Why judge a film on the Hindu-Muslim Criteria. It hardly matters if the character is a muslim Hindu or a Christian what should be seen is whether he jusfies the role or not.For me Shahrukh is my hero who is an Indian and who has just delivered a mindblowing performance. ChakDe is a classic which cannot be forgotten for a long time to come. As for the theme, I saw women's Liberation, national integration & a Spirit to win more than anything else. It is a film which unites, a film which takes us above the differences in religion, cast & creed. You remember all the dialogues but why did you forget what Kabir Khan says- Mujhe Kisi bhi State ka Naam nahin sunayee Deta, mujhe sirf ek naam sunayee deta hai, I-N-D-I-A. Try to be an Indian Mr.Sivaswamy.Atleast take inspiration from the movie itself,ChakDe India!
RE:SRK is an Indian First!
by QandA on Aug 13, 2007 07:53 PM
Why not? Why did SRK always played Hindu Characters? Can U imagine a black guy playing a White guys role in the West? What was the necessity of Yusuf Khan to rename a Dilip Kumar?
RE:SRK is an Indian First!
by Ritika on Aug 13, 2007 07:55 PM
I agree with you. India won't be India anymore if all us indians start judging things based on religion.
We are all Indians first and then Hindu, Muslim, Sikh etc. Long live Indian unity!!!
RE:meaning of article
by ziaul hasan on Aug 13, 2007 07:49 PM
i think you are useless and have no right to call yourself human being. buddy firstlearn that it is not the religion by which the man is remembered but it is the saying by which the man is remembered
LOL! And som folks say they don't make good films in Bollywood! That SRK is not a good actor. That RajiniGanth(LOL!) is the best. What impudence! Or is it ignorance? Or naivete? SRK is just stunning. No compare at all! He delivers with energy. he emotes with panache. That is what I called STYLE maan! He does no buffoonery like cigarette tossing, goggle juggling and other cheapo tricks. He is truly King Khan.
I am shocked by this posts. I wonder what is Mr. Saisuresh Sivaswamy's problem? What the hell is he trying to say? He seems to be instigating controversy rather than supporting Unity in India. Guess, its a game plan of Rediff to attract readership by making articles out of such sensitive topics.
I am sure a few of those mentally retarded guys who frequent the rediff discussion boards will soon start a mini-riot with their retarded opinions. God Help India!
Its their country as much as anyone else's. Just unfortunate that the West Vs Islam fight has come to shadow people who share the same religion but are part of the relatvely more humane civilisation in the sub-continent. For all our ills, at least we dont drop an atom bomb, or try to wipe out those who oppose us (and provoke them further, like the Allies did to Germany after WW I). The word Indian Muslim is abhorroent to use. They are Indians and their religion is Muslim just as it would apply to a Hindu, Sikh etc.
