it. No clear story line. No tough acting. Heroines weeps and laughs without any reason. Hero remains in a dilemma and still is an over excited champ. Only the character of Rani Mukherjee was well drafted who looked nice. Else all were blowing minds to pieces(that does not mean mind blowing). Worst movie watched by me till date. And that chatriwali heroine was a stupid character who can go with the hero for an adjustment if her boy friend does not return. God forbid how can directors ever expect us to see such a sort of devastating movie!! I wish to get my 220 Rs back which my boy friend spent on Diwali watching this absurd melodrama
RE:Horrible movie
by nalinikanth d on Nov 13, 2007 07:07 AM
So what if heroine wants to get married to someone else if her boy friend doesn't return. Atleast she hasn't planned to have an amorous/extra marital affair, which is the present trend in Bollywood movies
I have not seen the film...but your criticism for the film went on and on....please give me a break.It seems the movie and your criticisms both suck..though i love the songs and because you had to sooooo muccchhh to say about the movie..i think i'll surely go watch it..and i am sure i'll find something positive..hey u critics ..you guys are taking your job too seriously..you all are suppose to just give a point of view ..not go and on ..and don't have to use all the possible adjectives in the dictionary.take it easy.
Please Rediff please i request you please not let any tom dick and harry put their remarks on discussion board many times i find they are hopeless in their understanding of the matter. Or else you should first ready each and every matter before uploading. These headless remarks ruining your image.
As a director Bhansali can make any movie , any theme.. but this over-hyped movie promising lots - turned out to be really miserable... one good movie anyone can miss and feel happy about it ...
Indian audiance is not mature thats why they are critisizing the film and director. but in acytual the film is with great direction and with a unique story. sets are beautiful, music is amazing and new comers are charming with brilliant acting.
Our people can understand only direct jokes... they are not able to see the theme in hidden.
RE:sawaria - a very good film by SLB
by Gautam De on Nov 11, 2007 01:01 PM
You need some real good medicine to improve your brain and mind/ This movie is a piece of junk.
Just like "do billiyon ki ladai and bandefr happy" SRK/FARAH KHAN AND SLB KI Ladai, and we public ka achcha kaata logo ne. In my family there are admirers of Shahrukh and SLB and it's our opinion tht "achcha banaya un logo ne"
WHY DON'T WE TEACH THEM A LESSON???
Guys, after spending 1000 of rupess to watch OSO and Sawaariya, I felt that media along with promters have taken on ride. I BET IF THEY WOULD HAV EBEEN RELEASED SEPERATELY, BOTH WOULD HAVE BEEN SUPER FLOP.
Both Sharukh and SLB fans, apne dil se poocho dono filmein kitni bakwass thi. SLB AND FARHA SHARUKH are laughing on us by minting money Yesterday i gave 100 rsto a begger who was in real need. kaash yeh paise maine kisi achche kaam mein lagye hote. FRom now onwards, i wudn't be carried away by the marketing dept. of any film.
